|
|||||||
Lockdown Research: Implications for Sportswomen in India | |||||||
Paper Id :
15882 Submission Date :
2022-03-26 Acceptance Date :
2022-04-15 Publication Date :
2022-04-25
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. For verification of this paper, please visit on
http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/resonance.php#8
|
|||||||
| |||||||
Abstract |
The years 2020 and 2021 have been stumbling blocks for nations worldwide, causing umpteen distress to global populations. In India, the nationwide lockdown in March,2020 to contain the spread of novel corona virus cast a debilitating effect on the condition of women across the country and had irreversible impact on sportswomen in particularly.
This research* has been motivated in response to the indifference observed in catering to the female sports fraternity during the pandemic, and the unintentional errors in policy making in this regard due to the gaps left by inadequate research on the experience of sportswomen under the lockdown.
The research brings forth the lockdown-driven grievances and issues relating to health, financial and career-related uncertainty, effects on mental equilibrium of Indian sportswomen of various walks, ranging from beginners, professionals, elites, specially-abled, etc.
The research methodology includes information gathered through primary and secondary sources including online surveys, telephonic interviews, blogs and social media accounts of sportswomen, national coaches, guidelines of national sports organizations, reports by the Ministry of Sports, technological assistance (fitness apps, etc). and views of dieticians, gynecologists and obstetricians. Pictorial and graphical representation of data shall be accompanied by case studies to authenticate the arguments.
|
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Keywords | Sportswomen, Lockdown, Pandemic, Implications, Mental Health. | ||||||
Introduction |
Indian women have been living examples of grit, perseverance and strength, with stories of their achievements having prefigured for a long time within the developmental discourses of the nation. It is Indian women’s achievements in sports that have been the center of limelight presently. Needless to say, Indian sportswomen are achieving a noteworthy niche for themselves in what was hitherto a male-dominated affair. Achieving a historic feat, India fielded a whopping 56 female athletes in what was the highest female contingent being sported by India at the Olympics so far. In this regard, it is pertinent to mention the splendid performance of the Indian Women’s Hockey team at the Tokyo Olympics and their subsequent clinching of FIH (Fédération Internationale de Hockey) Star Awards in all categories. Mirabai Chanu, Mary Kom, PV Sindhu, Geeta Phogat, Mithali Raj, Dipa Karmakar, Manu Bhaker, Lovlina Borgohain are just a few of the scores of extraordinary Indian sportswomen whose consistent efforts in their respective fields have been outstanding.
However, their journeys have not been the easiest, to say the least- having won long and protracted battles, emotional turmoil, patriarchal challenges and financial woes- Indian sportswomen have undeniably had to bear a disproportionate brunt in making their way through these challenges. Thus, the idea was to conduct a vivid, comprehensive and broad-based research on the travails of sportswomen in lockdown was conceptualized by Policy Center and Gender Lab, Miranda House in May 2020, in the backdrop of an unprecedented nationwide lockdown.
Confined within the small spaces of our households, as the shocking news of tragedies being faced by various communities made headlines, a pertinent realization dawned upon the researchers. This realization had to do with the situation of sportswomen, hemmed within their houses due to the lockdown, as their professions and lives came to a standstill. What caught our attention, for the most part, was the fact that, sportspersons, and more so, sportswomen, were not portrayed as so much significant a community as others by the media, in its coverage of the effects of lockdown on the various communities constituting our society. This realization drove us to review the findings of schools of researchers, branches of the media, and civil society organizations into the lives of those sportswomen. Sports Women - whose lives had been battered under the diabolic effects of an untimely lockdown, their fears aggravated by the spread of a deadly contagion, their mental health deteriorating and a constant enigma of uncertain profession-related future prospects lurking over their minds. On a surprising note, however, the researchers encountered very limited pieces of research articles on the concerned section, among a plethora of literature available for other equally important categories of affected sections.
