P: ISSN No. 0976-8602 RNI No.  UPENG/2012/42622 VOL.- XI , ISSUE- III July  - 2022
E: ISSN No. 2349-9443 Asian Resonance
Financial and Non-Financial Decisions making Amongst Tribal Working Women: A Comparative study
Paper Id :  16396   Submission Date :  07/07/2022   Acceptance Date :  20/07/2022   Publication Date :  25/07/2022
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
For verification of this paper, please visit on http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/resonance.php#8
Tsering Yangzom
Assistant Professor
Economics
Jammu University
Jammu,Jammu and Kashmir, India
Abstract It has been witnessed a number of times that even a financially independent woman is less empowered in terms of decision-making power she enjoys at homes. Therefore, the paper assesses the status of the decision-making power enjoyed by them and the target group is the Scheduled tribes from Union Territory Ladakh. Accordingly, there are three main objectives, firstly to examine the socio-economic background of them, secondly, to assess the situation at financial and non-financial and finally, to recommend policy. The paper used primary data being collected from 131 ST working women, it uses statistical tools like percentage and frequency. The paper witnessed that tribal working women are less empowered in terms of decision-making perspective whether its financial or non-financial. The paper has made some policy suggestions.
Keywords Scheduled Tribes, Working Women, Decision-Making, Women Empowerment, Leh-Ladakh UT.
Introduction
The gender equality being one of the focuses of the SDGs as it is very important from every walk of the life be it saving the lives across globes or be it reducing the poverty level or be it a contributor to economy. It either has an effect on these various aspects directly or indirectly but definitely plays very significant role. The SDGs’ goal of gender equality quotes “Achieve gender equality and empower all women and girls” and this further ensures women’s active involvement in all levels of decision-making processes and at the same time have equal opportunities for the leadership. Therefore, empowering the women economically and socially is the prime focus of every government across globe. However, it seems there is trade-offs existing between economic and social factors. In other words, it’s not necessary that a financially independent woman at work place might be lacks empowerment at household level especially in the decision-making processes.
Aim of study 1. To identify the socio-economic background of Tribal working women 2. To assess the level of participation of these working women in financial and non-financial decision-making processes at households. 3. To suggest policy recommendations
Review of Literature
The existing literatures on the topic do confirm that there is wide gender disparity in the decision especially related to finances at household level and some of these studies are Pahl, Riley and Chow, Mukhtar, et al, Bernasek and Bejtelsmit, Acharya, et al and Yogendrarajah. The women always tend to involve themselves lesser in these decisions at home and most of the time, they have not been given their due power to take decisions. In other words, the men at home deliberately do not consider their wives or mothers, in the decision. However, the involvement from women does improve with the level of education and income. Therefore, there has been a gap as there is a dirt of studies on the particular problem in the UT Ladakh. Therefore, the paper will try to explore the problem and that too among the working women of Ladakh.
Methodology
The paper is primary data-based study and it has collected the primary data from 131 tribal working women. The questionnaires being sent to these respondents through google form in the month of December2021-January 2022. The questionnaire consisted a set of questions encompassing the individual socio-economic backgrounds to their involvement in financial as well as non-financial decisions at household level. The data has been processed in the SPSS software and accordingly it has been analyzed by using the tools like mean, percentage, graphs, etc.
Result and Discussion

These working women have been asked a series of questions pertaining to their involvement at decision-making processes at home and accordingly their responses have been aggregated and presented in the tables below. Apart from this, their socio-economic background has been also checked and the results are presented in the table 1. The table shows that the 63.4 percent of the tribal working women belongs to the age category of 30-49 years and corresponding frequency is 83 women. As far as the education qualification is concerned, the 28.2 percent of them are Post graduates and 25.2 percent under graduates. These two account for more than 50 percent of the total respondents. Then, the rest have lower education qualification except for the 7.6 percent (with Professional Degrees) and 8.4 percent (with Mphil/Ph.D). in terms of marital status, the majority i.e., 71.0 percent are married and 28.2 percent single, and 0.8 percent divorcee. The area to which these women belong, the majority of them that is 67.9 percent are from rural areas. In other words, they are living in villages. Only 32.1 percent of them are living in towns. The 61.1 of them live in a nuclear family and the rest in a joint family. In terms of their working place is concerned, the majority has a job in the public sector that is 67.2 percent and 32.8 percent of them are associated with private sector. The account other than saving account, the 65.6 percent said Yes and the rest has said No.  As far as the ownership of the property is concerned, only 4.6 percent of them won the property.

