|
|||||||
Semiotic Analysis of Class Divisions and Cultural Identity in James Cameron's Titanic | |||||||
Paper Id :
17224 Submission Date :
2023-02-13 Acceptance Date :
2023-02-23 Publication Date :
2023-02-25
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. For verification of this paper, please visit on
http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/innovation.php#8
|
|||||||
| |||||||
Abstract |
Directed by James Cameron, the film Titanic(1997) provides a rich canvas for analyzing the class divide using Roland Barthes's semiotic analysis. The film tells the story of the ill-fated voyage of the RMS Titanic, which struck an iceberg and sank in the Atlantic Ocean in 1912, resulting in the deaths of over 1,500 passengers and crew members. The Titanic was considered a symbol of luxury and technological advancement, but it also reflected the deep class divisions of the time. Roland Barthes's semiotic analysis provides a framework for understanding the ways in which signs and symbols are used in the film to convey the class divide between the first-class and third-class passengers. These signs include clothing, colour, physical space, behaviour, accents, music and relationships between characters.
|
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Keywords | Titanic, Roland Barthes, Film Narration, Social Class. | ||||||
Introduction |
Roland Barthes's semiotic analysis provides a framework for understanding the ways in which signs and symbols are used in the film to convey the class divide between the first-class and third-class passengers. These signs include clothing, colour, physical space, behaviour, accents, music and relationships between characters.
|
||||||
Objective of study | The objective of this research paper is to conduct a semiotic analysis of class divisions and cultural identity in James Cameron's "Titanic" by examining the use of signs and symbols in the film. The study aims to provide a deeper understanding of how cultural beliefs and values are communicated through signs and symbols in the context of a tragic historical event, and how they shape our perceptions of ourselves and others. By analyzing the film through a semiotic lens, this research paper seeks to contribute to the existing body of knowledge on the relationship between culture, identity, and social class. |
||||||
Review of Literature | Roland Barthes, in his work "Mythologies,"
explains that cultural myths are created and sustained through a network of
signs and symbols. Barthes' semiotic theory emphasizes that signs and symbols
convey meaning and values that are deeply rooted in the cultural context in
which they are used. Barthes' ideas are relevant to the study of
"Titanic" because the film uses a variety of symbols and signs to
depict the social class divisions of the passengers and how these divisions
influenced the actions and decisions of individuals. Barthes' work on semiotics is further expanded upon in
his book "Elements of Semiology," which provides a more comprehensive
understanding of how signs and symbols function in different cultural contexts.
The concepts presented in Barthes' work are useful in analyzing how the use of
signs and symbols in "Titanic" creates meaning and shapes cultural
identity. LauraGT's article "The Titanic 100 Years Later:
Social Class and Survival" provides an analysis of the social class
divisions and survival rates of passengers aboard the ship. This article
highlights the correlation between social class and access to resources such as
lifeboats, which is reflected in the film through the use of symbols such as
the different dining rooms and the grand staircase. Another useful resource is ParrishMiller.com's article
"Marxist Overtones in Three Films by James Cameron," which examines
the political and social commentary in Cameron's films, including
"Titanic." The article argues that the film critiques the capitalist
system and highlights the inherent inequality and exploitation that exists
within it. Shmoop's analysis of "Titanic" further explores
the themes of society and class, highlighting how the film uses symbols such as
the heart of the ocean necklace and the character of Rose to convey the complex
relationship between social class and cultural identity.
