|
|||||||
Ecofeminism in RK Narayan and Munshi Premchand Novel |
|||||||
Paper Id :
18749 Submission Date :
2024-03-09 Acceptance Date :
2024-03-23 Publication Date :
2024-03-25
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. DOI:10.5281/zenodo.10949436 For verification of this paper, please visit on
http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/anthology.php#8
|
|||||||
| |||||||
Abstract |
Ecofeminism is one of the branches of the feminism and it
examines and depicts the link between women and nature. In order to preserve
the mother Earth, it is important to achieve the goals of sustainable
development. But for this it is important to bring gender equality in our
society because this goal cannot be achieved without the contribution of women.
‘Gender equality and empowerment of all women and girls’ has also been included
by UN as one of the main Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in its 2030
agenda. Ecofeminist mainly developed this concept of ecofeminism by developing
the link between the women and the nature. This paper mainly analysis the
concept of ecofeminism and sustainable development in RK Narayan’s “A tiger for
Malgudi” and Munshi Premchand’s “Nirmala.” This paper has further dealt with
the question of contribution of women in sustainable development and protection
of the nature. It also puts light on how the women are changing and developing
with the time and how they are becoming independent and contributing in almost
every field. The conclusion deals with the development of the concept of
ecofeminism and role of authors like RK Narayan and Munshi Premchand in it and
also highlight few examples of women contribution in sustainable development. |
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Keywords | Ecofeminism, RK Narayan, Munshi Premchand, Novel. | ||||||
Introduction | RK Narayan and Munshi Premchand are one of the most famous
Indian authors. Both have dealt with social issues prevalent in the society.
Ecofeminism is one of the branches of the feminism and it examines and depicts
the link between women and nature. Since Vedic times we have seen nature as a
mother figure and the reason behind this is that these connections are
illustrated through traditionally feminine value such as reciprocity, nurturing
and cooperation which are present among both women and nature. This connection
between the nature and women can be seen by drawing the connection between the
menstruation cycle and moon cycle and the ability of women to give life is like
that of mother Earth’s ability of creation. Ecofeminism: In order to understand the concept of ecofeminism first it is
necessary to understand what feminism is. Feminism is the result of continuance
subjugation of women in the society at the hands of the men. Feminism can be
described as a political movement and an ideology that seeks to advance the
social role of women and protect and promote the rights of the women. There have been
many waves of feminism and the first wave of feminism mainly focused on
political rights of women. The core principle of feminism
is to change the patriarchal mindset of people in the
society because patriarchy is an ideology that advocates the subordination on
women and empowers the men. There are multiple forms of feminism liberal
feminism, Marxist feminism, post-modern feminism, radical feminism, and ecofeminism is one of them. “A ecofeminist perspective would involve the coming together of ecocriticism and ecofeminism
into one analytical focus, where it would be necessary to recognize that the
exploitation of nature and the oppression of women are intimately bound up with notions of class, caste, race, colonialism and neo-colonialism.”[1] Nature and
women are also related through the shared history of repression, suppression,
and oppression by the patriarchal society. Females have always been exploited
and suppressed by the men in the society and in the same manner the human beings are continuously deteriorating the nature and its
resources on the name of the development. “The human
sciences study biological, social, and cultural aspects of human life, as well
as the behavior and relation of human beings with other entities; this has
paved the way for the rise of discourses like ecofeminism to solve problems
related to women and nature.”[2] According to Webster’s New World Encyclopedia, “ecofeminism is a movement or theory that applies feminist principles and ideas to ecological issues.” it is one of the forms of feminism which has emanated through the amalgamation of feminism and environmentalism. The term ‘ecofeminism’ was coined by Francoise de Eaubonne in 1974. She used it “to call upon women to lead an ecological evolution to save the planet” (Merchant 184).[3] In Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary, ecofeminism is
defined as “a philosophical and political theory and movement which combines
ecological concerns with feminist ones regarding both as resulting from the
male domination of the society.”[4] |
||||||
Objective of study | The aim of study of this paper is ecofeminism in RK Narayan and Munshi Premchand novel. |
||||||
Review of Literature | Literature Review of RK Narayan’s “A Tiger for Malgudi” Rasipuram Krishnaswamy Iyer Narayanaswamy (RK Narayana) was a famous Indian
writer, known for his collection of works and writings set in the fictional
town of Malgudi in South India. He was one of the most eminent and famous
writers of early Indian literature. “A Tiger for Malgudi” is one of the famous works of Indian author R.K.