The table 2 reveals the summary of the responses given by these women and these responses are finances related decisions. The estimates are telling the percentage share of each answer category under the question on the decisions related to finances. There are two questions and

Table 1: Socio-Economic Background of the Tribal Working Women Respondents

Characteristics

Categories

Frequency

Percentage

Age

15-29 Years

41

31.3

 

30-49 Years

83

63.4

 

50-60 Years

7

5.3

 

 

131

100

Education Qualification

Under Matriculation

4

3.1

 

12th Passed

23

17.6

 

Under Graduate

33

25.2

 

Post Graduate

50

28.2

 

Professional Course

10

7.6

 

MPhil/PhD

11

8.4

 

 

131

100

Marital Status

Single

37

28.2

 

Married

93

71.0

 

Divorced

1

.8

 

 

131

100

Area

Urban

42

32.1

 

Rural

89

67.9

 

 

131

100

Family

Nuclear

80

61.1

 

Joint

51

38.9

 

 

131

100

Types (Occupation)

Public Sector

88

67.2

 

Private Sector

43

32.8

 

 

131

100

Account other than Saving A/c

Yes

45

34.4

 

No

86

65.6

 

 

131

100

Owner Property

Myself

6

4.6

 

My spouse

34

26.0

 

My Parents

83

63.4

 

In-Laws

3

2.3

 

Jointly

5

3.8

 

 

131

100.0

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 







Table 2:Percentage Share of the Responses in the Decisions related to Finances

Questions

Answers

Frequency

Percentage

Who decides monthly grocery list?

Myself

40

30.5

 

Husband

65

49.6

 

Jointly

26

19.8

 

Total

131

100.0

Who decides daily miscellaneous purchases?

Myself

19

14.5

 

Husband

77

58.8

 

Jointly

35

26.7

 

Total

131

100.0

Source: Author’s Calculations

these are financial related questions. decisions related to finances like monthly grocery list and daily miscellaneous purchases tell that, there is a low involvement from women in such purchases. There percentage is as low as 30.5 percent and 14.5 percent in grocery list and daily miscellaneous purchases respectively. While looking at the involvement of their spouse or parents, the share is as high as 49.6 and 58.8 in terms of former and latter respectively. Even, a significant share of them takes the decision jointly.

Table 3 reveals the situation of these working women from non-financial related decisions perspective and their performance is little bit better than in financial decisions. They have been asked four questions in this regard and the responses are almost the same. The overview of the situation is that unlike financial decisions case, here there is a relatively low involvement from their husbands and at the same time a relatively much higher involvement from these women but not independently rather jointly.

Table 3:Percentage Share of the Responses in the Decisions related to non-Finances

Questions

Answers

Frequency

Percentage

Who takes the decisions on the taking care of kids?

Myself

30

22.9

 

Husband

3

2.3

 

Jointly

53

40.5

 

No Kids

45

34.4

 

Total

131

100.0

Who takes the decisions on the taking care of elderly?

Myself

24

18.3

 

Husband

8

6.1

 

Jointly

99

75.6

 

Total

131

100.0

Who takes the decisions on the rearing of cattle?

Myself

12

9.2

 

Husband

43

32.8

 

Jointly

63

48.1

 

No Cattle

13

9.9

 

Total

131

100.0

Who decides the clothes to be worn by kids and yourself?

Myself

75

57.3

 

Husband

5

3.8

 

Jointly

19

14.5

 

Not Married

32

24.4

 

Total

131

100.0

 Source: Author’s Calculations

Therefore, it has been concluded that the involvement of these tribal working women at household decision- making processes is lower in financial matters than non-financial matters. While comparing their level of involvement with their husbands/ parents’, it has been argued that the latter involvement is always higher than the former’s. The other important feature of these women is that they somehow involve in the decisions but most of them take the decision jointly rather than independently.