Finally, Dusty Old Thing's article "What First,
Second, and Third Class Passengers Aboard the Titanic Ate" provides
insight into the cultural values and beliefs associated with food consumption
during the time period in which the film is set. This information is useful in
understanding how the use of symbols such as food in the film conveys social
class and cultural identity. |
||||||
Main Text |
Roland Barthes' semiotics is a method of analyzing
cultural symbols and signs to understand their meaning and significance in
society. Semiotics refers to the study of signs and symbols and how they are
used to communicate meaning, convey messages, and shape our understanding of
the world around us. Barthes believed that language and cultural symbols are
not neutral but are imbued with meaning and cultural significance. He argued
that cultural symbols and signs can be analyzed to reveal their underlying
meanings and how they contribute to the construction of social and cultural
identities. Barthes' semiotic analysis involves identifying the
signifiers (physical or sensory aspects of a symbol) and signifieds (the
meanings and associations that are evoked by the symbol). By analyzing the
relationship between the signifiers and signifieds, Barthes believed that we
can gain a deeper understanding of the cultural values, beliefs, and ideologies
that are embedded in cultural symbols and signs.Barthes' semiotics provides a
framework for understanding the ways in which cultural symbols and signs are
used to convey meaning, shape our understanding of the world, and contribute to
the construction of social and cultural identities. Such signs and cultural
symbols are prevalent in the narrative of the film Titanic which emphasises the
class divide among the passengers on the ship. Clothing Clothing is an important signifier of social class in the
film. The first-class passengers are shown wearing elegant, expensive clothing,
such as tuxedos, evening gowns, fur coats, luxurious dresses, suits, and
formalwear, while the third-class passengers are depicted wearing simpler, more
practical clothing, functional garments such as work clothes, shawls, and
blankets. The clothing worn by the first-class passengers connotes wealth,
status, and privilege, while the clothing worn by the third-class passengers
denotes poverty, lower status, and lack of privilege.The connotations
associated with the clothing choices reinforce the social hierarchy and the
power dynamics between the two classes.The differences in clothing also
highlight the class divide between the passengers, emphasizing the stark
contrast between the luxurious lifestyle of the upper class and the harsh
realities faced by the lower class.The distinction in clothing is exemplified
in the scene where Rose's mother expresses her disdain for Jack's attire, which
is not up to their social standards.The clothing choices also serve to
emphasize the class differences in terms of access to resources and the ability
to display wealth and status through fashion. Color Moreover, the use of colour in Titanic also conveys a
deeper meaning about the class divide. The first-class areas of the ship are
decorated in warm, rich colours, such as gold and red, which connote luxury and
opulence. In contrast, the third-class areas are decorated in cooler, bluish
tones, which connote poverty and harsh living conditions. The use of colour
emphasizes the differences between the classes and reinforces the idea that the
upper class enjoyed a life of luxury and privilege, while the lower class
struggled to survive. Space The physical space signs can also be analyzed using
Barthes's concepts of connotation and denotation. The spacious, luxurious
cabins complete with richly decorated interiors, fine furnishings, artwork, and
other amenitiesoccupied by the first-class passengers connote wealth, status,
and privilege, while the cramped, crowded cabinswith no privacy or personal
space, limited access to food, water, and other basic necessitiesoccupied by
the third-class passengers denote poverty, lower status, and lack of privilege.
The connotations associated with the physical space occupied by each class
reinforce the social hierarchy and the power dynamics between the two
groups.The physical space in which the characters exist serves as a powerful
signifier of their social status, emphasizing the inequality between the
classes. Relationships The film also portrays the class divide through the
relationships and interactions between characters. The wealthy passengers are
shown looking down upon the lower-class passengers and treating them with
condescension and contempt. Conversely, the lower-class passengers are depicted
as being envious and resentful of the wealthy passengers. These attitudes and
behaviours serve to reinforce the social hierarchy and the power dynamics
between the classes.The budding romance between Rose and Jack is seen as taboo
because of their different social classes. Rose's mother is highly disapproving
of the relationship and tries to keep them apart because she believes Jack is
not suitable for her daughter. Furthermore, the relationships between characters also
reflect the power dynamics that exist between the different classes. The
first-class passengers are shown exerting their power and influence over the
lower classes, often treating them as subordinates and disregarding their needs
and concerns. For example, when the ship hits the iceberg and starts sinking,
the first-class passengers are given priority access to the lifeboats, leaving
the third-class passengers to fend for themselves.The connotations associated
with the attitudes and behaviours of the wealthy passengers reinforce their
power and status, while the connotations associated with the attitudes and
behaviours of the lower-class passengers reinforce their lack of power and
status. During the sinking, the film portrays third-class men as
being at a significant disadvantage when it comes to accessing lifeboats and
finding ways to survive. They are shown struggling to make their way up to the
upper decks of the ship, where lifeboats are being loaded and are often
prevented from accessing the lifeboats by crew members who prioritize
first-class passengers. The scene where the gates leading to the upper decks
are locked, trapping third-class passengers below, highlights the sense of
powerlessness and vulnerability that these men experienced. The film also
depicts third-class men as being subject to discrimination and prejudice from
crew members and first-class passengers. They are often treated as second-class
citizens, and their concerns and needs are given little consideration. The
scene where a crew member tells Jack to stay in his place, saying "this is
for first-class passengers only," highlights the sense of exclusion and
marginalization that third-class men experienced. Accents Another important sign in the film is accents. The
first-class passengers are depicted speaking in refined accents, such as British or American accentswhile the
third-class passengers speak in regional accentssuch as Irish or Welsh accents.
