|
|||||||
Emerging Trends of Indian Politics: Issues, Challenges and Possibilities | |||||||
Paper Id :
16974 Submission Date :
2022-12-13 Acceptance Date :
2022-12-19 Publication Date :
2022-12-25
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. For verification of this paper, please visit on
http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/innovation.php#8
|
|||||||
| |||||||
Abstract |
The basic hallmark of the politics of any state is that it modifies with time. The stage of history and the context in which the politics burgeons in turn defines its meaning. India also witnessed the stage wise evolution of politics which gained maturity with time. From single party system during independence era to the emergence of multiparty system and coalition politics form 1989 till date, the politics of our country and the way the political battles are waged have undergone a phenomenal change. The politics of defection was a new trend that came into prominence during 1966s, however this evil was nipped to significant extent following 52 nd constitutional amendment act 1985 and 91 st constitutional amendment act, 2003. The caste politics and the criminalization as well as communalization of politics have inflicted irreparable damage to the real meaning of democracy in country. The tickets for the election are awarded on the lines of the caste of contestant, religion to which he is affiliated to and most importantly the extent of money and muscle power that he wields. The politics of vengeance that an incumbent government embarks upon against the erstwhile government is an another ill trait of today’s political culture. Ironically elections are not being contested on really important and grave issues but whole electoral process entwines around a image of prominent personality of any political party. The principle of collective responsibility and political homogeneity have been undermined. Politics of populism, dynastic politics and post-poll alliances have also eroded the essence of democracy. These recent development have eroded the basic pedestal on which our democracy stands. The Election Commission and Administrative Reforms Commission have come out with a slew of recommendations which ought to be enforced in letter and spirit to liberate the political culture of the maladies which have crept in. Various guidelines of Supreme Court regarding of criminalization of politics should be the guiding light of reforms in political culture of our country.
|
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Keywords | Party, Politics, Contestant, Administrative Reforms, Muscle Power. | ||||||
Introduction |
The political system of any country is ever evolutionary in nature. It evolves with time and space. When India was born free as an independent nation on 15 th August, 1947 after 200 years of bondage and slavery, it had all those traits of political culture which a nascent nation has such as domination of single party system in the country etc. India was not untouched from the tentacles of many other political malaises of a nascent nation which was just born. Since then time has changed, from single party domination in the country to the existence of multi party system currently. Many changes took place in our electoral culture. Before independence it was basically the Congress party which was at the vanguard of freedom movement in the country. After independence Congress still ruled the roost for many decades at the political landscape for few decades till multiparty system became the mainstay of Indian political scene.
Today there are 7 national parties and 48 state parties in India and there are approximately 730 political parties which do not have got recognition from election commission either as national party or state party.
|
||||||
Objective of study | The paper touches upon deeply the contemporary issues affecting our geo political setup and the challenges being thrown up before the federal domain in the 21 st century. Parochial politics for narrow gains have imperiled the constitutional setup of the country. There has been a mammoth change in the types of security hazards that a country today faces and this is what is dwelt upon in this paper. |
||||||
Review of Literature | 1. B.L. Fadia in his
book “Indian Government and Politics”, brings to the fore the extent of
criminalization of politics and the various types emerging security
hazard that have the potency to cripple the country 2. J.C. Johri, “Indian
Government and Politics in his book refers to caste based politics as
the most severe challenge to Indian polity in contemporary times. He
also comes up with slew of measures to rectify the issues. 3. Ashutosh Varshney, in “ The Business-Politics Nexus”, International Studies and Social Sciences at Brown University unravels the close nexus between criminals and politicians in Indian political setup. He also mentions umpteen number of measures that can be undertaken to alleviate the vitiated environment. |
||||||
Main Text |
The coalition government was almost a novel concept
for Indian citizens till 1989. In the year 1989, Chaudhry Charan Singh formed government
for the first time with the outside support of Bhartiye Janta Party, though it
was a different fact that the government could not last long. The governments
of HD Devegowda and AB Vajpayee are also some of the examples of coalition
experiments in our country that can be quoted with. Another distinguishing feature that is somehow
interrelated with the previous concept is the waning influence of national
parties. We have also witnessed that at the national level different political
party is ruling while at the state level different party rules the roost. The
state politics of states like West Bengal, Odisha, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh etc is
dominated by Trinamool Congress, Biju Janta Dal, Communist Party of India and
Telugu Desham Party respectively. During the past few years it has also come to the
fore that the political alliances are based on unholy, unprincipled and greedy motives.