In order to know these tribal working women their perception on themselves that how are they consider themselves as efficient enough to take decisions in general and financial and non-financial decision in particular. They have been asked three questions and the responses are categorized in to three, namely Yes, No and Maybe. The results are presented in the table 4 and these results tell that 68.7 percent of them consider themselves as efficient enough to take

Table 4:Working Women’s Perception on the Efficiency at Decision-Making Processes

Questions

Answers

Frequency

Percentage

Do you consider yourself efficient enough to take any decision?

Yes

90

68.7

 

No

16

12.2

 

Maybe

25

19.1

 

Total

131

100.0

Do you consider yourself efficient enough to take any financial decision?

Yes

55.7

19.9

 

No

19.8

22.9

 

Maybe

22.9

98.5

 

Total

131

100.0

Do you consider yourself efficient enough to take any non-financial decision?

Yes

84

64.1

 

No

25

19.1

 

Maybe

22

16.8

 

Total

131

100.0

Source: Author’s Calculations

Conclusion Any decision and responded Yes and only 19.1 percent said Maybe. But surprisingly, when the second question being asked on financial decisions, immediately, the percentage falls to 19.9 percent. On the other hand, 98.5 percent of them are doubtful in financial decisions. Whereas, the third question pertains to non-financial decision, the 64.1 percent of them considered them as efficient in taking the non-financial decision and responded Yes. But, only 16.8 of them are doubtful about themselves.
Suggestions for the future Study The level of participation of the working women from the Ladakh UT in decision making processes at household level project that though their participation is quite there but most of the time, they do not take these decisions independently. However, their level of involvement does vary from financial to non-financial decisions. In other words, the nature of decision has significant impact on the level of involvement of these tribal working women. Therefore, the policy makers should focus on following items.
1. The government must sensitize a gender sensitive training cum awareness programmes not for women but also for men, so these men also get awareness on the women empowerment and it starts from home.
2. The employers of these women must arrange training-cum-awareness camps for their women employees and must make a mandatory course for newly woman employee.
3. The Non-organizational bodies like Civil society, Social Activities, AAMA Tsokpa, Ladakh Buddhist Association (LBA), etc., must also come with the government bodies in sensitizing the gender disparity and women empowerment and at the same time ensuring the women’s basic human rights.
4. These working women, they themselves must encourage one another and must boost their confidence.
5. There should be more employment opportunities and self-employment programmes for these women in general as income does play a significant role in her empowerment.
References
1. Acharya, D.R., Bell, J.S., Simkhada, P. et al. (2010) Women’s Autonomy in Household Decision-Making: A Dempgraphic Study in Nepal, Reproductive Health, pp. 7-15 2. Bernasek, A. &Baitelsmit, V. (2002) Predictors of Women’s Involvement in Household Financial Decision-Making, Financial Counselling and Planning, Vol. 13, issue 1, pp.1-9 3. Maxwell, M. &Vaishnav, M. (2021) Working Women’s Decision -Making Power at Home: Evidence from Four North Indian Urban Clusters, Indian Institute for Human Settlements, Vol. 6, Issue 1, Supplement, pp. 558-576 4. Mukhtar, E.M., Mukhtar, H. &Abbhink, G.A. (1991) Female Participation in Household Decision-Making: An Analysis of Consumer Durables Acquisition in Pakistan, The Pakistan Development Review, Vol. 30, Issue 4, pp. 953-964 5. Pahl, J (1980) Patterns of Money Management Within Marriage, Journal of Social Policy, Vol. pp. 313-335 6. Pandey, P., Chaubey, A.K. & Rai, G. (2021) The Involvement of Women as the Domestic Decision Maker: A study of Patna Metropolitan City, Bihar, India, Sociedade&Natureza, Vol. pp. 1-9 7. Riley, w.b.& Chow, K.V. (1992) Asset Allocation and Individual Risk Aversion, Financial Analyst Journal, Vol. 48, Issue 6, pp.32-37 8. Sell, M. & Minot, N. (2018) What Factors Explain Women’s Empowerment? Decision-Making Among Small in Scale Farmers in Uganda, Women’s Studies International Forum, Vol. 71, November-December, pp. 45-55 9.Yogendrarajah, R. (2013) Women Empowerment Through Decision-Making, The International Journal of Economics and Business Management, Vol 3, Issue 1, December, pp. 2250-2750