|
||||||
Objective of study | The stigma associated with sports as a profession, that has much to do with the unpredictability of its future prospects, looms large in society even today. The fact that it is stigmatized to an even greater extent with respect to girls is not surprising. This leads to a very skewed number of sample sizes available for gauging a broad picture on how far the concerned community has been affected. Added to this, sportswomen, as a domain of research, separately constitute various individual categories of women - beginners, professionals, trainees, old women, students, etc. Such complexities further sabotage the efficient coverage of various intricacies of research work in the said field. It was to overcome these concerns of inadequate research that the researchers examined the tribulations being undergone by the community of sportswomen at large, under the wake of a sudden lockdown. |
||||||
Review of Literature | There has been relative negligence in terms of
catering to the apprehensions and issues plaguing the female sports fraternity
in the backdrop of the pandemic, and inadvertent errors and flip-flops in
policy making that have somehow been indifferent to the exigencies of their
situation. These concerns are well established by A Bowes (2020) meta-analysis,
who concluded that COVID-19 pandemic impacted elite level sports where the
sports women were more affected than the sportsmen. However, the challenges faced
by the elite sports players may not be generalizable to the semi-professional
and amateur sportswomen. In the light of this, the researchers went beyond the
‘professional-level’ of sports players and delved into specific aspects, such
as CS Czymara’s (2020) analysis, which focuses on the financial hardships
during lockdown for the sportspeople. Pertinent to note, however, that these
researches have been quite unequitable in their analysis of the issue. Much of
the research, for instance, has been put into a specific country - M Guicciardi
(2020) delved into the impact of lockdown on male and female sportspeople in
Italy where there were negative impacts on self-efficacy (especially in the
outdoor games) and on mental wellness; JM Buldú (2020) focuses on competition
faced by sportsmen and women post lockdown. Most of these studies are limited
to western countries. The Indian, or even ‘developing country,’ aspect to the
study is highly absent. One study, N Mathew-(2020), analyses the impact of
lockdown on women but it generalizes the concerns of women from different
social stratas. Sports, already being stigmatised as a career path in Indian
society, make it even more disadvantageous for women to take part. The
challenges faced by Indian sportswomen can be a varied experience with the
interplay of gender norms and poverty along with other factors. While drawing
upon certain autobiographies and biographies of Indian Sports Women, the
limitations of sports as a full-fledged career choice are undeniably visible. For
instance, in her autobiography ‘Unbreakable’, Mary Kom talks about the hardship
and the amount of hardwork and challenges a sports woman has to face after
being married and having children and at the; same time facing the hardships of
poverty. Mary Kom, in her book, says ‘Even when I went for the Nationals, my
shoes were tattered – not that I let it bother me.”, “In spite of our penury
and deprivation, we did not ever lose faith in God.”, “Not only does this rule
inconvenience players, it creates a highly avoidable rift among the coaches.
Groupism and favoritism are the inevitable consequences of it.”. Her
experiences clearly talk about the obstacles faced by her during the course of
her career. Other books like ‘Playing to win’ by Saina Nehwal bring out the
inevitable interplay of a multiplicity of roles that a woman shoulders– a
daughter, sister, a student. She also talks about her rigorous training, diet,
sacrifices and so on. A Different Spirit – Malathi Krishnamurthy Holla, who is
a wheelchair bound athlete chronicles her struggles and her dedication in not
giving up despite the hurdles she faced in life. She started the Mathru
foundation to take care of differently abled children from poor backgrounds.
‘Free hit’ by Surpita Das is the story of evolution of women’s cricket in
India. Its focus lies majorly on the negligent attitude of cricketing officials
with regards women’s sports in India, sponsorship-related challenges and pay
disparity based on gender that proliferates quite easily within the domain of
sports in India. “Junior cricket for girls needs to be entrusted in very strong
hands, just like it’s been done for the boys – they have Rahul Dravid in
charge. The BCCI has no accurate database of the number of women players, or
the performance of batsmen, bowlers, all-rounders and keepers from different
states.”, “Playing for Hyderabad Senior, she should have got the best grounds
to play and practice in. However, in reality, the Hyderabad U-19 boys team got
better grounds to play in. Some of the boys, even senior ones, weren’t serious
about the game; yet they were paid at least Rs 25,000 a match – more than what
More made in an entire year! The women also had to make do with their rations:
two pairs of clothes for a whole year, even though they trained every day, and
two idlis per day as food throughout the year. ‘Yahi kha lo [Make do with
this],’ they would be told, as if they were being done a favour.”, “About 200
spectators, college boys mostly, were in attendance to watch women – some of
them in white bell-bottomed trousers, the rest in white skirts – play cricket.