They are based on the principles of self aggrandizement and self prospects thus
negating the national interest to secondary status. Many a times political
parties have stooped so low as to doubt the credibility of our defence forces
and this has also undermined the security of the country in the process. The evil that rose its head in Indian political
landscape in 1966 was the “politics of defection”. Though 52 nd constitutional
amendment act was brought in to control the evil of political defection, it
failed in its purpose as this amendment applied only to the wholesale political
defection. To rectify the anomalies that had crept into 52 nd constitutional
amendment act with time, another constitutional in 2003. It provided that only
2/3 rd legislators of a political party could merge in another political party.
Since then the blot of defection being a disgusting feature of Indian politics
has subsided to some extent. Another despicable feature of Indian polity which
rose its ugly head and has been prominent factor currently is communalization
of politics. The political stalwarts irrespective of their political
affiliations make communal remarks so as to polarize the votes of a particular community.
Hate speeches and communal riots became engrained in the very essence of
electoral process. Nothing could be more depraving than this. Democracy and violence are antithetical to each
other. In a vibrant democracy there is no room for violence. But unfortunately criminalization
of politics has become an ironic reality in today’s political culture of India.
Data collated from last three general elections show hat candidates with
criminal cases pending against him were three times more likely to win than a
“clean” candidate. 17 percent of total 5,380 candidates who contested Lok Sabha
elections in 2014 general elections declared criminal cases in their affidavits
which they submitted to the election commission. Out of 17 percent of
candidates, 10 percent of candidates had serious charges of rape and murder on
them. It has come to the notice that political parties invariably field
candidates having criminal background in every election. It has been found out
in survey that while any random candidate has one out of eight chance of
winning a Lok Sabha seat, a candidate who is facing a criminal charge is twice
as likely to win as a clean candidate. Vote bank politics and the astronomical
expenditure which has to be incurred during electioneering are the major
reasons which forces a political party to field candidates having criminal back
ground. In India, it has been noticed that there is little trust in the efficiency
of democratic processes actually delivering outputs in good governance. This
extends naturally to accepting criminalization of politics as part and parcel
of one’s political life. Toothless laws to rein in the criminalization of
politics and dilapidated judiciary which is burdened with millions of pending
cases have further emboldened political criminalisation. The major sacrifice
that is done at the altar of criminalisation of politics is that of governance
as well as transparency and accountability. Expensive electioneering environment
is generally conducive to the candidates with strong financial background.
Those candidates when once gets elected strive to recover their expenses and
also try to ensure financial security for future elections. When someone is talking of elections in Indian
context how can one be oblivious of caste factor that has always played and
still plays an indispensable role in current political culture. Today the ill
effects of caste based politics have assumed mammoth proportions. Candidates are
contested and tickets are allotted on caste lines. Caste and politics have
symbiotic relation in Indian political context. Politics provides casteist
contestants with economic benefits as well as administrative patronage,
prestige and power while the caste of a contestant generally influences
political system in three different ways. Firstly caste of contestant reserves
its votes for its own members. Secondly people generally prefer to vote for the
candidate of their own caste irrespective of the fact whether the candidate is
deserving or not deserving and thirdly leaders of a particular caste tend to
prefer and select their own people on different posts. Members of particular caste
are considered as vote bank for members of that particular caste. In
constituencies dominated by upper castes such as Brahmins, Bhumihars, Kayastha
and Rajputs, upper caste candidates are fielded while those constituencies
which are dominated by backward castes, the candidates of backward castes
invariably get tickets. Caste as the factor provides basis for the emergence of
several interest groups in the country and these interest groups compete
against each other in unhealthy struggle of power and acts as divisive force.
Even today voting takes place on caste lines in majority of states in India.
The states of Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, Rajastha, Hariyana etc are ‘torch bearers’
in this regard. The political parties of Tamilnadu such as Dravida Munnetra
Kazhagm and All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagm(AIADMK) are self proclaimed
non Brahmin party. Another ominous trend which has been seen of late is growing
trend of money and muscle power in Indian politics. It is closely entwined with
criminalisation of politics. The concept and existence of “Baahubali” in Indian
elections is a stark reality. The so called “Baahubalis” not only have higher
chance of winning an election but they also enjoy the capacity of swirling the
electoral wind in favour of or against any political party. They are endowed
with immense clout in terms of money and muscle power. Raja Bhaiya, Mukhtaar
Ansaari, Brijesh Singh are some of the known ‘baahubalis’ . With growing awareness
of the masses and strict enforcement of rules, their unbridled role in
influencing electoral results have been reined in to a significant extent. Of
late it has been noticed that there is reemergence of personality cult in
Indian political scene. Voting pattern is tend to be polarized on personality
of individual rather than promises and performance of the political party.
