|
|||||||
Rights of Women Police and Challenges | |||||||
Paper Id :
16877 Submission Date :
2022-12-18 Acceptance Date :
2022-12-22 Publication Date :
2022-12-25
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. For verification of this paper, please visit on
http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/shinkhlala.php#8
|
|||||||
| |||||||
Abstract |
Policing is a demanding job, which involves long and uncertain hours of duty.Many women are entering this job but their representation is not satisfactory. There are many challenges women police have to face. Policewomen emerge as tokens in a male-dominated occupation notwithstanding the fact that their representation in the police department is very necessary for addressing gender-related issues on a priority basis and ensuring support to women victims of violence as well as protecting their rights.So this paper focus on the problems of the women police.
|
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Keywords | Women, Police, Challenges, Gender, Facilities, Discrimination, Representation. | ||||||
Introduction |
Women are often viewed as “the weaker sex” and it is believed that their characteristics are not suited to fit the requirements of certain jobs, especially in male-dominated professions like police service. But the present globalization and liberalization era have changed the position of women in India. As a result, women are actively participating in various economic activities, and simultaneously managing their family and work life. Their traditional role of home-maker has been transformed into the new role of a professional woman. In India, a number of women have successfully broken the glass ceiling and attained top positions, like Mrs. Indira Gandhi (first female Prime Minister of the country), Mrs. Pratibha Patil (first female President of the country), Ms. Naina Lal Kidwai (first Indian woman to lead a foreign bank, HSBC), Ms. Kanchan C. Bhattachariya (first female DGP of Uttaranchal state), Ms. Sonali Banerjee (first female merchant navy officer), Ms. Kiran Bedi (first female IPS officer) and many more.
|
||||||
Objective of study | The objective of the study related to this topic is to know the challenges faced by women police at the workplace. |
||||||
Review of Literature | On this topic reference have been made from various books i.e. “New Dimensions to Police Leadership” by Samanta, A. K. (2003 ), Women police in India by Tumpa Mukherjee, (2020), Laws relating to women In India by Dr.. Syed Masood , ‘Justice for Women (Concerns and Expressions )’ by A.S. Anand-CJI Of India , journals, newspapers and websites |
||||||
Main Text |
If we talk about the job of policing many women are
entering into this job.It is considered to be one of the most masculinized
occupations of the world. It has been described as one of the most “gendered”
professions particularly agreeable to traditional male gender characteristics.
It is believed women have been slow to enter. Policing is a demanding job,
which involves long and uncertain hours of duty. However, over the past few
decades, the police workforce has grown much more diverse with regard to gender
and race .In India, while all the postings and ranks in the police are common
to both men and women, women are still under-represented in the police force.
Policing is a psychologically stressful work filled with responsibility to
maintain law and order in addition to personal responsibilities towards their
own families. This becomes all the more stressful to women police as women
traditionally considered as care takers of house hold activities. During the
corona pandemic women police officers have performed their duties excellently
and bravely keeping the welfare of the society in priority before their
personal lives but the policewoman's progress has been beset by subtle
barriers, largely generated by the traditional belief held by many police
administrators, that police work is essentially a man's job. Women police have certain limitations also like physical strength, family responsibilities, (e.g. pregnancy, motherhood) ,which creates hindrance in performing her responsibilities. It is usually thought that women police are less capable of bearing the work pressure in performing duties of the police. Even as the government
plans to induct more women into police as part of its empowerment drive, they
still face with lack of basic amenities like toilets, uncomfortable duty gear
and want of privacy. They don't have the facility of of toilets around due to which they spend long hours on duty without water which results in dehydration problems . There is also the problem of lack of health facilities and
crèches. Sexual harassment and organizational in-civility affect
the dignity and performance of women personnel in any profession. Sexual
harassment introduces stress. The cost of stress for employees are mainly
physical and psychological illnesses, including depression and job
dissatisfaction; while the costs for employers are mainly absenteeism, job
attrition and deterioration in productivity.It is a great challenge for women
police personnel to work with full honesty and dignity in a corrupted and
compromised environment. They don't get recognition from their male colleagues. Although policewomen are
expected to perform tasks and roles similar to those of policemen, there are
differences in terms of the women’s motivation levels as well as the negative
attitudes of their male counterparts and decision-makers. Role ambiguity and multiple roles
result in increased stress. Most women in the police are confused about the way
they should conduct themselves. Although they have been present in the law enforcement
profession, they are often placed in the women’s cell or the suvidha centre
(citizen-government interface), denying them full equality with their male
counterparts. Even when women have been given full policing powers, they have
not been able to completely utilize these powers. This creates problems of
co-ordination both among women personnel and between the women police personnel
