|
Digital Anthropology: Mobile Phone
Usage and Social Change among Urban Youth in Prayagraj
|
|
Paper Id :
20029 Submission Date :
2025-04-08 Acceptance Date :
2025-04-21 Publication Date :
2025-04-25
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
DOI:10.5281/zenodo.15310822
For verification of this paper, please visit on
http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/shinkhlala.php#8
|
Vishakha Srivastava
Ex- Student
Anthropology
University Of Allahabad
Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh, India
|
|
|
Abstract
|
This
research explores the intersection of technology and culture through the lens
of digital anthropology, focusing on mobile phone usage among urban youth in
Prayagraj, India. Employing qualitative ethnographic methods, including
participant observation and semi-structured interviews, the study reveals how
mobile phones influence communication patterns, identity construction,
relationships, and socio-cultural values. The findings suggest that mobile
phones serve as tools of empowerment, social connectivity, and self-expression,
while also introducing challenges related to digital dependency and shifting
interpersonal dynamics.
|
Keywords
|
Digital Anthropology, Mobile Phones, Youth Culture, Urban India, Social Change, Prayagraj. |
Introduction
|
The
rise of mobile phone technology has redefined the fabric of everyday life
across the globe. In the context of India—home to one of the world’s largest
and fastest-growing populations of mobile users—this transformation is
especially significant among the youth, who not only adapt to new technologies
swiftly but also actively participate in reshaping cultural and social
landscapes through digital means. As digital connectivity expands beyond
metropolitan hubs into Tier-II cities like Prayagraj, the need to understand the
socio-cultural implications of this shift becomes ever more pressing.Digital
anthropology, a relatively recent but rapidly evolving subfield, focuses on the
intersection of human culture and digital technology. It moves beyond viewing
technology as a neutral tool, instead exploring how digital devices—such as
mobile phones—become embedded within specific cultural, social, and economic
contexts. Through this lens, mobile phones are seen not merely as instruments
for communication, but as dynamic cultural artifacts that influence how
individuals relate to themselves, to others, and to the world around them.Prayagraj,
formerly known as Allahabad, provides a compelling site for such inquiry. As a
city with deep religious roots, historical significance, and a growing urban
infrastructure, it straddles tradition and modernity in complex ways. The youth
of Prayagraj—shaped by the city’s unique blend of conservatism and
cosmopolitanism—occupy a liminal space where inherited cultural values coexist
with global digital trends. For these young individuals, mobile phones are not
only gateways to information and entertainment but also platforms for
self-expression, identity formation, peer interaction, and resistance to
established social norms.This
paper aims to explore how urban youth in Prayagraj use mobile phones in their
everyday lives and what this reveals about broader patterns of social change.
It examines how mobile technology is transforming interpersonal communication,
educational practices, romantic relationships, gender roles, and community
engagement. Special attention is paid to how digital spaces—particularly social
media platforms—allow youth to experiment with identity, negotiate traditional
restrictions, and forge new forms of belonging.Several
key questions guide this research: - How
do mobile phones influence the way young people in Prayagraj form and maintain
social relationships?
- In
what ways do mobile-mediated interactions reflect or challenge traditional
social structures such as caste, gender, and family hierarchy?
- How
do youth perceive and navigate digital risks such as surveillance, peer
pressure, and identity anxiety in their use of mobile phones?
To
answer these questions, this study draws on ethnographic methods characteristic
of digital anthropology, including in-depth interviews, participant
observation, and analysis of digital behavior. By focusing on Prayagraj’s
youth, the research provides a localized yet insightful perspective on how
global technological shifts intersect with deeply rooted cultural frameworks,
offering new understandings of how digital devices are reconfiguring life in
contemporary urban India. Ultimately,
this research underscores the importance of contextual and grounded analyses in
the study of digital cultures. In doing so, it contributes to broader
discussions on youth agency, cultural adaptation, and the socio-technical
evolution of Indian society in the digital age.
