|
|||||||
Desire
for Self-Sufficiency and Role Reversal in Clear
Light of the Day |
|||||||
Paper Id :
18124 Submission Date :
13/09/2023 Acceptance Date :
22/09/2023 Publication Date :
25/09/2023
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8409832 For verification of this paper, please visit on
http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/anthology.php#8
|
|||||||
| |||||||
Abstract |
When one thinks of Indian women, mind conjures up with images of the wife trailing the husband, never daring to walk alongside him. One also thinks of such pains taking and decorated women as Sita and Shankuntla. But from the days of subservience and passivity to now, women have been steadily changing by much to the bewilderment from the rest of the world around them. As an example, Celien in Alice Walker’s The Colour Purple (1982), despite her shortcomings, asserts: (I’m pore, I’m black, I may be ugly… but I’m here”.[1] The change in hundred years is remarkable. The woman of today is not only articulate but also aware of her identity and potentiality. Inside “the enclosure of patriarchy”,[2] fortunately, with recent changes in moral imagination and perception with regard to women, here is Meera Masi, Bim & Tara of Clear Light of the Day, defying the limiting norms of patriarchy in different ways to define themselves. Anita Desai is one of those novelists who have captured the vitality of changing roles of contemporary Indian women. In her earlier work, Desai’s protagonists, most of whom are women, battle desperately with their traditional roles and with society’s expectations of them. What is apparent in all of her women is that they exercise their wills; they are mistresses of their own fates. Undercurrent of this topic, author will scrutinise the different means and methods adopted by the protagonists of Clear Light of the Day in their defiance of patriarchy; their self-definition and individual development ultimately “Transcends gender” in Jungian terminology. |
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Keywords | Patriarchy, Feminism, Functions, Harmony, Equally. | ||||||
Introduction | Clear Light of the Day is a novel about the Das family consisting of the parents, Raja, Baba, a mentally retarded boy, the eldest sister Bim, the younger Tara and a distant poor relative, Mira Masi. The novel covers long span of time covering both British India, a post-independence India. Mr. Das, a well-off cultural officer of an insurance company, dies prematurely of heart-attack. But his death doesn’t matter because he hardly gave any time to children. During his life time he passed his days in the office evening at the club. For the mother, her Roshanara club is far more precious than her home. She is preoccupied with her dressing-up, her bridge and her diabetes. Father earns a living pays the bills and signs the admission forms of the children to next higher class. Neither feels responsible towards the young ones: they are left to fend for them. There is hardly any exchange between the children and the parents. With the arrival of Aunt Mira, the children experience a certain measure of love and warmth that their lives had lacked. Bim and Raja though quite content to have aunt Meera around, were not entirely contained in the self-diffident love of the Aunt. They bore great resentment against their parents: “day after day and year after year till their death,” their parents sent the time, “Playing bridge with friends like themselves, mostly silent… now and the speaking those names and numbers that remained a mystery to he children who were not allowed within the room while a game was in progress… Raja used to
swear that one day he would leap up onto the table in a lion- mask, brandishing
a torch, and set fire to their paper-world of theirs, whiled Bim flashed her
sewing scissors in the sunlight and declared she would creep in secretly at
night and strip all the cards in to bits. ButTara simply sucked her finger and
retreated down The veranda to Aunt Mira’s rooms where she could always touch
herself… It would hafrightened her a bit if they had come away, followed her
and tried to communicate with her”[3]
After their parents’ death, being the eldest member
of the family, Bim assumes the role of a father, taking care of brothers and
sisters and later marrying them. She is so pre-occupied with family
responsibilities that she has no time for her own love and life. Even though
she has an affair with a doctor who becomes her family doctor and it appears
that they would be engaged yet somehow things do not happen that way. The irony
of the novel is that in spite of her sacrifice at the familial altar everyone is
busy in his or her family and she gets nothing but acrimony and bitterness.
