P: ISSN No. 2321-290X RNI No.  UPBIL/2013/55327 VOL.- IX , ISSUE- VI February  - 2022
E: ISSN No. 2349-980X Shrinkhla Ek Shodhparak Vaicharik Patrika
A Study of The Effect of Family Type on Marital Adjustment of Working and Non Working Adults
Paper Id :  15765   Submission Date :  10/02/2022   Acceptance Date :  21/02/2022   Publication Date :  25/02/2022
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
For verification of this paper, please visit on http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/shinkhlala.php#8
Yashika Verma
Research Scholar
Psychology
C.C.S University
Meerut,,Uttar Pradesh,
India
Abstract Marriage is an institution where marital adjustment is about to establish harmony, where partner changes their roles praise and compliment each other playing together opposing two individual units. The purpose of the present study was to study the effect of work status and family type on marital adjustment of Couples with working wives and couples with house making wives. For this purpose, the sample consisted of 128 married adults or 64 married educated couples of age ranges 25-35 belonging to middle economic status. A 2X2 factorial design was used for the accomplishment of research. The marital Adjustment Questionnaire developed by Dr. Pramod Kumar and Dr. Kanchan Rohtagi (1999) was used for data collection. Obtained data were analyzed by mean, S.D, and ANOVA. Results indicated that there appears to be a significant effect of work status of wife on marital adjustment f (63,1=15.92,p<.01) and significant f(63,1=115.42p,.01). A significant interaction effect was found between family type and work status on marital adjustment f (63, 1= 10.06, p<.01).
Keywords Working Wife, House Making Wife, Marital Adjustment, Family Couple, Economic Status.
Introduction
Marriage is one of the most important events in most people’s lives. In almost all cultures, marriages involve a commitment to remain in a close relationship forever through the remainder of one’s life. It is a very serious commitment and although only some couples maintain the goal of remaining married to one person throughout life. Marriage is one of the difficult homework given to every person and it is the role of the partners to find the best way that will support their marriage to become a good and comfortable marriage (Dr. Clyde and Narromore). Marital adjustment is the process during which partners in a marriage adapt and change to their new roles complementing each other acting as a team opposed to two separate units, it is also important to unify the following interests and values marriage open lines of communication and encouraging the expression of each other’s communication. Burges’s and Catrell’s formulation scientists have examined extensively the factors constituting marital adjustment. Agreement between spouses on important matters is critical to a well-adjusted marriage, though minor differences may broaden their perspectives matters such as philosophy, political, orientation and attitude towards gender role are detrimental to marital adjustment. In a well-adjusted marriage, both spouses try to make sure that their marriage will be successful. Husband and wife share similar interests, ideas and are involved in joint activities. It seems that a well-adjusted marriage is where both partners are happy as well as satisfied with each other, and those couples who are not happy with each other but whose marriages are long lasting are not well adjusted ones. Partners in adjusted marriages love to share warmness and it is also exhibited as affectionate behaviour. Finally, we can say that the level of stress and tension in a well-adjusted marriage is marginal and if tension rise it is also resolute probably with communication and spending quality of time and as a result amount of stress, tension and anxiety is normally found very low.
Aim of study In almost all cultures, marriages involve a commitment to remain in a close relationship forever through the remainder of one’s life. It is a very serious commitment and goal of remaining married to one person throughout life. Marital adjustment has long been a popular topic in studies of the family, probably because the concept is believed to be related to the stability of a given marriage. Its an expectation from Well adjusted marriages to stay for a long time where it has been seen that poorly low adjusted marriages end in separation. it seems that the concept of marital adjustment is not very easy to objectify and also challenging to measure through empirical research. The scientist has long been interested in understanding which factor contributes to success in marriage and which to failure. This study is an attempt to study the effect of work status and family type on marital adjustment and Psychological wellbeing of Couple with working wives and couples with house making wives so the results can be helpful for the family, doctors, counsellors and mental health professionals to make different strategies for the marital couple to make their marriage life successful and happy.