It would be safe to say that the crowd had turned up to watch women play in
skirts.”, “. So when her neighbours saw her playing cricket in shorts with
boys, they didn’t miss a single opportunity to taunt her parents: ‘Aap ki beti
ka yeh awaarapanti kitne din chalega? [How long will this nonsense of your
daughter go on for?]” and numerous other examples from her book clearly explain
the level of gender-based discrimination a women has to face in
‘male-dominated’ sports. Thus, it certainly brings out the importance of
inclusion of research related to Indian sportswomen for better hold on the
various challenges faced by them. Hence, the impact of lockdown on Indian and
other developing countries sportswomen must have a different experience given
their stature, profitability of sports and affirmative actions by the
government to promote sports, especially amongst Indian women. Nonetheless,
there has been a lack of robust studies on Indian sportswomen and their
challenges in various aspects owing to the COVID-19 Lockdown. This is primarily
and foremostly, what led the authors of this paper to brew within the contours
of their research, a wide array of aspects related to sportswomen and the
fallouts of an ill-conceived lockdown on their personal and professional lives. |
||||||
Methodology | Research methodology is important in determining the validity and reliability of the study undertaken. Authors of this research initiated the study with an aim to explore an under-researched topic – the disruption caused by the Pandemic and its effects in the lives of Sportswomen – and to establish a cause-and-effect relationship. The research methodology adopted by the authors combined information gathered through primary and secondary sources of data collection including both qualitative and quantitative data. The researchers identified and collected contacts of pan-India sportswomen from across colleges and schools through the circulation of Google form. To seek primary data, a carefully-structured questionnaire was circulated amongst a pool of respondents. The questionnaire drew vastly upon subjective and objective questions covering a plethora of issues related to sportswomen, which might have undergone variations and overhauls in the midst of the lockdown period. Questionnaires along with the consent form were emailed to all the identified contacts. Thus, the study draws primarily upon interaction with most of the identified sports women on telephone, in-person interviews and surveys conducted in liaison with technology driven survey apps, telephonic interviews, blogs and social media accounts of sportswomen and already conducted interviews of national coaches. Furthermore the anonymity and confidentiality of respondents has been maintained by using changed names while analyzing the research findings.
For secondary data collection researchers depended on guidelines of national sports organizations, reports by the Ministry of Sports and reports of national newspapers. Authors also lead further research on some aspects of existing research by conducting a detailed literature review. To cite one such source is the research undertaken by Ali Bowes, Lucy Lomax and Jessica Piasecki on the topic – ‘The impact of the COVID-19 lockdown on elite sportswomen’. Thus, information gained from all the sources was classified and represented pictorially and graphically to provide the reader with a visual understanding of the data acquired. Arguments and conclusion of the research is based on critical data analysis and has been substantiated with case studies for an optimal understanding of the issue at hand. |
||||||
Tools Used | The research paper seeks to analyse the impact of lockdown on sportswomen and come out with possible solutions. It has been observed that a majority of the female sportspeople (most of whom are national level players) experienced a negative impact on their lifestyle. While at the same time, they found cost effective means to access fitness trainers and wellness practitioners during the lockdown. Thus, they explored new possibilities to pander to their fitness needs in the times of lockdown. Authors surveyed a wide range of female sportspersons under the sample size of 100+ to understand their challenges in various areas and the kind of alternatives they have looked forward to overcome the difficulties. The survey was conducted through Google Forms which were circulated through emails and social media platforms, prominently WhatsApp. It is to be noted that certain assessments and measures were taken into account while recording the responses of female sportspeople. 1. Email IDs and phone numbers were recorded for the purpose of an official authentication of the respondent and their responses. 2. A consent form was generated for an informed collection of data. The form evinced basic details of the research to the prospective respondents; informed them the purpose of the research, process and duration of data collection; stated the official wherewithal that might be required from them in the future (audio recordings of phone calls, quoted texts of their responses, etc.) and gained their voluntary consent to be the formal respondents of the survey undertaken. 3. Extensive rechecking was done to avoid any discrepancy and possibilities of transcription errors. 4. The survey questionnaire was a mix of objective and subjective type questions spanning a range of different aspects that might have undergone diametrically diverse impacts under the lockdown. 5. Even in the case of objective questions, it was ensured that comments can be added, in case the respondent wants to give opinions which do not coincide with options provided for the questions asked. The form was structured into 5 parts- Part I- Demographic details of the sportswomen and their areas of interest in sports. Part II- Status of their sports career before the lockdown Part III- Mental and physical health status of the female sportspersons Part IV- Respondents’ comments on their sports career status during ‘stay-at-home’ orders Part V- Sportswomen’s future prospects |