Being deprived of warmth of human relationship or familial relationship ,books
are her only solace and refuge. Anita Desai’s protagonists brought up to be
diffident, meek and quiet in the face of exploitation, are yet highly sensitive
and intelligent and are desperate to find an outlet to their pangs. Their
extreme sensitivity, however, channelies their mode of liberation in various
directions. Clear Light of the Day is chosen to evince and
examine the wide space that divides that two type of women hailing from the
same family… the woman who do not act but surrender and so keep the tradition
alive and next Bim the chief protagonist of Anita Desai chooses not to
surrender and be meek but breaks the convention to face the situation and take
up a new road where no one can dictate to her. Her ambition is two-fold; to be
emotionally and economically independent. Through role-reversal and not through
self warping, she takes on the task of race upliftment. Her desire for
self-sufficiency enables her to refute masculine power. She defeats the
patriarchal forces in various ways. She not only obliterates the
memory of the biological father but also dwarfs the masculine power. |
||||||
Aim of study |
The aim is, a call for recognition of woman as an equally
important partner in marriage or in any other relationship. A world which
should be based on equally sharing and harmony between the two sexes, where the
need, the functions, the virtues of women are valued equally along with these
of men. |
||||||
Review of Literature | Bim, the protagonist of the novel
of ''Clear Light of the Day'', is the eldest of all,
shoulders upon herself all the burden of the family. After her
father’s death she accepts the role of a father taking care of her sisters and
brothers and later marrying them. Due to the responsibilities she
has no time for her own love and life even though she has an affair with a
doctor who later on becomes her family doctor. She explores her
solace andrefuge into books. At a superficial level, such women may
be seen as “westernised”. Madhusudan Prasad, commenting on this
image points out, “This image combined with the
image of Sisyphus, is replete with deeper symbolic significance. A
momentous image, it is connected with the theme of the novel illuminating the
real character of Bim.”[4] Anita Desai does no describe the childhood of her character at length, but occasional references to childhood conditions and their reminiscences confirm her belief that childhood impressions are lasting and they affect the development of personality. |
||||||
Main Text | Many factors damage the sense of
self-reliance, such as dominating parents, partial, irritable, over-indulgent
or hypocritical elders. Consequently a child fails to relate himself
to others and develops some strategy diverts his constructive emerges towards
alleviating his basic anxiety. There are other victims of an unhappy
and detrimental home environment in Anita Desai: the Das brother and sisters
in Clear Light of the Day; whereas the tragedy of the
Dases is alleviated and averted with the benign presence of Mira Masi, home and
a family, if presence of parents and a roof overhead is the
notion. Parent-child partnership is essential because man is not a
readymade being. He is moulded by his circumstances and his
choices. Unfortunate home atmosphere makes the question of “choices”
impossible for the Das children. Bim, the protagonist, doesn’t like
to think her past as it has been wholly unsavoury. She asks Tara
tauntingly, “You wouldn’t want to return
to life as it used to be, would you?… All that dullness, boredom,
waiting. Would you care to live that over again? Of
course not. Do you know anyone who would-- secretly, sincerely, in
his innermost self--really prefer to return to childhood?” This bitterness indicated her
tortured vision of the world against the backdrop of a malevolent
home. She wishes to flee it by denying its reality. Bim
the worst sufferer withdraws into herself and wishes to shut all doors to the
past and the future. Clear Light of the Day doesn’t seem
to have a tangible story. Bim tells her younger sister, Tara, about
“All that dullness, boredom, and waiting”[5]. She
links up the boredom of her home with that of old Delhi: “Old Delhi does not
change. It only decays.”[6] The
petrified condition in which the whole family lives makes them feel as if they
are wallowing in a “pond so muddy a stagnant.”[7] Bim
says: “Here we are lift rocking on the back waters, getting duller and
greyer everyday.”[8] Bimla,
the central consciousness in Clear Light of the Day, where self is
wounded by the callow behaviour of her parents and her brother very often
compare her relations and their memory to mosquitoes. The following
excerpts from her reminiscence clarify her feeling: The memory came
whining out of the dark like a mosquito, dangling its ling legs and bovering
just out of reach.[9] The mosquitoes that
night were like the thoughts of the day embodied in monster form, invisible in
the dark but present everywhere, most of all in and around the ears, piercingly
audible.[10] They had come like
mosquitoes--- Tara, and Bakul, and behind them the Misras, and some where in
the distance Raja and Benazir--- only to torment her and, mosquito--- like, sip
her blood. All of them fed on her blood, at sometime or the other
had fed--- it must have been good blood, sweet and nourishing. Now,
when they were fully, they rose in swarms, humming away, turning their backs on
her”.[11] The above citations suggest the
pattern of Bimla’s feelings. Ironically enough, she doesn’t
