|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Political Empowerment of Dalit’s at Grass-root Level: A Study of Kuthari Village in Shimla District of Himachal Pradesh | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Paper Id :
15798 Submission Date :
2022-02-16 Acceptance Date :
2022-02-20 Publication Date :
2022-02-25
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. For verification of this paper, please visit on
http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/innovation.php#8
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Abstract |
in indian society Caste has often been seen as a system of hierarchy based on the social and religious ideology of the Hindus with a same structure across the subcontinent. which is based Based on an extensive field study in the kuthari village of Himachal Pradesh, this study shows how caste actively articulates with the known realities of the indian society, economy and the local histories of political arena. and Even though the inequality and untouchability exist in the present time, at their structures have specific regional forms. While it seen in the everyday life practices of faith and their beliefs local specificities, that this field study analyse that are also have implications for our understanding of the caste system in the present time either todays day to day life in villege or in rural ares it is extremely seen. the himachal pradesh is known as the land of god and godesses people of the state is accepting it as the order of their god.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Keywords | Awareness of Dalit, Through Panchayat Raj Institution, Empowerment, Political Participation and Social Upliftment. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Introduction |
This study makes an attempt to understand the political empowerment of Dalits in Himachal Pradesh by studying the extent of participation and representation of Dalits in local grass root level institutions (i.e. panchayat level) by using secondary sources and with the help of field work in Kuthari village. The present study examines extent of political participation by studying participation of Dalits in Panchayat level election, campaigning and participation in gram sabha meetings and level of representation by studying dalit leadership at the grass-root level. at the kuthari panchyat of district shimla in himachal pradesh and this paper also analyze the how dalit people take decision in panchyat and are the aware of govt. policies.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Objective of study | 1. To study the nature of Dalit,s political participation at grassroots level in Himachal Pradesh.
2. To analyze the socio-political and economic conditions of the Dalits in the state of Himachal Pradesh.
3. To study the level of political consciousness’ among the Dalits in Himachal Pradesh in Kuthari village. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Review of Literature | Kumar (2001) BSP- “Some issues of Democracy and Governance” In this article he tried to analyze how the Indian democracy (mainly for Uttar Pradesh) has directly or indirectly helped in the assertion of the Dalits
Sharma (1987) analyze some aspect of the Continuity and Change among Dumnas as an untouchable caste in Punjab and found spatial educational, occupational, economic and political mobility among the Dumnas in the state of punjab and how they moblize theirself.
Judge and Bal (2009) in their field study, have made an attempt to understand the paradox involved in the changes that are taking place among Dalits in Punjab
Gupta (2004) in his valuable work, “Interrogating Caste”, has made an attempt to analysis the caste structure in Indian society. His work has also tried to explore the close relation between hierarchy and difference
Pai (2004) New “Social and Political Movements” in her study she rightly argued that Dalits have not been able to gain control over village land or introduce change in the structure of land ownership but they have been able to strike at the power of the landed castes by collective identity assertion, educational and economic advancement and establishing their control over panchyati politics. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Main Text |
Political Empowerment While understanding
political empowerment it is an important to throw some light on political
empowerment and different aspects of political empowerment taken in this study. political Empowerment, as a concept is related with the notion of power in politics, in which according
to Weber (1970:80) is ‘the chance of a man or a number of to realize their own
will in a communal action even against the resistance of others who are
participating in the action’. Empowering the Dalits through the state
intervention could be only understood, in the light of Weber’s definition, if
the Dalits are able to carry one’s will one has to have necessary resources.
Therefore the role of the state intervention is aimed at providing that
resource. The reservation of seats in the formal political democratic process
is enabling some dalit to get elected and occupy position of authority. In this
regard, the state intervention has provided the resources and it requires to be
examined whether this resource has been translated into empowerment. (Judge
2009) Political participation Political participation
generally defined in the words of Verba, Schlozman and Brady (1985) as an
“activity that is intended to or has the consequence of affecting, either
directly or indirectly, government action.” A democratic political system by
its very definition is characterized by the fact that power is shared and authoritative
decisions concerning the society are taken by the citizens or by their chosen
decision makers(Thakur, 1984) Political
participation may be defined as the involvement of citizens in such political
acts which directly or indirectly influence the behaviors and action of
decision makers. It also denotes participation in such activities by which the
citizens elect their representatives, empower them to form a government. The
concept of political participation thus includes activities like voting, decision
making in the statutory bodies up to the grassroots level to bring about
changes in the political system. Himachal is the state which has the
second largest population of Dalits in the country after the
neighboring state of Punjab. (Rai. 2006) Dalits have been
socio-economically oppressed, culturally subjected and politically marginalized
for long. (Chaudhary, 2004) Now they have begun to articulate their identity,
asserting not only equality for themselves but also participate in decision
making in the statutory bodies up to the grassroots level to bring about
changes in the political system. The present study attempts to examine the
demographic position of Dalits leadership at the grass-root level in a village
of Himachal Pradesh. The importance of Himachal Pradesh lies not only in its
being a hilly and a border state endowed with scenic beauty, but also in its
rich culture, glorious history, bountiful natural resources and above all the
fast changing socio economic lot of the people including the Dalit.