The refined accents of the first-class passengers connote education,
refinement, and sophistication, while the informal accents of the third-class
passengers denote a lack of education, informality, and regionalism. The
difference in language is apparent in the scene where Jack teaches Rose how to
spit like a man, which is a sign of his lower-class upbringing.The connotations
associated with the accents serve to reinforce the social hierarchy and the
power dynamics between classes. Behaviour Behaviour is another signifier of social class in the
film. The first-class passengers are depicted as being more refined,
sophisticated, and cultured than the third-class passengers. They are shown
engaging in leisurely activities, such as playing cards, smoking cigars, and
dancing, while the third-class passengers are depicted as being more rowdy,
loud, and boisterous. The behaviour of the first-class passengers connotes
elegance, refinement, and privilege, while the behaviour of the third-class
passengers denotes a lack of culture, education, and sophistication.In one
scene, when Jack joins the first-class dinner table, he is initially viewed
with suspicion and is reminded of his place when Rose's fiancé, Cal, makes a
snide comment about his background. Music The use of music in Titanic is especially significant
because it helps to shape the audience's emotional response to the film and
reinforces the class divide portrayed in the story.The music played by the
third-class passengers in Titanic can also be analyzed in terms of its cultural
significance. The use of Irish jigs and reels serves as a signifier of the
lower-class passengers' cultural identity and heritage. This music is
associated with Irish and Celtic traditions, and its inclusion in the film
highlights the diversity of the passengers aboard the ship.However, the use of
traditional Irish music can also be seen as a signifier of the lower-class
passengers' marginalisation within the larger society. Irish immigrants were
often subjected to discrimination and prejudice in early 20th century America,
and the use of Irish music in the film can be interpreted as a nod to this
historical context. The music played by the third-class passengers is often
contrasted with the more refined and elegant music enjoyed by the upper-class
passengers. This reinforces the idea that the upper class has access to more
sophisticated forms of culture and entertainment, while the lower class is
relegated to more rough-hewn and folkloric traditions. The use of music in Titanic can also be analyzed in terms
of its visual and narrative context. For example, when Jack and Rose dance
together at the third-class party, the music is lively and upbeat, reinforcing
the sense of joy and exuberance that the characters are experiencing. In
contrast, when the ship begins to sink, the music becomes more sombre and
melancholy, connoting the sense of tragedy and loss that the characters are
experiencing.Throughout the film, the music is used to underscore the emotional
intensity of certain scenes. For example, when Jack and Rose dance together for
the first time, the music swells to convey the passion and intensity of their
budding romance. The romantic music, along with the soft lighting and the
elegant surroundings, all serve to emphasize the luxury and opulence of the upper-class
world that Rose inhabits.In contrast, when the ship begins to sink, the music
becomes more ominous and foreboding, connoting the sense of impending disaster.