Narayan. The book is written from the perspective of a tiger named Raja, who in
his elderly stage recounts his life, while being in an exhibit in the Malgudi
zoo. By personifying Raja, the novel elevates the experiences and emotions of
animals, which are often neglected by their captors, thereby promoting a
culture of nonviolence between humans and animals. The novel tries to present
the selfish nature of human with the help of the character of “captain” who
tortures and exploits Raja for his benefit. Raja, the main character of the
story, has seen a lot of ups and downs in his life and he recalls how the other
animals in jungle were used to afraid of him. He established his dominance over
them and he punishes other animals if they don’t respect him. when his
supremacy was challenged by a tigress, he fought with her but on the advice of
a jackal he became her mate. But the incident of killing of his family by the
hunters devastated him and he developed as a beast and started attacking the
villagers. Terrified by Raja, the villagers approached the authorities but Raja
was then caught by “Captain” who was a circus owner and he used Raja as a
source of income. Distressed by the torture of Captain he accidently killed him
and escaped from his grasp. Then he reached in a city but now he was more
interested in enjoying his freedom rather than killing and terrifying people.
He went to a school and slept quietly in headmaster’s office then he met the
person whom he called “master.” After this incident Raja’s life was completely
changed. Master taught Raja a lot new things and now he has completely changed.
They both travelled together and spread the message of non-violence. Finally,
they reached the mountains and make their home in a cave. As Raja has grown older it became difficult for him to hunt and survive on
his own that’s why the master called a Zookeeper who promised to take care of Raja
and then master asked Raja to go with him to the Zoo and make children and
other people happy. At the end of the novel, they both part ways and master
told him that after this life their spirits will meet again. The novel “A Tiger for Malgudi” beautifully shows a companionship between a
human and an animal and it also beautifully portrays the spiritual journey of
both of them and gives a message of non-violence and freedom. Literature Review of Munshi Prem Chand’s Novel “Nirmala”: Munshi Premchand was one of India's independent, bold, and progressive
writers. He always raised social issues and focused on the lives of common
people. Through his book “Nirmala” he raised women's issues in a highly
conservative society, regardless of the consequences. This novel has
beautifully presented the evils such as dowry, child marriage, sexual
harassment, subjugation of women etc., prevailing in our society. Premchand
said it was written with the specific purpose of exposing one particular Social
Evil, namely “UN EQUAL MARRIAGES” i.e. marriages between old men and girls young enough to
be their daughters.[5] Munshi
Perm Chand has strongly presented his opinions that women are the central
pillar of Indian society and the foundation of the entire structure of Indian
society. Nirmala was first published in twelve parts between November 1925 and
November 1926 in Chand magazine. It was a huge success and is still studied
today as one of the canonical texts of Indian literature. It is a kind of
revolutionary social novel. “Munshi
Premchand’s Nirmala, first published in 1928 is a touching tale of a sixteen-
year- old girl whose life is bartered by the very hands of fate when she is
made to marry an aged widower – a matchless match.”[6] This novel
depicts the story of many women caught in a prison of this patriarchal society.
It revolves around the main female character named Nirmala. It depicts how her
unfortunate fate and the patriarchal mindset of the other characters of the
story led her into a forced marriage with a man who is almost double of her
age. This breaks the dreams of her of having a happy romantic and peaceful
married life. She was married at the age of sixteen with the person named
Totaram who was around forty and had three children. Nirmala is shown as a
typical woman of soft heart who accepted her fate. After this marriage she had
no attraction or affection for her husband but she has been portrayed as a good
mother who developed good relations with her stepsons. Totaram’s eldest son
Mansaram was of her age and she used to learn English from him and enjoyed his
company. They had no attraction towards each other but their bond sown the
seeds of doubt in her husband’s mind so he decided to send his son to hostel.