|
Objective of study
|
This research underscores the importance of contextual and grounded analyses in
the study of digital cultures. In doing so, it contributes to broader
discussions on youth agency, cultural adaptation, and the socio-technical
evolution of Indian society in the digital age. |
Review of Literature
|
For this paper many books, online literature and government reports i.e. Miller, D., & Horst, H. (2012). Digital Anthropology, Donner, J. (2008) Research approaches to mobile use in the developing world: A review of the literature, Sundaram, R. (2016). Pirate Modernity: Delhi’s Media Urbanism, Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI). (2023). Annual Report on Mobile Usage Patterns have been reviewed. |
Methodology |
This qualitative study uses
ethnographic tools: - Participant
observation in schools, colleges, cafés, and public spaces
- In-depth
interviews with 45 individuals aged 16–30 from diverse socio-economic
backgrounds
- Focus
group discussions on themes of digital identity, social media, and peer
interaction
- Secondary
sources including census data, telecom reports, and scholarly
literature on digital anthropology
- The study was conducted
between September 2024 and January 2025 in urban prayagraj.
|
Analysis
|
Prayagraj and Youth Culture - Prayagraj, formerly known as
Allahabad, is one of India’s oldest and most culturally significant cities.
Situated at the confluence (Sangam) of the Ganga, Yamuna, and the mythical
Saraswati rivers, the city holds immense religious value and is home to the
iconic Kumbh Mela, one of the largest religious gatherings in the world.
Historically a hub for saints, scholars, poets, and freedom fighters, Prayagraj
has long stood at the intersection of sacred traditions and intellectual
progress. It has housed some of India’s premier educational institutions, such
as the University of Allahabad, which earned the title “Oxford of the East”
during the colonial period.
- In recent decades, Prayagraj
has undergone notable urbanization and digital transformation. The city has
expanded its infrastructure, seen rising aspirations among its population, and
experienced the influence of digital globalization—particularly through the
proliferation of smartphones and internet access. This transition is especially
visible among the city’s youth, who occupy a critical demographic group
navigating both inherited values and contemporary global influences.
- Youth in Prayagraj are
situated within a unique cultural and developmental context. Many belong to
middle- and lower-middle-class families where traditional values around family
honor, gender norms, religion, and caste remain significant. However, they are
also increasingly exposed to modern ideas through digital platforms, mass
media, and educational spaces. This juxtaposition creates a tension that
defines their lived experience—one marked by negotiation, adaptation, and
transformation.
- The youth culture in Prayagraj
is thus dynamic and multifaceted. Students and young professionals are active
on social media, use mobile phones for education and entertainment, and often
consume global digital content alongside local media. Mobile phones provide
them with tools for expanding their social networks, asserting individuality,
and engaging with public discourse, even as they remain embedded in social
structures that emphasize community over individualism.
- Furthermore, mobile phone
usage among Prayagraj’s youth is deeply gendered. While both young men and
women are active digital users, their experiences diverge in terms of access,
surveillance, and autonomy. Boys often have greater freedom in terms of device
ownership and unsupervised internet use. Girls, on the other hand, often face
restrictions from families concerned with safety, morality, and social
reputation. In this context, the mobile phone becomes not only a technological
device but also a symbolic site of gender politics and youth empowerment.
- Language also plays an
important role in shaping youth engagement with mobile technology. Bilingual or
multilingual usage (Hindi, English, and local dialects like Awadhi) is common
in digital spaces, reflecting the hybridity of youth identities. Social media
posts, memes, YouTube comments, and WhatsApp messages often blend languages to
produce a unique digital vernacular that resonates with local sensibilities
while signaling modernity.
- Cultural events, religious
festivals, college functions, and street spaces in Prayagraj have increasingly
integrated digital practices—such as mobile photography, live streaming, and
social media tagging—into their rituals. These phenomena illustrate how the
city’s youth are not passively consuming digital culture but actively
participating in reshaping it.