||||||
Analysis | Part 1 The
survey collected the demographic details of the respondents, and the
professional sport pursued by them. The observations are as follows: 1. 69.8% of sports-women were equal to or below the age of 19 years whereas 30.2% of sports-women were above the age of 19 years. 2. 67.9% of the respondents
belonged to an urban background and 33.1% belonged to semi-rural/urban or rural
background. 3. The
respondents play sports such as Basketball, Table Tennis, Lawn Tennis,
shooting, Javelin throw, Twaekwondo, archery, athletics, horse riding,
handball, Net ball, swimming, badminton, skating and Karate. 4.83% of the players were national level players and 5.7% of them were international level. The rest of them (22.6%) were district and regional/district level players. Part
II The
next part of the survey inquired the respondents about the status of their
sports profession before the lockdown was proclaimed. Majority
of the respondents stated that they followed intense workout schedules,
practiced regularly, and actively took part in competitions. Pre-lockdown
many responding sports-women were at the peak of their careers. Due to the
pandemic, many tournaments and events were canceled for instance, as stated by
(Kajal) Ojwaswini Kotwal, a national-level air pistol shooting player- “I
was doing pretty well. I had an upcoming shooting tournament which got delayed
and when the pandemic hit, it got canceled”. Hence, "most of them
were", as said by Shruti Rathi- a national level Lawn Tennis player, “giving
their best physically as well as mentally and were able to perform well in
tournaments”. (Priya) Aggarwal, a national level Taekwondo player stated, “It
[sports] was regular .Suddenly there was a huge break in the training session
and everything got disturbed.” (Nancy) Aggarwal, another national level
athlete had this to say: “The practice flow was really good and the progress
was consistent. Competitions made me keep a check on my progress every now and
then. But since the lockdown started, the performance is completely lost. It
feels like, i [I] need to start everything again from scratch.” It is thus
observed that life for sportswomen under the pandemic has been riddled
with multiple absurdities and uncertainties. This is what (Namita)
Sharma, another respondent reiterated, “It [situation] was still better
before as compared to now, as i (I) was able to play better as we all know that
in order to play any sport we need basic human contact but after COVID sport is
one of the industries that has been severely affected. “ Part
III This
part of the survey delved into the issues faced by sports women in the
sphere of health (both-mental and physical) during the lockdown. 1.
When asked about their general health status, the majority of them
(92.45%) responded that they have experienced a sweeping deterioration in their
physical health. The leading reasons stated were “lack of endurance or
strength, weight gain, drop in body metabolism and irregular menstrual cycle”.
Other health issues included “lower lung function, loss of muscle strength and
memory, and infection due to COVID-19.” Only 2 out of 53 respondents (3.77%)
opined that their health underwent no disastrous changes under the lockdown. 2. The respondents were also worrisome about their menstrual health, 66% of the respondents complained about their stress, irregular menstrual cycle, painful cramps, bloating and cravings, heavier bleeding and sleep disruption. While 34% of the respondents did not have such complaints. 3. In the question related to their mental
health, a mixed response was recorded 35 out of 53 (66.3%) respondents
were not very much occupied with fears, inadequacy or uncertainty of the pandemic.
25/53 (47.16%) of respondents were concerned about the uncertainty due to
pandemic. Part
IV This
part sought to unveil the general outlook on the sports the respondents play
during the pandemic. 1.The
majority of the respondents (62.3%) agreed that unavailability of training
equipment, proper diet, and courts for practice has negatively impacted their
practice and techniques. 2.
The survey asked whether the respondents were able to follow a routine
that was similar to the one they followed before the pandemic. It was
observed that 71.7% of them were out of schedule or a routine. Very few gave a
mixed response on getting back to their schedule. 3. The respondents were also asked whether the availability of time shifted their focus from preparedness to enjoyment of the game Respondents had a mixed outlook towards this. While 30 respondents (56.6%) responded in the affirmative, 22 respondents (41.5%) had the opposite response. It was observed that they have shifted to a positive outlook towards their sports. Part
V The
last and concluding portion of the survey wanted to know about the future
prospects of the respondents in their sports career. These were subjective
questions. 1.
54.7% of sports women were looking forward to tournaments. The
respondents mentioned names of tournaments they want to participate in like
ITUSA, South Asian Games and some intercollege and inter-club competitions. 2.
The respondents were inquired about their new goals after the new normal
that COVID-19 has brought. Most of them are focusing on themselves, working
out, practicing, watching online videos for new techniques, switching to Yoga,
recovering from their surgeries and injuries if any, and finding alternatives
like cycling, swimming, and so on. With much headway being made in opening up
spaces, some respondents are now able to access the courts with adequate
COVID-19 safety precautions. 3.
Many were optimistic about their fitness regime to become more
professional and intense than before. However, some anticipate that practice
will not be the same as they will be cautious about the infection and avoid
overcrowded space. (Mansi), a national level Basketball player notes, “ [The
situation will be] Very different definitely. Since basketball is a
contact sports it is going to be difficult to bring it back to normal.”