(Kumar.2006) Himachal a Brief History Himachal Pradesh is a
small state, a hilly region having an area of about 55,673 square kilometers.
The entire state is divided into three ranges, namely lower, middle, and upper
Himalayas. According to the 2001 census, it has a population of 60, 77,248.
Scheduled castes constitute 25.34 percent of the total population of the people
of Himachal Pradesh like those of the sub, Himalayan hills from western Kashmir
to eastern Nepal, are referred to by the generic term PAHARI’(of the
mountains). Two major ancestral stocks, the DOMS’ and the KHASA’ are generally
believed to have contributed to the present PAHARI population. The DOMS
constitute the low caste group like the blacksmith, carpenter, shoemaker,
weaver, tailor, basket maker etc., while the KHASA include the high caste group
like Brahmins’ and Rajputs. The DOMS are believed to be the indigenous people
of the hills and the predecessors of the KHASA. (Gerald 1963) The people of
Himachal Pradesh are predominantly Hindus with 95 percent of its population in
this category. Family, caste and community are the most significant social unit
of society. The people, by and large, are caste-ridden. The PAHARI caste system
is characterized by a twofold division into high caste (Brahmin and Rajputs)
group and low caste groups, who are accorded the status of Achhut
(untouchables). Within each of these classifications, there are status
distinctions. (Gupta.1985) The Economy of state Himachal Pradesh is
predominantly agricultural with 90 percent of its people depending on
agriculture for their livelihood. The state is endowed with extensive natural
resources. It has vast deposits of minerals like salt, gypsum, limestone and
barytes. Horticulture was a symbol of higher status but today Dalits have also
taken to horticulture making it a common vocation without any caste barriers
and which has provided mobility to the lower castes. Although, the upper caste
own more land but Dalits also have a good amount of land. The state has played
an important role to promoting horticulture and nurseries and private
plantation nurseries have been registered, cold storage have been established
and the state government is providing subsidies to farmers, of which is up to
fifty percent is being provided to farmers of belonging to SCs and STs, up to
twenty five percent small farmers and up to thirty three percent to middle
class farmers. The other significant areas contributing to the Himachal economy
are forestry and hydropower production. Industrialization has also started
taking its roots in the last decades; tourism has also been given priority as
an industry. (Sharma 1989) Political profile of
state The period following the
first general election was a period of chequered politics in Himachal Pradesh.
This is a period of political jubilation from the grant of responsible
government in 1952. Administratively Himachal Pradesh consists of twelve
districts seventy five tehsils and seventy five developmental blocks and three
thousand thirty seven villages Panchayat. The state represents seven members to
the parliament four to the lower house and three to the upper house of
parliament. The unicameral legislature of Himachal Pradesh consists of a total
sixty eight members in which sixteen seats are reserved for scheduled caste and
three seats for scheduled tribes. (Sharma.1989) Rohru Block a
profile Rohru Block in District
Shimla is located at a distance of 110 kilometer From Shimla town. It has 29
gram Panchayat and 181 ward panchayat. It has a population 55, 512 percent with
males comprising 28, 214 and females 27, 298. The population of sc is 34.22
percent of the total population comprising 17.14 percent males and 17.07
females. Rohru town is the central place for all the social, political and
economic activities of the people of the area. The people from the village
frequently visit Rohru to meet their daily requirements and also sometimes in
connection with some work in government offices. (Kumar, 2006) All the important
government offices such as the sub judge BPO office, PWD circle, government
hospital, transport and communication etc. are situated at Rohru. Out of the 29
Panchayat in under Rohru Block, the common features is that seven seats
are reserved for women, six are for scheduled caste males and three for SC
females and the remaining thirteen for the general category From the above
mentioned 29 Panchayat, for the study I select village Kuthari Panchayat.