articulate her feelings. But Dr. Biswas, who comes to treat Raja,
diagnoses Bimal’s predicament. Although the narrator seems to think
that Dr. Biswas misunderstand Bim, we are not wrong in inferring that somewhere
in her consciousness Bim’s frustration crystallizes itself into tine spot,
which gradually develops in to a perpetual and unhealed wound.The
domestic disharmony that often stifles and chokes Bim’s adventurous spirit has
as its objective correlative the fortunes of two girls, Jaya and Sarla: in the
Misras boys. Bimla says: “The wives wanted the new
life; they wanted to be modern women. I think they wanted to move into
their own separate homes, in New Delhi, and cut their hair short and give card
parties, or open boutiques or learn modelling. They can’t stand our
sort of Old Delhi life--- the way the Misras vegetable here in the bosom of the
family. So they spend as much time as they can away”.[12] Though
Bim comment refers to the Misras boys it applies with equal force to her
parents, her brother and sister. Moreover, Bim’s resolve not to
marry is firmly rooted in her emanate desire to be self-sufficient and
self-dependent by refusing to accept the chain of matrimony she tries to
interpret the female conduct formula and refuse. The following conversation
between Bim and Tara about the Misras girls illustrates the point: The
mother wanted them to be married soon. She said, “she married
when she was twelve and
Jaya and Sarla are already sixteen and
seventeen years old”.“But
they are not educated yet,” Bim said sharply. “They haven’t
any degrees. They should go to college,” she
insisted. “Why?” said
Tara… “Why?” repeated Bim indignantly, “Why, because they might find
marriage isn’t enough to last them the whole of their lives”, she
said darkly,
mysteriously. “What
else could there be?” countered
Tara. “I mean”,
she
fumbled, “for
them”.“What else?” asked Bim. “Can’t
you think? I
can think of hundreds of things to do instead. I won’t
marry”, she added, very
firmly. Tara glanced at her sideways with a
slightly sceptical smile. “I
won’t”, repeated Bim, adding “I shall never leave Baba and Raja and Mira Masi”.[13] Tara,
who has not been able to outgrow her childhood completely, feels to be “an
eternal, miniature Sisyhus.”[14] Most
of their problems they inherited from their parents who spent time playing
bridge with friends like themselves.Their paper-world had a sapping
effect on the children.They were: “sucked down into the silent
centre of a deep, shadowy vortex while they floated on the surface, staring
down into the underworld, their eyes popping with incomprehension.”[15] Bim, never attempts to attain
sainthood; her inner life sometime petty, sometime bobble, is imaginatively
portrayed by Anita Desai. Through role reversal, she takes on the
talk of race upliftment. Her “social quest”, and not “spiritual
quest”[16],
enables her to refute masculine power.If she is “brisk, practical,
agile, firm, dominating and patronizing on the one hand”, she is also
“abstract, sullen, stubborn, introspective, irritable and shadowy”[17]. Bim
refuses to define herself through her husband (as women happily do), and does
not consider marriage to be either the beginning or the end of her
story. Her desire for self-sufficiency becomes evident in her
childhood when she decides to become a Florence Nightingale or Joan of Arc; her
resolution, “I shall earn my own living a look after Mira Masi and Baba and ---
and be independent”,[18] reveals
her ambitions. It is symbolically uncovered through her preference
for trousers.[19] Independence
normally denied to women can’t be denied to Bim. Her biological
father, a shadowy figure, is only a remote bread-winner,[20] Raja
the weak brother selfishly escapes the family burden; Baba the youngest brother
is an imbecile; and Dr. Biswas, Bim’s one time suitor with spinsterish nerves”[21],
disappears sensing Bim’s disapproval. The inter-relation between Bim
and other male characters is not even combative as they are
non-entities. Reduction of male power is a typical method employed
by women novelists to illustrate female power. The
novel throws some significant light on discards at various
levels. Raja’s letter about house rent badly humiliates and hurts
his sister. In the novel, quite few unbelievable incidents and developments
take place. Bim nurses Raja thinking that he would provide succour
to the fatherless family. But he tells his decision to Bim that he
would go to Pakistan: “I will go… go to… to
Hyderabad. Hyder Ali Sahib has asked me to come... I …I will… go today… today I
will catch the train… I won’t stop here, with you, another day. It’s
enough… enough”[22] Again he asks her: “You don’t want me to spend
all my life down in this hole, do you? You don’t think I can go on
living just to keep my brother and sister company, do you?”[23] Bim and Baba, the valid brother,
are left behind to face the music. Bim’s pathetic conversation with
Baba unfolds the disorganized state of the family. “So now there are just you and
I left, Baba,… Does the house seem empty to you? Everyone is gone
except you and I. they won’t come back. We’ll be alone
now.”[24] The novel, nevertheless, ends on
a positive note. “Be strong. Face
challenges. Be decisive” seems to be one message of
it. Forgiveness and dedication of one’s life to others can
transfigure one’s life. Without them life “would remain flawed,
damaged” for ever and “The wholeness of the pattern, its perfection, would be
gone”[25]. This
is aptly illustrated by the example of Bim. Ironically enough, Bim…