- In essence, Prayagraj serves
as a compelling case study of how mobile phones are not only adopted as tools
for utility but also incorporated into the daily performances, negotiations,
and aspirations of young urban Indians. The city's youth are both shaped by and
shaping the digital culture around them, forging hybrid identities that
straddle the sacred and the secular, the local and the global, the traditional
and the modern.
|
Result and Discussion
|
The ethnographic exploration
of mobile phone usage among urban youth in Prayagraj reveals that digital
technology is not merely adopted but is actively adapted, localized, and
embedded within the city’s socio-cultural context. Through this discussion, we
delve deeper into the broader implications of the findings by linking them to
theoretical frameworks in digital anthropology, youth studies, and Indian
socio-cultural dynamics.
Mobile Phones as Sites
of Cultural Hybridity
- Drawing from Homi Bhabha’s
concept of hybridity, it is evident
that the youth of Prayagraj navigate a cultural “third space” where traditional
norms and digital modernities converge. Mobile phones, and particularly social
media platforms, become hybrid cultural arenas where religious symbolism can
coexist with global pop culture; where a meme in Awadhi might be followed by a
quote from an American influencer; and where rituals like Raksha Bandhan are
both enacted offline and performed online through posts and digital
dedications.
- This hybridity is not merely
aesthetic—it signifies deeper negotiations of cultural identity. Rather than a
linear shift from tradition to modernity, youth engage in a dialogic process
where both are continuously reinterpreted and reconstructed.
Reconfiguring Social
Relationships and Intimacies
- Mobile phone usage is
transforming the texture of interpersonal relationships. The boundaries between
public and private, formal and informal, are increasingly blurred. For
instance, WhatsApp groups replace community gatherings, while Instagram stories
become arenas of romantic signaling or peer status assertion.
- These digital intimacies are
reshaping traditional social hierarchies. Romantic relationships, once highly
surveilled and regulated in physical spaces, now take refuge in encrypted chats
and virtual exchanges. However, this does not imply total liberation—social
pressures re-enter the digital sphere through parental monitoring, screenshot
culture, or moral policing.
- Interestingly, the notion of
“respectability” has expanded to digital domains. For example, girls navigate
dual expectations: to be visible and likable online, yet modest and controlled
in expression. This duality illustrates Michel Foucault’s concept of self-surveillance,
where individuals internalize societal norms and reproduce them within digital
behavior.
The Digital Gender
Order: Control, Access, and Resistance
- Gendered experiences of
digital space are among the most significant findings of this study. Male youth
generally experience mobile technology as a space of exploration and freedom.
For female youth, it is simultaneously a tool for empowerment and a site of
surveillance and restriction. Families often regulate girls’ online presence
under the guise of protection and honor, reflecting the patriarchal values
deeply entrenched in urban Indian society.
- Yet, the digital also becomes
a subversive space. Many young women employ pseudonyms, locked apps, and secret
accounts to bypass restrictions and reclaim agency. In this, mobile phones
function as what de Certeau might call “tactical tools”—devices through which
individuals resist dominant power structures using everyday strategies.
- These acts of digital
resistance are subtle but significant—they signal shifts in how gender roles
are negotiated and contested in postcolonial urban contexts.
Digital Inequalities:
Class, Language, and Technological Capital
- While mobile phone penetration
is high, the quality of access
remains unequal. Pierre Bourdieu’s idea of cultural
capital helps frame the disparities among youth. Those from English-medium,
middle-class backgrounds not only have better devices and faster connectivity
but also possess the digital literacy to navigate online spaces confidently. In
contrast, students from lower-income families often struggle with outdated
phones, data limitations, and lack of guidance on utilizing educational or
professional digital resources.
- Moreover, language plays a
crucial role in reinforcing these digital inequalities. English-language
content dominates aspirational and high-value digital spaces (e.g., competitive
exams, job portals, LinkedIn), marginalizing youth who are more fluent in Hindi
or regional dialects. Although vernacular content is growing, the symbolic
power of English as a marker of class and modernity remains strong.
- This suggests that while
mobile phones have the potential to democratize access, they also reproduce and
even exacerbate existing social hierarchies when structural inequalities go unaddressed.
