P: ISSN No. 0976-8602 RNI No.  UPENG/2012/42622 VOL.- XII , ISSUE- IV October  - 2023
E: ISSN No. 2349-9443 Asian Resonance

Comparative Mӧssbauer Spectroscopic Study of the Ferric-ferrous Ratio of the Sediments of the Different Test Wells of the Bikaner-Nagaur Basin of the Western Rajasthan

Paper Id :  18157   Submission Date :  06/10/2023   Acceptance Date :  21/10/2023   Publication Date :  25/10/2023
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
DOI:10.5281/zenodo.10013993
For verification of this paper, please visit on http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/resonance.php#8
Samay Singh Meena
Assistant Professor
Department Of Physics
Jai Narain Vyas University
Jodhpur,Rajasthan, India,
Hemant Dhaka
Research Scholar, Department Of Physics
Jai Narain Vyas University
Jodhpur, Rajasthan, India
Beena Bhatia
Retired Professor
Department Of Physics
Jai Narain Vyas University
Jodhpur, Rajasthan, India
Abstract

Bikaner-Nagaur basin constitutes a late Riphean-Vendian basin in the north-western part of the peninsular Indian shield. Structurally Bikaner-Nagaur basin is bounded in the east by Delhi-Aravali folding and, in the south, south-west by Pokra-Nachna high, separating Jaisalmer basin and to north-east lies the Delhi-Sargoda rides. The basin slopes to the northwest and merges with the Indus shelf. The north-western shield had undergone the proto plate tectonics complex process of a Proterozoic accretionary collision tectonics starting from 700-1300m.In the present Mössbauer spectroscopic a comparative study of the sediments of the Phulasar well with from different test wells already studied  of the Bikaner-Nagaur basin was carried out.  In the present study the ferric-ferrous ratio shows the redox condition of the deposition environment of the sediments except few samples of wells Pinodah-01 and Lunka-01 and completely well Phulasar-01 deposition of sediments in the oxidation environment, which shows poor generation of oil and gas.

Keywords Mӧssbauer, Sediments, Basin, Redox, Environment.
Introduction

Mössbauer spectroscopy is widely used for the study of geological samples including all types of sediments for mineralogical identification, investigation of the oxidation states and site population of the iron and identification of iron-bearing minerals, and the semi-quantitative analysis of iron distribution in each mineral and lattice site [1]. It is well known that the oxidation state of iron metal in sediments is a measurement of the oxidation-reduction condition of sedimentation. It is the only technique that provides crucial information about the ferrous/ferric ratio in sediments. To get better insight into the application of 57Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy for geological samples [2].57Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy is particularly useful for the characterization of iron-bearing species because it probes the local environment of iron nuclei sensitivity. This method offers certain advantages over other conventional techniques such as chemical, optical, electron microscopic analysis, etc. Indeed each technique has its own strength, but where Mössbauer spectroscopy can give results, it offers a quick reliable and simple method. Being a non-destructive technique in the sense that the sample either in powder form or thin slice is not altered during the experiment also in a single run, one can get information about all the iron phases present in the sample by proper de-convolution of the Mössbauer spectrum. Mössbauer spectroscopy is also used widely to study organic-rich sediments (source rocks) from the different petroliferous basins. In fact source rocks are tiny generators of oil/gas or both. Source rock characterization is one of the important aspects of the exploration of oil/gas. This distribution of minerals suggests that North Sea offshore sediments were deposited in a highly reducing environment. It is worthwhile to note that the offshore region is a major oil field off the North Sea. The detailed study of the chemical state of iron in subsurface sediments for four differ tiny of minerals including iron-bearing minerals, e.g. if the rate of sedimentation is fast it quickly cuts off sediment from the environment and this may favor the formation of minerals like pyrite which are digenetically stable in reducing environment. Simultaneously organic matter also escapes oxidation and becomes more favorable for the generation of oil. But if the sedimentation rate is slow sediments will remain in contact with the atmosphere for more time. This may result in oxidation of organic matter making it unfavorable for the generation of oil and favors minerals like siderite, iron oxide etc. depending upon the degree of redox condition. This correlation can also be viewed that the physicochemical transformation of organic matter during the geological history of the sedimentary basin cannot be regarded as an isolated process. It is controlled by the same major factors that determine the variation of the composition of the inorganic solid phase of sediments; that is to say, biological activities in the early stage, and temperature and pressure afterward decide the evolution of both the organic matter and the inorganic solids[3-7].