The use of music in this scene heightens the tension and reinforces the idea
that the lower-class passengers, who are largely trapped in the lower decks of
the ship, are at a distinct disadvantage compared to the upper-class
passengers, who have greater access to resources and means of escape. Furthermore, the choice of music in Titanic can also be
analyzed in terms of its cultural significance. The film features several
popular songs from the early 20th century, such as "Nearer My God to
Thee," which was reportedly played by the Titanic's musicians as the ship
sank. These songs carry with them cultural connotations that are specific to
the time period in which the film is set. By using these songs in the film,
Titanic is able to create a sense of historical authenticity and convey the
cultural context in which the story takes place. Overall, the use of music in Titanic serves as a powerful
signifier of social class, cultural identity, and emotional tone. By analyzing
the music through the lens of Roland Barthes' semiotic analysis, we can gain a
deeper understanding of the ways in which music functions as a form of
communication that shapes our understanding of the world around us. Myths The film also makes use of myths and symbols to reinforce
the class divide. For example, the first-class passengers are shown being
rescued first, while the third-class passengers are left to fend for
themselves. This reinforces the myth that the wealthy are more important and
deserving of rescue than the poor. Similarly, the use of lifeboats to evacuate
passengers serves as a powerful symbol of social privilege, as the first-class
passengers are given priority access to the limited number of lifeboats available. In addition to connotation and denotation, the semiotic
analysis ofTitanic can also highlight the mythologies and ideologies portrayed
in the film. One of the dominant ideologies in Titanic is that of the American
dream, which suggests that anyone can achieve success and upward mobility
through hard work and determination. This ideology is exemplified in the
character of Jack, who comes from a lower-class background but dreams of a
better life. Jack's determination and resourcefulness enable him to win a
ticket to board the Titanic, and eventually fall in love with Rose.However,
despite Jack's efforts, the class divide remains a significant obstacle to his
success and upward mobility. His lower social status is emphasized throughout
the film, such as when he is denied access to certain areas of the ship due to
his class. Additionally, his relationship with Rose is viewed as unacceptable
by her upper-class family, further highlighting the class divide.
Another myth that is portrayed in Titanic is the idea of
chivalry and gender roles. The scene where women and children are first taken
to safety on the lifeboats while the men stay behind on the sinking ship
reinforces the societal expectations of men as protectors and providers. This
scene shows how gender roles are deeply entrenched in the society and how they
reinforced the class divide. Men of the upper class were expected to behave in
a certain way, whereas men of the lower class had to adhere to a different set
of expectations. |
||||||
Conclusion |
Roland Barthes' semiotic analysis provides a valuable framework for analyzing the class divide in Titanic. The film uses various signifiers to highlight the differences between the upper and lower classes. By analyzing these signifiers through the lens of connotation, denotation, and mythology, we can gain a deeper understanding of the ways in which class was portrayed and reinforced in early 20th-century society. |
||||||
References | 1. Admin. ‘Roland Barthes: Myth’. Critical Legal Thinking, 12 June 2020, https://criticallegalthinking.com/2020/06/12/roland-barthes-myth/.
2. Barthes, Roland. Mythologies. New York: Hill and Wang, 2012.
3. Elements of Semiology by Roland Barthes. https://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/philosophy/works/fr/barthes.htm. Accessed 18 Feb. 2023.
4. LauraGT. ‘The Titanic 100 Years Later: Social Class and Survival’. Soapboxie, 18 Oct. 2022, https://soapboxie.com/social-issues/Titanic-100-Years-Later-Social-Class-and-Survival-A-Public-Health-Perspective.
5. Marxist Overtones in Three Films by James Cameron - ParrishMiller.Com. https://parrishmiller.com/marxist-overtones-in-three-films-by-james-cameron/. Accessed 18 Feb. 2023.
6. Titanic. Directed by Cameron,James, Paramount Pictures, 20th Century Fox, 1997.
7. Titanic Society and Class | Shmoop. https://www.shmoop.com/study-guides/movie/titanic/themes/society-and-class. Accessed 18 Feb. 2023.
8. ‘What First, Second, and Third Class Passengers Aboard the Titanic Ate’. Dusty Old Thing, 29 Oct. 2019, https://dustyoldthing.com/titanic-menus-by-class/. |