Kuthari Panchayat is situated 30 Km from Rohru Block Sex and Population of
Panchayat in Kuthari Village of Rohru Block in Distt. Shimla
While probing it further, an attempt was made to investigate issues, such as the participation and empowerment of Dalits at the village level. In view of this an in depth study of the village panchayat Kuthari was conducted. In this study an attempt was made to contact all the elected members as well as the selected scheduled caste people of the village panchayat. Observations were made with regard to their socio economic condition and other issues related to their participation and empowerment. This village panchayat which consists of three small villages, namely Kuthari, Nalavan and Jarla for the practical aspect of the study I kept in mind the location, caste composition, distance from the nearby town, educational facilities, extent of development, access to the communication facilities and exposure of the scheduled caste to newer socio economic and political matters. Although the scheduled caste population is scattered in all the three villages of panchayat. Age of the Elected Members of Panchyat
Age wise distribution of
the members reveals that the scheduled castes are relatively younger than upper
caste. The economy of this
village panchayat is dependent on agriculture where three major crops, apple,
peas, and potato, are produced. The land holding of scheduled caste people is
equal to upper caste. There is not much difference between upper and lower
caste land holding. They all have their pucca house. In the past the
scheduled caste who are also called as Achhut (untouchable) in the village panchayat,
were not allowed to take water from the same wells as the upper castes. The
entry in the temple was restricted. But nowadays, this regulation has little
practical application, because people of every caste draw water from a tapped
supply provided by the government and people from the scheduled caste also have
separate water taps in front of their houses and get a regular water supply
provided by the government. Scheduled castes still have separate
cremation ground. As a result of a great breakthrough in the approach of the scheduled caste of this panchayat towards education and realization that education is virtually required for their progress and a secured life in the society. Education is receiving their attention. All the children from scheduled castes are enrolled in the government school and some in convent schools. Education Background of the Panchyat Members
The above table reveals
that the education of the panchayat member. The Pradhan of the village panchayat
has studied up to metric likewise other; a majority of the other members are
educated up to middle standard. The scheduled caste members are no less
educated than upper caste of the panchayat. Explosion of mass media
in the decade of the nineties has also played an important role in increasing
the political knowledge and awareness among the Indian masses. Of late,
television has emerged as an important resource of knowledge. Many scholarly
studies have also pointed towards the role played by the mass media and
television as an agent of political information among Dalits. (Pai 2001) It was notice that all
of dalit household owned the television sets and they get information regarding
the political matters from television. Though it may be reason that television
might be one of the factors responsible for their awareness, some of them
reported to learn about political matters from family members, neighbors’ and
local village leaders, some Dalits told that they often read vernacular
newspapers like Amar ujala, Dainik Bhaskar and Divya Himachal. The electoral politics
in the state of Himachal revolves around the congress and BJP. There is no
regional party in the state majority of the scheduled caste preferred congress
to which most of them have been voting for many years. The BJP has got second
place in the political preferences of Dalits With regard to the
dominance of the upper caste the elected members of the village panchayat felt
that it was a temporary phenomenon and would decline. They think that if the
present policies of scheduled caste welfare and progress continue for a long
time and Dalits themselves strive hard to achieve educational, economic and
political equality, in that case gradually the dominance of the upper castes
will cease to exist in near future. Some scheduled caste people also accept the
dominance of upper caste as an unavoidable phenomenon. They feel that their
social and economic conditions and minority character does not allow them to
overcome the traditional dominance. Political participation
and Representation Regarding political
participation, the scheduled caste had no chance to participate in the decision
making of the village matters. Now there has been a considerable change in the
post-independence era. The factor of reservation has further strengthened their
participation and assertion in village matters. Now their share in power has
further ameliorated their socio economic conditions. At the time the Kuthari
village panchayat had seven elected members, including the Pradhan/Sarpanch.