Aim of study To study generation of oil and gas in sedimentary source rocks.
Review of Literature

Mössbauer spectroscopy is also used to study various shale deposits from different basins (Cluff, 1987; Cole et al., 1978; Karl and Zukermann, 1981; Leventhal and Hosterman, 1982; Lineback, 1970; Ross and Bustin, 2007 and Pisuotto et al., 1992). On the basis of these studies it has been hypothesized that the organically rich oil/gas shales were formed in an anoxic environment while the kerogen poor shales were formed in an environment high in oxygen cf. Maynard, (1982). On the basis of these studies it is expected that iron in minerals will be in more reduced state in those shale deposits which are favorable to produce shale oil/shale gas relatively to those shale deposits which are not favorable for shale oil/shale gas. Mørup et al., (1985) have reported relative distribution of iron bearing minerals as a function of depth in inorganic rich Cenozoic and Mesozoic subsurface sedimentary samples (source rocks) from North Sea Danish oil field. It is worth noting that in Danish North Sea though offshore area show large reserve of oil/gas but on-shore wells were found to be dry. In their study they found that relative distribution of iron bearing minerals was markedly different in these two regions. While offshore wells show presence of iron in Fe2+ state in pyrite and clay minerals in onshore wells there is appreciable amount of iron was present in Fe3+ state and siderite. This is consistent with the hypothesis of (Maynard, 1982). In follow up this chemical state of iron was also studied by our Mössbauer group, at Jodhpur in sub surface sediments of different petroliferous basins of India cf. (Tripathi et al., 2008; Ram et al., 1997; Ram et al., 1998; Nigam et al., 1989; Kulshrestha et al., 2000 and Bhatia et al., 2012 etc). These studies also suggest that Mössbauer spectroscopy can be used as one more additional tool for characterization of organic rich sediments.

The Bikaner-Nagaur basin could probably be an extension of the infra-Cambrian tectonic-depositional system of the Arabian platform. The eastern flank of the Indus Shelf including Bikaner-Nagaur, Jaisalmer and Barmer-Sanchor remained uplifted from Middle Eocene to Pliocene and supplied classics to the fluvial Basin to the southwest. However, during Quaternary, thin veneer of the fluvial sediments covered middle Eocene sediments prominent east-west basement of high trend acts as a structural trap for oil accumulation. Broadly two sedimentary systems clastic-carbonate system and the clastic dominant system had been observed in this basin[8-15].In the present investigation, we have further extended Mössbauer spectroscopic studies of deep subsurface sediments collected from two representative wells Lunkha-1, Pinodha-1 and Phulasar-1 wells of Bikaner–Nagaur basin.

Methodology

Mössbauer absorber was prepared by sandwiching finely ground sediment samples between two paper discs, in a sample holder (25 mm in diameter). Thickness of the absorber was always kept nearly constant (about 100 mg/cm2 ). The isomer shift (IS) values are reported with respect to the centroid of a 25 lm thick an iron foil obtained from M/S FAST COM Tech., Germany. The 57Co embedded in Rhodium matrix was used as a Mössbauer source (the initial strength of source was 10 m Ci). During the work the stability of the system was checked periodically by taking standard iron spectrum. All the Mössbauer spectra were recorded at the room temperature (300 K). Computer programme written by Meerwal [16] was used for data fitting after suitable modifications. The programme assumes the spectrum to be the sum of Lorentzians. In most of cases, the width and intensity of the two halves of a quadruple doublet were constrained to be equal. In the case of a sextet, the width of all the peaks and the intensities of 1st and 6th, 2nd and 5th, and 3rd and 4th peaks were constrained to be equal. The solid lines in the spectra represent computer-fitted curves and dots represent the experimental points. The value of Chi-square (χ2 ) reflects the quality of fitness. But many times the larger value of chi-square was also accepted if iteration does not improve the fitting further and also when fitting provides the physically acceptable parameters[16].

Sampling

Mӧssbauer spectra at room temperature:

Mössbauer spectra of the samples of the wells Pinodah-01, Lunka-01 and Phulasar-01 recorded at room temperature as shown below

Figure1.1 Mӧssbauer spectra at room temperature of the Pinodah-01 well at different depths (retrace)


Figure1.2 Mӧssbauer spectra at room temperature of the Lunka-01 well at different depths(retrace)

Figure1.3 Mӧssbauer spectra at room temperature of the Phulasar-01 well at different depths

Tools Used Meerwal Software
Analysis

Pinodah-01

Lunka-01

Phulasar-01

Depths(m)

Fe2+/Fe3+

Depths(m)

Fe2+/Fe3+

Depths(m)

Fe2+/Fe3+

540

0.703

520

1.309

1127

0.235

570

0.740

570

3.545

1191

3.177

585

0.000

595

1.638

1213

0.000

618

0.000

620

12.736

1247

1.056

1244

0.937

695

0.000

1297

0.481

1364

0.985

1740

0.000

1315

0.000

1404

1.074

1910

0.616

1335

0.145

1446

2.186

 

 

1385

0.000

1460

1.888

 

 

1387

0.330

1582

5.157

 

 

1427

0.689

1676

0.732

 

 

1451

0.189

 