and their male counterparts. The women police lack knowledge related to the new
techniques of information technology which is a hindrance in tackling the cyber
crimes. Due to the advancement in technology the face of crime has also become more advanced. The criminals are committing crimes in new techno ways which these women police, due to the lack of training and knowledge ,find it difficult to catch them and punish them. There is also a big question that
when women police are being exploited and harassed by her seniors then to whom
she complaints ? Leadership is a another factor which pose a challenge to
women in the police. Women are perceived to be more people-oriented because of
their socialization; they are meant to exhibit more democratic, participative,
holistic and interactive styles of leadership, while men are thought to be more
task-oriented. Another reason is lack of job satisfaction. Women police are not
satisfied with their promotion opportunities and working conditions Thus, it is
understandable that women police personnel who are less satisfied with their
jobs will be less motivated to perform the necessary tasks. Policewomen emerge
as tokens in a male-dominated occupation notwithstanding the fact that their
representation in the police department is very necessary for addressing
gender-related issues on a priority basis and ensuring support to women victims
of violence as well as protecting their rights. There are various enactments occupying the field
pertaining to protection ,welfare and empowerment of women on account of
illiteracy ,immortality, radical change in the Indian societies on overall
rapid and effective westernization of India. The problem related to women are
being mushroomed. The parliament in its part legislated various exclusive
statutes to deal with the harassment ,cruelty and cases of molestation against
women. Indian Penal Code,1860, Criminal Procedure code,1973, Indian Evidence
Act,1872, Protection of women against sexual harassment at the workplace) Act,
2013 etc. are the various statutes to provide protection to women literate or
illiterate. Suggestions It is very necessary so as to bring their problems before
different sections of the society like judiciary, legislature ,media, common
people so that required and necessary amendments can be done by making
effective policies .If our women protectors will be happy then it can be an
inspiration for our coming generations to choose police service as a career and
there will be less discrimination at home as well as at the workplace.
Recruitment and promotion of women police are important to increase women’s representation at different levels. To increase the numbers of women police at all levels, states should make commitments to maintain equitable balance of men and women. Recruitment procedures should be conducted in a systematic and phased manner to achieve proportionate representation of women. Departments should create common and combined posts and assign clear targets for the number of women to be recruited in every recruitment year at all levels. Although women are supposed to be given 33% reservation but the reality is something else and there is partiality and biasedness which women police face at the workplace .Therefore in order to ensure 33% reservation in direct recruitment for all posts at the entry level special measures should be taken. If the assigned seats are unfilled by women, states should carry these forward and conduct special recruitment drives to fill long pending vacancies. To publicize the opportunities for women in police, departments should collaborate with local media and educational institutions. Retention of women police is equally important. Data published by the Bureau of Police Research and Development shows the decrease in the strength of women police over the years. Unless state governments make the institutions gender-friendly and create facilities that cater to the needs and roles of women, retention of women police is challenging. This includes setting up creches, preventing sexual harassment at workplace and building separate rest-rooms. It is unfortunate that even police training schools do not have these facilities, not even those as basic as separate washrooms. In such a situation, there is an urgent need for setting up basic necessities for women police at the workplace i.e. police outposts, district headquarters, police training schools, etc. Apart from this, it is also necessary that female police personnels should be provided the similar opportunities as their male counterparts are being provided in hard core policing.
|
||||||
Conclusion |
Retention of women police is equally important. Data published by the Bureau of Police Research and Development shows the decrease in the strength of women police over the years.Studies show that some of the key reasons for the high attrition rate of women police are sexual harassment and gender discrimination.Unless state governments make the institutions gender-friendly and create facilities that cater to the needs and roles of women, retention of women police is challenging. This includes setting up creches, preventing sexual harassment at workplace and building separate rest-rooms. It is unfortunate that even police training schools do not have these facilities, not even those as basic as separate washrooms. In such a situation, the urgent need for setting up basic necessities for women police at workplace cannot be over-emphasised. These are not only required at the police station level, but also at district headquarters, police outposts, traffic police and training schools.
Simultaneously, governments and police departments should ensure that women police are given similar opportunities as their counter-parts in contributing to hard-core policing. Serving women police have expressed that they are likely to be assessed less competent and considered less suitable for positions with a high level of responsibility and challenge. Women’s role cannot be restricted to answering calls on 100, making diary entries or to all-women battalions/units.