Out of the seven elected members, three members belong to the scheduled caste
and four from upper caste. Both the position of Pradhan and up-Pradhan belong
to the scheduled caste. The majority population belongs to the upper caste in
the village. This time this seat is reserved for scheduled caste women, she has
no experience to run the affairs of a panchayat. However she was determined to
handle the village matters. She thinks that the high caste people do not give
her the desired cooperation in carrying out the developmental works of the panchayat
on account of her being from the scheduled caste. The higher caste members even
do not attend the meetings of the village panchayat convened by her. The adequate
representation of scheduled caste in the village panchayat has paved the way
for dalit community to assert their demands and problems in the village. With
their empowerment and active participation in the decision making process, the
age old practice of their exploitative on, discrimination and atrocities at the
hands of the high caste also come down considerably. Conversely the
participation of Dalits in different activities, like socio economic and
political, has gone up significantly in the village panchayat. Their plight is
getting reduced and awareness about their interest and well being is
increased. However, according to
her the provision of reservation has considerably increased the participation
of Dalits at the village level. This can also help in building confidence and
social security among lower caste people. She hoped to strengthen it further.
She thinks that she would expedite matters relating to economic help and the
other opportunities to the poor families. The panchayat would provide loans for
cattle, housing and self employment as well. The hitherto neglected scheduled
castes, according to her, get full help from her in the panchayat. Reservation provides
dalit a position within the new panchayat but is not a guarantee that they will
be able to effectively participate in the decision making process. It is the
level of participation of dalit leaders that will determine the success of the
reservation policy; it was only after the 73rd constitutional
amendment act in which provision for reservation of seats to weaker sections of
the society was made. An important reason for the failure of dalit representative to play an effective role is the lack of awareness’ and knowledge about reservation provided in the panchayat. In this village panchayat forty percent of respondent were not aware at all. Dalit representative showed greater awareness’ then the general category representatives. Which is a reflection of rising political and social consciences and a desire for a share in power and decision making at the grass root level? Dalit leaders of the panchayat are fairly regular in attending panchayat meeting and other activities. Meetings are generally hold once a month and fixed in consultation with the block development officer concerned. The issues discussed at these meetings pertain to the overall development of village. Members take stock of the ongoing construction and developmental activities, expenditure occurred on various activities, welfare measures, education, health etc. despite signs of successful working of Dalits at the grassroots level, the scope for further improvements always remains. They find that it is not always smooth sailing as there are many hindrances. While the lack of education and lack of support from one’s own community is cited as major problems. In the case of women leaders, it has been found that they are very active and tend to participate in all activities. But there is a lack of support from their own families. This is not only curbs their free participation but also their personal growth as leaders and the growth of grassroots democracy |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Conclusion |
Thus the findings of the study shows that in Himachal Pradesh the absence of an oppressive social order and rise in literacy improvement in the economic and employment opportunities offered by the state have provided Dalits confidence and capability. Reservation has brought them into the new panchayats giving them representation and other opportunities that they did not enjoy earlier. The adequate representation of scheduled castes in the village panchayat has paved the way for dalit community to assert their demands and problem in the village. Although the reservation at grass-roots has considerably increased the participation and empowerment of Dalits at various levels of panchyati raj institutions, certain hindrances are still their low socio economic status. The leaders in most cases owe their loyalty to the higher caste leaders because a dalit candidate in electoral politics cannot achieve victory without the support of non Dalits i.e. the higher or dominant caste in the area. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
References | 1. Chaudhary, S.N. Dalit and Tribal Leadership in Panchyats ; Concept Publisher New Delhi, 2004.
2. Gerald D. Berreman, Hindus of Himalayas, Bombay; Oxford University press, 1963.
3. Gupta, S.K. the Scheduled Caste in Modern Indian Politics; their emergence as a political power, New Delhi; Munshiram Manoharlal, 1985.
4. Judge. Paramjit Singh, Mapping Dalits, Rawat Publications. 2009.
5. L.R. Thakur , socio-economic problems of Depressed classes in Himachal Pradesh, an unpublished PhD Thesis submitted to the Himachal Pradesh university; Shimla 1984.
6. Lester W. Milbrath, political Participation; How and why do people get involved in politics .chicago; Rand a McNally, 1965.
7. Narenedr Kumar.Manoj Rai; Dalit leadership in Panchyat, a Comparatives study of four states; Rawat Publications, 2006.
8. Pai Sudha. Social Capital Panchyat and Grassroots Democracy; Politics of Dalit assertion EPW Vol XXXII,NO 3 June 2001.
9. Sharma Ranbir, Party Politics in a Himalyan state, Delhi; National Publishing House, 1977.
10. Sharma T.R. New Challenges of Politics of India New Delhi Uppal Publishing House 1989.
|