 

 

 

1505

0.894

Table-01: Ferric-ferrous ratio of the sediments of the different test wells of the Bikaner-Nagaur basin

Conclusion

Mössbauer parameters viz isomer shift (IS), quadruple splitting (QS), full line width at half maximum (LW), relative area (A) and hyperfine magnetic field (HMF) obtained for various samples of well Lunkha-1, Pinodha-1 are as in previously reported in the publish work(Beena,et.al.2012).In present study of The Phulasar well-01 also the same procedure for assignment of doublets was followed accordingly, in the present work doublet marked as BB/ are attributed to iron present in mineral siderite and AA/ are attributed to iron present in mineral pyrite. The doublet DD/ is attributed to iron in high spin Fe2+ state in some silicate minerals, doublet CC/ to high spin Fe3+ iron in some silicate matrix. When more than one doublet corresponding to Fe3+ in silicate minerals are resolved they are marked as C1C0/1 and C2C02 . In some samples doublets exhibit anomalous Mössbauer parameters. In some samples doublets exhibit anomalous Mössbauer parameters. Such parameters are hitherto not reported in sedimentary samples. Such doublets are marked as doublet NN/.

References

1. Mørup Steen, Franck Jørgen et. al., Mössbauer spectroscopy study of the chemical state of iron in Danish Mesozoic sediments, FUEL, V. 64, 1985.

2. Hoffman E., Seifu, D. et. al. , Axtell and Allende: A Mössbauer spectroscopy study, Meteoritic and planetary Science 35,431-434(2000).

3. Tominaga, T., Minai, Y.,. Applications of Mössbauer spectroscopy to environmental and geochemical studies. Nuclear Science Application 749e791(1984).

4. Meena, S.S et.al., Mössbauer Studies on The Test Well P#1 Located in Phulasar Structure of Bikaner-Nagaur Basin of Rajasthan, India, International Journal of Engineering, Management & Sciences (IJEMS) ISSN-2348 – 3733, Volume-3, Issue-9, September (2016).

5. Tripathi R. P. et. al., 57Fe Mössbauer Spectroscopy study of organic rich sediments (source rocks) from test well CT-1, Chinnewala structure of Jaisalmer basin, India, Geoscience Frontiers (2015)

6. Bhatia, B., Tripathi, A., Sharma, R., Tripathi, R.P.,. 57Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy study of sediments collected from test wells drilled in the BikanereNagaur basin. Fuel 98, 140e148(2012).

7. Ram, S., Patel, K.R., Sharma, S.K., Tripathi, R.P.,. Distribution of iron in siderite in sub-surface sediments of Jaisalmer Basin (India) using Mössbauer spectroscopy. Fuel 77 (13), 1507e1512(1998).

8. Wagner F.E., Wagner U. Mössbauer Spectra of Clays and Ceramics. Hyperfine Interactions, v.154, pp.35- 82(2004).

9. Mathur, S.C., Gaur, S.D., Loyal, R.S., Tripathi,A., and Sisodiya, M.S. Spherules in the Fatehgarh Formation(Cretaceous) of Barmer Basin, India. Gondwana Res.,V. 8,pp.579-584(2005a).

10. Compton Paul. M. The Geology of the Barmer Basin, Rajasthan, India and the origins of its major oil Reservoir, The Fatehgarh Formation, Petroleum Geoscience,V.15, pp.117-130, (2009).

11. Dalson, J.D., Burley, S.D. and Sunder, V.R. The Discovery of the Barmer Basin Rajasthan, India and its petrology, AAPG Bull., V.99,pp.433-46(2015).

12. Meena, S.S, Mössbauer Spectroscopic Study of the Sedimentary Samples Collected from Barmer Hill Formation of Northern Barmer Basin, Western Rajasthan (India), IJIRET, Vol. 5, Issue 7, July 2016.

13. Sonal Mathur et.al., Mössbauer Spectroscopic Study of phosphatic sediments collected from Fetahgarh Formation of Northern Barmer basin, Western Rajasthan, Journal Geological society of India vol.94 pp 590-594 Dec. 2019.

14. Meena, S.S et.al., 57Fe Mössbauer Spectroscopic Study of Sedimentary Samples from Goru Formation in Well MNW-1 of Jaisalmer Basin, Rajasthan, India, Journal of Pure and Applied Science & Technology, V, pp.18-26, ol.7(2), Jul 2017.

15. Mridula, Bohra, et.al., Mössbauer Spectroscopic Study of samples from Cambay Shale formation, cambay basin,in context of shale gas and shale oil, Journal Geological society of India vol.96 pp 603-608 Dec. 2020.

16. E. V. Meerwall, “A least-square spectral curve fitting routine for strongly overlapping Lorentzians or Gaussians”, Computer physics communications,Vol. 9, pp. 117-128, 1975.