Review of Literature
Family is the smallest construction block of the society where great and warm family relation is the assurance of the upcoming of the society(Kisşlak 2012).In the present changing scenario a new picture of marital life is emerging. Slowly but surely, women are entering to semi professional and professional occupations.Research revealed that gender and family type had no evidential main effect on locus of control. But a significant interaction was found between gender and family type. While On the other hand, family type had a significant effect on marital adjustment, i. e. nuclear family couple's marital adjustment is better than joint family couples.(Lailun Nahar 2020) Social support is a factor which is positively associated with marital adjustment, even though it showed a negative connection with anxiety, depression, and stress in working and nonworking women; this finding explore the better mental health of the working and non working women. Social support play a role as a moderator for marital consistency, affection, stress, and depression, and the results reflected that nonworking women with higher marital consistency and warmth showed less stress and depression because of social support. (Jaffar Abbas et.al 2019)Some researches revealed that the level of marital adjustment for mothers increases the maternal attachment.the level of maternal attachment was high, when the level of marital adjustment was liminal. There are many factors affecting sociodemographic characteristics, pregnancy and baby care. (Birsen MutluZeynep, ErkutZeynem, YıldırımNurgül & Gündoğdu 2018) Occupation is one of the most crucial factors, which brings many changes in the life of women; it brings along with it several expectations, burden, time strain and commitments that may have an effect on the mental health of women. In present scenario Working women are more prone to marital adjustment issue because they have lot of work in two environments, home environment as well as work environment one. The success of marital life much depends upon the success in marital adjustment by both husband and wife. (Asiya Ameen 2017) Whether working on the job or at home, women have to play diverse and simultaneous roles by frequently switching on from one role to the other. Researchers have concluded that women need to confront the professional duties and family responsibilities with a congruent approach (Valimakaki et al. 2009). In order to be successful in balancing work and family life, working mothers have been found to be making several marital partnerships with their spouses inclusive of sharing house work, mutual involvement in childcare, joint decision making, equal financial influence and sharing emotional stress (Zimmerman et al.2003). Workng women cannot pay full attention to their family and are unable to satisfy their members. Whereas the non-working married women have more time to their household task and their married life goes smooth. According to the researches working married women cannot properly adjust with their married life because they have many roles to play at a time to find out the level of mental health of working and nonworking women. (Singh 2005, Sharma 1990). Marriage in reality is a way of living. It is not always full of roses; but its success depends upon adjustment on the part of both the partners involved. With the rise in the number of dual-career families, the adjustment and marital relationship are major challenges in most of the families. In India nine out of ten working women are informal workers. They have to face adjustment problems. The adjustment and relationship are major challenges in most of the families. Couples from nuclear families found better marital adjustment in comparison to the joint family couples which means family type found significantly effective on marital adjustment among couples.(Nahar & Mohajan 2020)
Methodology
Independent Variable 1.Working status of wife i.Working Wife ii.Nonworking Wife 2. Family Type i.Joint Family ii. Nuclear Family Dependent variable Marital Adjustment A 2X2 factorial design was employed in the research. The first variable of the study consisted of two groups of couples on the basis of the work status of the wife, they were couple with working wives and couples with house making wives. The second variable of the study was the family type which was varied at two levels i.e., Nuclear family and joint family. The effect of these two variables was studied on marital adjustment.
Sampling