Despite the continued presence of these issues, no government has attempted to conceptualise a comprehensive policy to make the police service more inclusive in the real sense. Unfortunately, the manifestos do not seek to address any of these concerns and needs. Merely creating policies that promise a certain target of reservation does not ensure that as many women are actually recruited and promoted. Any government that comes to power must create a level-playing field to truly open up opportunities and cater to the requirements of diverse sections of the society. We must remember that policing needs women for the values and quality that they bring in, and it is not the other way round. |
||||||
References | 1. Ministry of Finance, Govt. of India. 2012. Economic Survey, 2011–12. New Delhi: Ministry of Finance, Govt. of India.
2. Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, Advisory (2015),15011/72/2014 – SC/ST – W : https://mha.gov.in/sites/default/files/CrimesagainstWomen0601.PDF
3. Data on Police Organisations as on 01.01.2017, Bureau of Police Research and Development, Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India.
4. Samanta, A. K. 2003. “New Dimensions to Police Leadership.” Academy Journal 56 (1): 33– 37.
5. Natarajan, M. 2006. “Dealing with Domestic Disputes/Violence by Women Police in India: Results of a Training Program in Tamil Nadu”. International Journal of Criminal Justice Science 1 (1): 1–19. Available online at: http://www.sascv.org/ijcjs/mangai.pdf.
6. Laws relating to women In India by Dr.. Syed Masood (Oriental Law House, New Delhi))
7. Justice for Women (Concerns and Expressions ) by A.S. Anand-CJI Of India (3rd edition ,New Delhi,Universal Law Publishing Co. Pvt. Ltd.,2008)
8. Women Police In India :A Journey from Periphery to Core By Tumpa Mukherjee (Rawat Publications 2020)
9. Fact Sheet on Women Police in India, http://www.humanrightsinitiative.org/download/Fact%20sheet%20-%20women%20police.pdf
10. Recruiting and Retaining Women: A Self-Assessment Guide for Law Enforcement, https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/bja/185235.pdf, page 93
11. https://www.humanrightsinitiative.org/blog/women-in-police-india-needs-more-than-just-political-promises-to-raise-numbers
12. National Centre for Women and Policing, (website homepage) http://womenandpolicing.com
13. Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, Advisory (2013), D.O.No.15011/21 – SC/ST – W:https://mha.gov.in/sites/default/files/AdvisoryWomenPolice-290513.pdf
14. UN Women (2011-12), Progress of the World’s Women: In Pursuit of Justice
15. Sahgal, P. 2007. “Women in Police: A Study of Their Career Aspirations and Motivation.”Indian Journal of Industrial Relations 42 (3): 408–29.
16. George, J. 2011. “Women in Administration in India.” Journal of International Women’s Studies 12 (1): 151–56. Available online at: http://vc.bridge.edu/jiws/vol12/iss1/12.
17. Suman, M. 2010. “Women in the Armed Forces: Misconceptions and Facts.” Indian Defence Review 25 (1). Available online at: http://www.usiofindia.org/Article/Print/?pub=Journal&pubno=579&ano=711.
18. Surender, A. 2010. “Growth and Development of Women Police in India.” In Cliff Roberson, Dilip K. Das, and Jennie K. Singer, eds., Police Without Borders: The Fading Distinction between Local and Global. Ch. 4, 65–85. Boca Raton, Florida: CRC Press
19. Women and Law in India- with an Introduction by Flavia Agnes,2004
20. Sharma, A., S. Sharma, and N. Kaushik. 2011. “An Exploratory Study of Glass Ceiling in Indian Education Sector.” Zenith International Journal of Multidisciplinary Research 1 (8): 73–82.
21. Ministry of Finance, Govt. of India. 2012. Economic Survey, 2011–12. New Delhi: Ministry of Finance, Govt. of India.
22. Commentary on India Penal Code by K.D. Gaur,2006,Universal Law Publishing Company Private Ltd., New Delhi
23.https://www.cnbctv18.com/views/indias-policewomen-increasingly-feel-unsafe-at-the-workplace-5391401.htm
24.https://www.humanrightsinitiative.org/blog_inner.php?type=blog
25. https://legislative.gov.in/sites/default/files/A2013-14.pdf
26.https://www.researchgate.net/publication/247748492_Policing_and_Gender_Male_and_Female_Perspectives_among_Members_of_
the_New_Zealand_Police
27.https://www.academia.edu/38159620/Women_in_Police_Employment_Status_and_Challenges_pdfhttps://apsnews.typepad.com/blog/2011/04/career-advancement-of-females-in-police-necessary-to-combat-violence-against-women.html
28.https://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-433-the-role-of-judiciary-protection-for-working-women.html |