Due to his father’s groundless and distorted thinking Mansaram felt ashamed and
he lost all his interest in life and eventually he died. This incident
shattered his father and after this gradually he lost all his three sons two by
death and one has renounced the world and became a monk. Nirmala gave birth to
a girl child but Totaram blamed her for his bad condition and said: “Get out of my sight or I won’t be answerable for what I do! All this is your doing. It’s entirely
because of you that I have been reduced to this condition. Was this the state
of my home six years ago? You have destroyed my well-established home, uprooted my flourishing garden... I
didn’t bring you into this house to have my whole world destroyed. I wanted to make my happy
existence even happier. And this is the price I am paying.”[7] One more
horrified incident took place in Nirmala’s life which shattered her, one day
her friend’s husband tried to sexually exploit her but he was red handed caught
by his wife Sudha and due to shame he committed suicide. At the end of the
story, she died and finally get liberated from her pathetic and wretched life. This book
awfully depicts the social evils of society against the women and describes how
a woman is exploited and blamed for the situation that the males are facing in
the family. Analysis of
role played by women for sustainable development Sustainable
development means the moving towards the development and meet the need of
present without compromising the needs of the future generation. It mainly
talks about thoughtful use of natural resources available instead of its
exploitation which also results in environmental degradation. Sustainable
development depends on the fair distribution of natural resources for today and for the future.
It cannot be achieved without gender equality. Women’s empowerment is a key
factor for achieving sustainable economic growth, social development and
environmental sustainability.[8] Michelle Obama once said, “no country
can ever truly flourish if it stifles the potential
of its women and deprives itself of the contributions of half of its
citizens”.[9] The goal of sustainable development cannot be achieved
without the half of the population of the world and for that gender equality is
important. Attaining full
gender equality globally can increase the world GDP by up to USD 28 trillion by
2025. Even the United Nations has included ‘gender equality and empowerment of
all women and girls’ as one of the main Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in
its 2030 agenda.[10] Women play a central role in environmental sustainability
and natural resource management. They are the primary carers and providers of
food and water, women have traditional knowledge and expertise in sustainable
agriculture, biodiversity conservation and renewable energy practices because
women in rural areas spend most of their time in activities like agriculture,
collecting woods for fuel, water etc. in order to effectively implement the
sustainable practices and deal with the problem of climate change women’s
participation in decision making is necessary. Nature and
women are way more similar to each other so women can have better understanding
of the nature and natural resources and can help in decision making in order to
protect the environment. Today is the time to change the age-old patriarchal
mindset of the male dominated society so that both women and nature can be
protected from being exploited. There are many Indian women writers who have
written on the concept of ecofeminism such as “Nectar in a sieve” (1954)
by Kamala Markandya, “Fire on the Mountain” (1977) by Anita Desai, “A
Riversutra” (1993) by Gita Mehta, “The God of Small Things” (1997)
by Arundhati Roy, “Staying Alive: Women, Ecology and Development”
(1988), by Vandana Shiva, “Woman and Nature: The Roaring Inside Her” (1978), by
Susan Griffin, “How Women Can Save The Planet” (2021), by Anne Karpf and
many more books and writers are there. Though the
characters of novels of both R.K. Narayan and Munshi Premchand have not done
any rule breaking thing or have brought any significant change but still the
impact of those cannot be ignored. Both has portrayed women as a traditional
Indian woman full of love and motherhood, caught in the web of patriarchal
society, struggling and fighting against the norms and rules of the orthodox
society. In “The Dark
Room” R.K Narayan has portrayed two contrasting female characters Savitri,
a traditional Indian house wife and Shanta Bai, a woman with modern values and
thoughts. Savitri took stand against her husband’s behaviour and she left the
home, this shows her way or revolting against the orthodox patriarchy
prevailing in Indian society. The character Rosie in R.K Narayan’s “The
Guide” is quite like Savitri but unlike Savitri Rosie is a woman with
strong will and thought after facing the deception from the love of her life
Raju she decided to lead her own life and not to be a mere puppet at the hands
of her husband. Daise in “The Painter of Signs” is very different from
the female characters of R.K Narayan in other novels. Unlike others who are
engaged in their own struggle against the societal taboos and restrictions, she
is an example of modern women who believes in making her own decisions and
lives her life for herself. Munshi
Premchand was one of the eminent writers in Hindi Literature. His female characters
are more related to the traditional Indian woman who is humble, polite, has
quality of acceptance and sacrifice etc. Gangi in “Thakur ka Kaun” is
one of the most famous characters of his novels. She is a Dalit woman who
breaks the exploiting norms of untouchability prevailed in Indian society and
get water for her ill husband from the well. She is a courageous woman. Suman
in “Sevasadan” follows her path and choose a profession by her choice
even after the societal pressure. Dhania from “Godan” who is wife of
Hari is portrayed as a strong character. She fights against the injustice in
the society, goes against the wish of her husband and help the needy. She is a
bold woman having determination to fight against the evil.