Digital Aspirations and
New Forms of Subjectivity
- One of the most profound
shifts observed is the emergence of new subjectivities shaped by digital
imagination. Youth in Prayagraj do not just use mobile phones passively; they
imagine futures through them. From watching YouTube videos about “how to study
abroad” to following digital influencers from Delhi or New York, the mobile
phone becomes a lens through which alternative life paths are visualized and
desired.
- This aspirational subjectivity
aligns with Arjun Appadurai’s theory of the “capacity to aspire,” where access
to media expands the cognitive map of possibilities. Yet, the gap between
digital dreams and material reality often leads to what scholars term aspirational anxiety—a sense of
inadequacy or frustration when digital exposure outpaces real-world
opportunity.
- Despite this, mobile phones
still serve as motivational devices, offering micro-opportunities for learning,
side hustles, and digital entrepreneurship—even within constraints.
Reimagining Urban Space
and Identity
- The rise of digital practices
among Prayagraj’s youth is also reconfiguring the experience of urban space.
Street corners, parks, tea stalls, and university campuses have become hybrid
zones where offline and online worlds converge. For example, local hangouts are
documented via Instagram reels, turning everyday spaces into curated digital
landmarks.
- Urban identity itself is being
reshaped. While Prayagraj is often imagined in mainstream discourse through its
religious or colonial legacy, its youth are crafting new identities that
incorporate regional pride, street style, digital fluency, and cosmopolitan
aesthetics. This reimagining of the city reflects the power of digital
anthropology to uncover how local cultures are not eclipsed but re-authored in
the digital age.
- The case of Prayagraj
demonstrates that mobile phones are far more than technological
conveniences—they are cultural tools that youth use to make sense of, adapt to,
and subtly transform their world. They are at once sites of conformity and
resistance, access and exclusion, aspiration and anxiety. Through the
anthropological lens, we see that every tap, text, post, and swipe is an act of
social engagement—rooted in historical structures yet open to new futures.
- The study urges us to go
beyond techno-optimism or digital pessimism and instead appreciate the
complexity of mobile phone usage as a deeply embedded cultural phenomenon. In
doing so, we better understand the rapidly evolving contours of youth culture
in contemporary urban India.
|
Findings
|
The ethnographic fieldwork
conducted in Prayagraj between September 2024 and February 2025 yielded rich
insights into the everyday digital practices of urban youth. The mobile phone
emerged not simply as a technological tool but as a socio-cultural object that
mediates identity, relationships, knowledge, aspirations, and power. The
findings reveal several key thematic patterns: Mobile Phones as Tools
of Social Belonging and Performance- Mobile phones—particularly
smartphones—are central to how young people in Prayagraj establish and maintain
social networks. WhatsApp, Instagram, Snapchat, and Facebook dominate their
daily digital interactions. Youth often described these platforms as
"public rooms" where friendships are displayed, relationships are
validated, and personalities are curated.
- Social belonging is expressed
through participation in group chats, sharing memes and videos, using trending
slang, and maintaining daily digital visibility. Digital silence—such as not
posting or replying—can be interpreted as social withdrawal or exclusion. Many
users acknowledged the performative pressure to appear happy, attractive, or
successful online, creating a feedback loop of self-presentation and peer
validation.
The Blurred Boundaries
Between Private and Public Life- Mobile phones have redefined
the contours of privacy for Prayagraj’s youth. Unlike earlier generations, who
often separated public personas from private ones, young people today live in a
state of digital exposure. Sharing personal moments—from meals and outfits to
political opinions and romantic gestures—has become normalized, often shared in
real-time across platforms.
- However, this digital openness
is not without ambivalence. While some youth embrace it as a form of
self-expression and liberation, others expressed anxiety over surveillance by
family members, peers, or romantic partners. Girls, in particular, reported
being cautious about posting photos, using passwords, and hiding online
activity due to concerns about moral judgment or parental scrutiny.
Mobile Phones and the
Reconfiguration of Romantic Relationships- Romantic relationships among
urban youth in Prayagraj have been profoundly impacted by mobile phone usage.