The Sample for the study consisted of 128 adults (64 married educated couples) of the age range 25-35 belonging to medium economic status. The data were randomly collected from schools and offices of Meerut city. These couples consisted of two groups of couples with working wives and couples with house making wives with 32 couples in each group. In both groups, the husband was working but the wife’s work status was varied. Each group of working wives and house making wives further consisted of two groups of family type, they were a nuclear and joint family with 16 Ss in each cell. 

Tools Used 1.Marital adjustment questionnaire developed by Dr. Pramod Kumar and Dr. Kanchan Rohtagi (1999).
Statistics Used in the Study

Obtain data were analyzed with the help of mean and ANOVA. 

Result and Discussion

Table- 1 Showing Mean of Marital Adjustment Score of work status

Variables

Level

Mean Value

Work Status

Working

22.37

House making

19.93

 

 

 

 

The Table-

1 indicated that mean marital adjustment score of the group of couple with  working wife (M 22.37) was significantly higher than couple with house making wife (M 19.93).  This indicated that the two groups work status differs significantly on marital adjustment of married adults.

Graphical representation of Mean of Marital Adjustment Score of work status

 

Table -2 Showing Mean of Family Type scores of Marital Adjustment of working and non working adults

Variables

Level

Mean Value

 

Family Type

Nuclear

24.43

Joint

17.87

Table-2 indicated Mean of marital adjustment scores of two groups of family type of the group of couple with nuclear family (M-24.43) was significantly higher than couple with joint family (M-17.87) This  indicated that the two groups differ significantly on marital adjustment of married adults. 

Graphical representation of Mean of Marital Adjustment Score of family type


Table -3 Showing summary of ANOVA of Marital Adjustment for the group of Family Type and group of couple with working and house making adults

Source of Variation

SS

Df

MS

F

P value

Working &non working(A)

95.06

1

95.06

15.92**

P<.01

Family type(B)

689.06

1

689.06

115.42**

P<.01

Interaction(AXB)

60.06

1

60.06

10.06**

P<.01

Within group

358.26

60

5.97

 

 

Total

1202.41

63

 

 

 

The result indicated a significant effect of work status of wife was found on marital adjustment of couples. [F (63, 1=15.92; p<.01)] because working couples have good marital Adjustment level in various areas of life for example- social, emotional, and sexual.Repetti, Mathews, and Waldron (1989) concluded that employment was associated with improved health for married women who held a positive attitude toward employment. Crosby (1991) concluded that women who juggle multiple roles are less depressed than other women. Moreover wives’ earnings can affect marital disruption, having either advantageous(G.H. Conger et al., 1990. Zedlewski (2002) studied economic factor in relation to family well-being, he found that low family income and limited benefits have negative influences on child and family well-being.

Voyandoff (1990) studied economic distress and family relations.  Ross & Mirowsky (1992) and Yadollahi (2009) studied that employment of spouses and the sense of control in various types of stressors of marital life.

Diener and Diener (2001) investigated that wealth is related to many positive outcomes in life. Gudmunson, Beutler, Israelsen, McCoy & Hill (2007) found that financial problems significantly contributed to lower reported marital satisfaction among married couples.

A significant effect of family type was found on marital adjustment.[F(63,1=115.42;P<.01)].Marital Adjustment is higher in couples in nuclear family because in nuclear family there is greater degree of freedom for spouses. The status of the woman is higher and she often takes up employment outside the home. The material well- being of children, such as healthcare and education, is higher because of more resources available. Nuclear families are adaptable to social change.

A significant interaction effect between family type and work status was found on marital adjustment. [F (63,1=10.06;p<.01)]. In today's traditional nuclear families, it is common to have dual incomes. Both parents work to provide financial stability for the household, creating a larger cash flow to supply the basic family needs of housing, food and healthcare. Financial stability also allows the parents to provide additional extracurricular opportunities for their children, such as music or athletic lessons. These opportunities allow children to flourish socially and develop a higher level of confidence.

Table 4 Showing Interaction Effect between working Status and family type on Marital Adjustment working and non working adults

Working Status

      Nuclear

       Joint

Working

24.68

20.06

Non Working

24.18

15.68

Table 4 showing interaction effects between work status and family type of marital adjustment of married adults. Mean for marital adjustment score indicated that couple with working wife in nuclear family subject (M=24.68) was significantly higher than couple with working wife in joint family (M=20.06). Similarly couple with house making wife in nuclear family (M=24.18) are significantly higher than couple with house making wife in joint family (M=15.68). This means that the two group scores interact significantly. The same results are depicted in fig 4.

Therefore, the null hypothesis that there will be no significant interaction effect between working status and family type on marital adjustment of married adults is rejected substantive hypothesis that there will be a significant effect of work status and Family type on marital adjustment of adults is accepted.