Narendra Modi was inarguably the biggest personality cult in Indian elections
of 2014, and in 2019 elections also he is reckoned to be personality cult who
could swing votes. During elections votes are sought in the name of leaders and
voters are requested to strengthen hand of the leaders of their party. Politics of vendetta has become a curse of Indian
politics. Quite often politicians are seen openly threatening their detractors
and taking revenge once they come to power. Politicians coming across different
party lines openly intimidate the bureaucrats. The leaders of ruling dispensation
instead of indulging in clean politics are busy in taking revenge from their
detractors once they come to power. Populist politics though not a new trend
has become a stark reality of today’s political landscape of India. The
election process which is going on now a days has brought to the fore this fact
once again. Farm loan waiver and various other slogans are being given just to
muster the attention of the public irrespective of the fact whether the state has
got the capacity to fulfill the promise. During the 1977 general elections,
Janta party had the slogan of ‘democracy versus dictatorship’ while congress
party banked on the slogan of ‘stability versus anarchy’. In the same way
during general elections of 1991, Congress gave slogan of ‘stability and
development’, Bhartiye Janta Party gave slogan of ‘Ram, Roti and Nyaya’ and
Janta Dal of ‘social justice’ . Politics of mass rallies and road shows are also
one of the many emerging trends of Indian polity. Although mass rallies used to
happen earlier also but there is drastic increase in their frequency and intensity.
Big political stalwarts carry out road shows to garner attention of the public
and fetch votes. Besides there are other umpteen number of changes which are perceived now a days in Indian Polity . There is alarming presence of dynastic politics. Children of politicians have started considering their party as their own fief. Practice of outside support and increase in number of coalition partners to form the government has become the order of the day. The fractured mandate and hung parliaments too have become common, though this trend was an exception in last couple of general elections. There is also steep decline in ideology of different political parties. |
||||||
Conclusion |
To conclude the analysis in the nutshell with the change of time our Indian polity has definitely matured but it still has got miles to go. There is still a poor representation of women in parliament although women constitute approximately 50 percent of total population. The tentacles of caste politics and communalisation as well criminalisation of politics must be strictly dealt with. It is high time that the politicians raised themselves above petty issues of temples and mosques. Ours is a largest democracy and it should be beckon of excellence for other countries to follow. India should tread a golden
path which other countries can emulate. |
||||||
References | 1. Mohan C. Raja , Crossing the Rubicon: The shaping of India’s New Foreign Policy, Palgrave Macmillan, 2004
2. Brass P., Politics of India Since Independence, Hyderabad, Orient Longman, 1990
3. Fadia B.L. , “Indian Government and Politics”, Sahitya Bhawan Publications, 1999
4. Johri J.C. , “Indian Government and Politics”, Vishal Publications
5. Badyal J.S. , “Indian Government and Politics”, Raj Publishers, Jalandhar, 2012
6. Austin G. , The Indian Constitution: Cornerstone of a Nation, Oxford Unversity Press, 1996
7. Basu D.D., An introduction to the constitution of India, New Delhi, Prentice Hall, 1994
8. Johri J.C. , “Indian Government and Politics”, Vishal Publication, 1976
9. Singh V.B. and Yadav Yogendra, ‘The Maturing of a Democracy’, India Today, August 31, 1996
10. The Times of India, “Indian women hardly have any say in decision making”, New Delhi, November 2, 2014
11. Deccan Herald , ‘Panchayati Raj-Needed for Orientation’, August 20 th , 2000
12. Varshney Ashutosh, “ The Business-Politics Nexus”, International Studies and Social Sciences at Brown University, July 9 th , 2012
13. Singh M.P. and Saxena Rekha, India at the polls: Parliamentary Elections in the Federal Phase, Orient Longman, New Delhi, 3003, p.268
14. Kothari Rajni, “The Congress System in India”, Asian Survey, Volume
15. Martin Lipset Seymour, “ The indispensability of Political Parties”, Journal of Democracy, Vol 2, No. 1, January 2000 |