While arranged marriage norms and social taboos still hold sway, mobile
technology offers youth discreet spaces for flirtation, intimacy, and
communication. WhatsApp and Instagram Direct Messaging were described as
primary channels for initiating and maintaining relationships.
- Interestingly, digital
interactions often precede physical meetings. Emojis, memes, audio notes, and
selfies play significant roles in emotional bonding. Yet, these relationships are
fraught with risks—such as ghosting, screenshotting private messages, or
digital blackmail—highlighting the vulnerability that accompanies digital
intimacy.
Digital Gender Divide
and Resistance- While both young men and women
in Prayagraj are active mobile users, their digital experiences are shaped by
unequal access and gendered norms. Girls often face restrictions regarding
screen time, app usage, and online friendships, particularly with boys. Many
reported borrowing phones, sharing devices with siblings, or hiding apps to
avoid parental monitoring.
- Despite these constraints,
mobile phones have also become instruments of subtle resistance. Girls use
phones to access motivational content, health information, feminist pages, and
educational resources that may be censored or stigmatized offline. Some even
described using anonymity features (e.g., fake profiles or pseudonyms) to
participate in debates, express dissent, or explore romantic interest without
direct exposure.
Education, Aspirations, and
Informal Learning- For many young people in
Prayagraj, mobile phones are indispensable educational aids. Students regularly
use YouTube for tutorials, government exam preparation, English learning, and
coding practice. Apps like Byju's, Unacademy, and PDF-sharing platforms are
frequently mentioned as academic lifelines, especially for those lacking access
to private tuition.
- This access to knowledge via
mobile phones is reshaping aspirations. Youth from lower-income families view
smartphones as equalizers—tools that can bridge class divides by providing
access to the same content consumed by elite urban students. However, concerns
over digital distractions, poor time management, and screen addiction were also
commonly voiced by both students and parents.
Negotiating Traditional
Values through Digital Culture- Perhaps most strikingly,
Prayagraj’s youth are engaged in constant negotiation between tradition and
modernity through mobile-mediated interactions. Many continue to uphold
religious practices, family obligations, and community customs while
simultaneously embracing global pop culture, digital aesthetics, and liberal
ideas.
- TikTok (before its ban),
Instagram Reels, and YouTube Shorts were seen as spaces where youth could
express themselves through fashion, dance, poetry, and mimicry—often mixing
Western trends with local cultural references. These digital expressions do not
necessarily reflect a rejection of tradition but rather an adaptive fusion
where young people create new cultural forms.
Emerging Digital
Inequalities- Despite the democratizing
potential of mobile phones, digital usage among youth in Prayagraj also reveals
new forms of inequality. Factors such as device quality, internet speed, data
affordability, digital literacy, and language barriers affect how different
segments of youth engage online.
- English-speaking,
college-educated youth often dominate digital spaces of prestige and
visibility, while those from vernacular-medium schools struggle to find
representation. This digital stratification mirrors and, in some cases,
reinforces existing socio-economic divisions, suggesting that access alone does
not guarantee equity.
|
Conclusion
|
The findings clearly
demonstrate that mobile phones have become embedded in the social fabric of
urban youth culture in Prayagraj. Far from being passive consumers of
technology, young people actively shape and are shaped by the digital
environments they inhabit. Through mobile phones, they assert identities,
challenge norms, express desires, and negotiate power—all while navigating a
complex terrain of opportunity and vulnerability. |
References
|
- Miller, D., & Horst, H.
(2012). Digital Anthropology.
Bloomsbury Academic.
- Donner, J. (2008). Research
approaches to mobile use in the developing world: A review of the literature. The Information Society.
- Sundaram, R. (2016). Pirate Modernity: Delhi’s Media Urbanism.
Routledge.
- Telecom Regulatory Authority
of India (TRAI). (2023). Annual Report on
Mobile Usage Patterns.
- Fieldwork data collected in
Prayagraj (2024–2025).
- https://ansi.gov.in/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Indian-Anthropology-Congress-2025-A-Book-of-Abstracts.pdf
|