Findings 1.A significant effect of work status of wife was found on marital adjustment of couples so the null hypothesis that there will be no significant effect of working status of wife on marital adjustment of couple is rejected 2.A significant effect of family type was found on marital adjustment so the null hypothesis that there will be no significant effect of family type on marital adjustment of couple is rejected. 3.A significant interaction effect between family type and work status was found on marital adjustment so the null hypothesis that there will be no interaction effect of working status of wife and family type on marital adjustment of couple is rejected.
Conclusion In modern society educated women want co-partnership with their husbands. They expect marital happiness and demand gratification of their social, economical and personal requirements and full satisfaction of biological impulses and fulfillment of psychological needs. Finally it can be concluded that couple with working wife were showing high level of marital adjustment than couple with house making wife, (Renu Pal 2016) whereas couples of nuclear family were also showing high marital adjustment than couples in joint family.
Suggestions for the future Study 1. further research requires more data.
2. The age group range in the study was 25-35 years. The age group may be divided into other groups to the interaction effect of age on other variation
.3.Marital adjustment can be measured in different professional areas like doctors, lawyers and other government sectors.
Limitation of the Study 1. The sample size in the study was limited which limit the generalization to the entire adults.
2. Study includes male-female both, gender differences can also be seen while taking only both gender as a variable to see the comparison.
References
1. Allport, G. (1961). Pattern and growth in personality. New York: Holt,Rinehart & Winsten.pp.245-247 2. Baron and Byrne. Social psychology (12ed) pp.259-265.. 3. Benobraites, Nijole 1999: Marriage and families changes Choices and constraints, Prentice hall pp: 239-245,250-252. 4. Biswas-Diener.R.,&Diener.E.(2001).Making the best of a bad situation: Satisfaction in the slums of Calcutta.Social Indicators Research.55,329-352. 5. Crosby, F. J. (1991). Juggling: The Unexpected Advantages of Balancing Career and Home for Women and Their Families. New York: Free Press. 6. Gudmunson, C. G., Beutler, I. F., Israelsen, C. L., McCoy, J. K., & Hill, E. J. (2007). Linking financial strain to marital instability: Examining the roles of emotional distress and marital interaction. Journal of Family and Economic Issues, 28(3), 357-376. 7. Singh, H.M. 1972. Marital Adjustment Inventory. Agra: National Psychological Corporation. 8. Sharma, Tirthrani; et.al (1990). Marital adjustment in house wives of Nuclear and joint families. Journal of Personality and clinical Studies Vol, 6 (2), 244-245. 9. Singh M, Singh G (2005) Assessment of mental health status of middle-aged school teacher of Varanasi city. The internet Journal of Health 5. 1 10. Rani Rinku 2013 Marital Adjustment problems of working and non working women in contrast of their husband international journal for research in education.Vol, 2(7).pp1-8 11. Repetti, R. L., Matthews, K. A., & Waldron, I. (1989). Employment and women's health: Effects of paid employment on women's mental and physical health. American Psychologist, 44(11), 1394. 12. Ross, C. E., & Mirowsky, J. (1992). Households, employment, and the sense of control. Social Psychology Quarterly, 55, 217-235. Retrieved from http://www. jstor.org/pss/2786793 13. Valimakaki, S., Lamsa, A., & Hiillos, M. (2009). The spouse of the female manager : Role and influence on the women's career. Gender in Management, 24(8), 596-613 14. Yadollahi, M, et al. (2009). Factors affecting economic status. European Journal of Scientific Research, 37,99-109. Retrieved from http://www.euro journals.com/ejsr_37_1_ 12 .pdf 15. Voydanoff, P. (1990). Economic distress and family relations: A review of the eighties. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 1099-1115. 16. Zedlewski, S. R. (2002). Family economic resources in the post-reform era. The Future of Children, 121-145. 17. Zimmerman, T. S., Haddock, S. A., Current, L. R., & Ziemba, S. (2003). Intimate partnership:Foundation for the successful balance of family and work. American Journal of Family, 31, 107-124. 18. www.sandiego.edu/inter church/marriage/marriage.htm. 19. http://members:tripod.com/dr_rath/index3.00 perception.html