(Richa) Shukla, a national level Shooter and Swimmer had this to say “It's
tough to have all equipment available thus my practices have taken a hit.
However, I [will] try to maintain my fitness levels as much as possible.”
(Mahima), associating herself with Javelin Throw, notes, “After the lock
down. I am not expecting my performance (or fitness) to be as good as it was
before lock down while I was regularly showing up at the field. But also it is
not affected very badly because I've been working out at home.”(Janki)
Asapu, national level Tennis player, stated “It's tough to go back to the
old normal days and resume everything as usual but I and my coaching team are
trying our best to stay on track.” 4. When asked about their experience during the lockdown, we got a mixed bag of responses. Many respondents struggled financially and for opportunities along with reduced fitness levels. “Financial crisis was one such cause that affected everyone regardless if [of whether] they play [a] sport or not. I would really want to see our government make certain policies in India's Sports Sector to help those sportspersons who are facing financial issues due to COVID 19 Pandemic.”, said (Namita) Sharma. It was difficult to connect with the coaches and teammates also. One of them pointed out the discrimination between men and women in the case of accessibility of the playing ground in small areas. She said that men were given the upperhand in the accessibility of play-grounds. Many found the pandemic to be “unmotivating, mentally exhausting and depressing” as well. However, quite a few respondents had a positive experience as they were able to spend time with their families, bringing alternatives like Yoga and online tutorials for workouts into practice. (Kajal) Kotwal, an Air Pistol shooter responded, “Corona has affected my social ability to go out with family and friends and has made staying inside and spending more time with myself an easy task.” |
||||||
Findings | The survey has unveiled some crucial dimensions and issues faced by the sportswomen during lockdown. The respondents were mostly young (18-25 years old), majorly national level players and majority of them belonged to an urban background. It was observed that they had an active life, and a consistent and rigorous schedule. However, with the imposition of COVID-19 lockdown, the lives of the respondents changed drastically in terms of their physical health. They were concerned about the lack of professional facilities for better practice of techniques also. Notably, many of the respondents were not occupied with negative thoughts of uncertainty due to lockdown. While considering the availability of opportunities post lockdown, the respondents were particularly optimistic. Quite a few explored the alternative to live in the ‘new normal’. | ||||||
Conclusion |
The survey has unveiled some crucial dimensions and issues faced by the sportswomen during lockdown. The respondents were mostly young (18-25 years old), majorly national level players and majority of them belonged to an urban background. It was observed that they had an active life, and a consistent and rigorous schedule. However, with the imposition of COVID-19 lockdown, the lives of the respondents changed drastically in terms of their physical health. They were concerned about the lack of professional facilities for better practice of techniques also. Notably, many of the respondents were not occupied with negative thoughts of uncertainty due to lockdown. While considering the availability of opportunities post lockdown, the respondents were particularly optimistic. Quite a few explored the alternative to live in the ‘new normal’. |
||||||
Acknowledgement | The research was carried by Dr. Hena Singh and Dr. Namrata Singh of Policy Centre and Gender Lab (PCGL), Miranda House, University of Delhi. The student researchers were Harshita Srivastava, Tanya Sood, Niddhi Kanaujia and Hajra. | ||||||
References | 1. https://thebridge.in/tokyo-2020/56-indian-women-tokyo-olympics-highest-female-participants-23148
2. https://thebridge.in/tokyo-2020/a-look-india-women-power-tokyo-olympics-22569
3. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/05/what-lockdown-means-for-athletes-olympicscoronavirus-covid/
4. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/womens-sport/2020/05/11/lockdown-effect-increase-femaleathletes-experiencing-changes/
5. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/05/what-lockdown-means-for-athletes-olympicscoronavirus-covid/
6. https://covid-19.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202003/26/WS5e7bdb69a31012821728204a.html
7.https://mumbaimirror.indiatimes.com/sport/badminton/tips-from-pullela-gopichand-on-keeping-mentally-and-physically-fit-during-lockdown/articleshow/75231036.cms
8.https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/badminton/indian-badminton-goes-online-due-tocoronavirus-lockdown/articleshow/74967180.cms
9.https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/sports/badminton/indian-badminton-goes-online-due-tocoronavirus-lockdown/articleshow/74967180.cms
10. https://www.newindianexpress.com/sport/other/2020/mar/28/covid-19-lockdown-lack-oftraining-may-cause-health-problems-says-sports-authority-of-india-2122521.html |