the most adventurous, strong sensitive and humane of the children… is left
behind to take care of her childlike, speechless, artistic brother, Baba and
their, aged aunt, dying in delirium tremens. But the conclusion of
Dr. Biswas: “Now I understand why you do
not wish to marry. You have dedicated you life to others --- to your
sick brother and your aged aunt and your little brother who will be dependent
on you all his life. You have sacrificed your own life for them,”[26] is horrifying to
Bim. She had not chosen the situation in which she had been caught: “She
even hissed slightly in her rage and frustration… at being
so misunderstood, so
totally misread, then gulped a little with laughter
at such
grotesque misunderstanding, and her tangled emotions twisted
her face
and shook her.”[27] Outraged with the lack of any
adequate response from anyone around her, Bim threatens to give up her
responsibilities, because the problems around her need attention and she is not
quite equipped to deal with it all. The arrival of a letter from
their father’s office disturbs the routine of their lives, because it requires
one of them to go to the office to attend a meeting. She is
reluctant to hold forth her compassion any longer, and with all her anger
unappeased, she chooses Baba as her target: “With
my salary, I’ll be able to pay the rent, keep on the house
I’ll manage…
but I might have sent you to live with Raja. I came to
ask you…- what would
you think of that? ... Are you willing to go and live with Raja
in Hyderabad?”[28] She was taken aback at this fury
of her own self. “She
had only walked in to talk to Baba --- cut down his defence
and demand some kind of a response from him, some
kind of a
justification from
him for herself, her own life, her ways and attitudes, like a
blessing from
Baba. She had not known she would be led into making such
a threat, or blackmailing
Baba. She was still hardly aware of what she
had said
only something seemed to slam inside her head, painfully, when
she looked
at Baba.”[29] Baba did not say
anything. Perhaps, that is why she decided to address her anger to
Baba and not to Raja, Tara or Bakul: “She
could have so easily drawn on answer out of them --- she
already knew
the answers they would have yielded up.”[30] It was Baba’s silence and reserve
and other worldliness that she had wanted to break open. Bim’s rage
once appeased, she comes to the startling realization: There
could be no love more deep and full and wide than this one,
she knew.No
other love had started so far back in time and had so much time in
which to grow and spread. They were really all parts of
her,inseparable,
so many aspects of
her as she was of them, so that the anger or
the disappointment she felt in them was only the anger
and disappointment
she felt at herself. Whatever hurt they felt, she
felt.Whatever
diminished them, diminished her. What attacked
them attacked
her.”[31] After these words no doubts what Bim has decided to play in her family; she acts as a provide, protector, and redeemer of her family members. Bim appears as new woman. She is independent and liberated only, yet there is no mark of arrogance of superiority in her.Bim is very clear about her aspirations ,urges and expectations, yet she is not the one to roll in pity about her alienation. If she felt cheated and stranded and thought Raja and Tara to be selfish. She was ready to forgive them. She was ready to see every flaw of others in the light of understanding. She would have to forgive her parents too, towards whom she was resentful because she could not grasp disturbed atmosphere of their lives. Bim is able to obtain everything in life without the help of the masculine forces due to her confidence in herself. It is in Bim that we recognize the emerging new and independent woman that Simon de Beauvoir delineates: |
||||||
Conclusion |
“Once she ceases to be a parasite, the system based on her dependence
crumbles; between her and the universe there is no longer any need for a
masculine mediator.”[32] |
||||||
References | 1. Walker, Alice, The Colour Purple, New York: Pocket Books, 1982. p. 214. 2. Pratt, Annis, The Archetypal Patterns in Women’s Fiction; Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1981, p. 38. 3. Desai, Anita, Clear Light of the Day; London: Penguin Books, 1980, p. 22. 4. Prasad Madhusudan , The novels of Anita Desai: A Study of Imagery, p. 75. 5. Desai, Anita, Clear Light of the Day; London: Penguin Books, 1980, p. 4. 6. Ibid, p. 5. 7. Ibid,. 12 8. Ibid, p. 5. 9. Ibid, p. 151. 10. Desai, Anita, Clear Light of the Day; London: Penguin Books, 1980, p. 152 11. Ibid, p. 153. 12. Desai, Anita, Clear Light of the Day; London: Penguin Books, 1980, p. 151. 13. Desai, Anita, Clear Light of the Day; London: Penguin Books, 1980, p. 140. 14. Ibid, p. 2. 15. Ibid, p. 22. 16. Ibid, p. 5. 17. Asnani, Shyam, “The Indian English Novel with a Unique Vision: A study of Clear Light of the Day ”, New Dimensions of Indian English Novel, New Delhi: Doaba House, 1987. p. 98. 18. Desai, Anita, Clear Light of the Day; London: Penguin Books, 1980, p. 140. 19. Ibid, p. 131. 20. Ibid, p. 65. 21. Ibid, p. 83. 22. Ibid, p. 95. 23. Desai, Anita, Clear Light of the Day; London: Penguin Books, 1980, p. 100. 24. Ibid, p. 101. 25. Ibid, p. 165. 26. Desai, Anita, Clear Light of the Day; London: Penguin Books, 1980, p. 97. 27. Ibid, p. 97. 28. Ibid, p. 163. 29. Desai, Anita, Clear Light of the Day; London: Penguin Books, 1980, pp. 163-64. 30. Ibid, p. 164. 31. Desai, Anita, Clear Light of the Day; London: Penguin Books, 1980, p. 165. 32. Beauvoir, Simon de, The Second Sex, p. 412. |