Thus, bot the
writers have portrayed woman as a strong character in their own way. Women are
eligible to play any role and they can handle any responsibility cast on them.
With their ability to have balance between the personal and professional life
and feeling of empathy they can make better decisions. Therefore, women can
play a major role in environment protection and sustainable development. |
||||||
Conclusion |
Ecofeminism has developed as a new branch of feminism and
many writes have contributed in its development through their writings. RK
Narayan has portrayed the subjugation of animals by the human beings and it is
somewhere related to the condition of women in patriarchal society. In Munshi
Premchand’s novel he has shown the societal evils against women. But now a days
the scenario has changed to some extent and women are becoming aware about
their rights and taking their own decisions. Many women have contributed in the
protection and preservation of the environment one of the biggest examples are
the women of Tehiri Garhwal who played an important role not only as
participants but also as the leaders and strategist in the Chipko movement and
one another example is Saalumarada
Thimmakka, also known as “Mata Thimmakka” or “Mother of Trees,” she has planted
more than eight thousand trees and continues the tree plantation campaign at
the age of 112 years. She has been awarded with Padma Shiri for her contribution.
There many more examples of women’s contribution for preservation of the
nature. |
||||||
References | 1. Chanda Priyanka. “Ecofeminism in Indian English Fiction.” International Journal of Educational Research and Technology. https://soeagra.com/ijert/ijertmarch2014/8.pdf 2. Sharnappa, Patil Sangita. “Reconstructing ecofeminism: A study of Kamala Markandaya’s nectar in a sieve.” Claudia Alvares (Reviewing Editor) (2016), Cogent Social Sciences, 2:1, DOI: 10.1080/23311886.2016.1243772 3. Mannan, A.K.M. Masudul. “A Critical Study of The Man-Eater of Malgudi from Ecofeminist Perspectives.” British Journal of Arts and Humanities. ISSN: 2663-7782 (Online) & 2663-7774 (Print) https://doi.org/10.34104/bjah.0210970102 4. bid 5. Dr. Selvi.L.Thillai. “Socialism Depicted In Munshi Premchand’s Novel Nirmala.” https://www.academia.edu/34483911/SOCIALISM_DEPICTED_IN_MUNSHI_PREMCHANDS_NOVEL_NIRMALA 6. Ahmed Farooq. “Munshi Premchand’s Nirmala as a Symbol of Female Predicament.” [VOLUME 5 I ISSUE 3 I JULY – SEPT 2018] e ISSN 2348 –1269, Print ISSN 2349-5138. http://ijrar.com/ Cosmos Impact Factor 4.236 7. (Nirmala, p 181) Premchand, Munshi. (1999). Nirmala. Translated, and with an Afterword, by Alok Rai (Oxford University Press 8. Kumar Arvind. Women and sustainable development - Women’s empowerment is a key factor for achieving sustainable economic growth. 13 May 2012. https://www.indiawaterportal.org/articles/women-and- sustainable-development-womens-empowerment-key-factor-achieving-sustainable 9. Anand Priyanka. “Role of women is integral to a sustainable future.” Times of India. March 9, 2022. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/voices/role-of-women-is-integral-to-a-sustainable-future/ 10. bid |