P: ISSN No. 0976-8602 RNI No.  UPENG/2012/42622 VOL.- XII , ISSUE- II April  - 2023
E: ISSN No. 2349-9443 Asian Resonance
The Effect of Organic, Inorganic Fertilizers and Their Combinations in Ginger Production in Periyaptna Taluk of Mysore District
Paper Id :  17417   Submission Date :  2023-04-01   Acceptance Date :  2023-04-09   Publication Date :  2023-04-12
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
For verification of this paper, please visit on http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/resonance.php#8
R.H.Pavithra
Assistant Professor
Department Of Economics
Karnataka State Open University
,Karnataka, India
Vijay Rajan Singh
IFS
Department Of Forest
Aranya Bhavan, Malleshwaram
Banglore, India
Abstract
Agriculture is a significant sector of the Indian economy, accounting for nearly 17 percent of the gross national product (GDP). With over 60 percent of the population dependent on agriculture as their primary source of livelihood, meeting the increased demand for food grains requires sincere efforts in agricultural research and extension. Ginger, a perennial tropical crop, is widely known and cultivated globally. Ginger cultivation is considered a cash crop that can generate viable income and employment opportunities for farmers throughout the year, making it an effective tool for improving their socio-economic conditions. The study area of this research focuses on the production of Ginger in organic and inorganic fertilizer conditions, and their combinations. The results suggest that combining organic and inorganic fertilizers significantly improves the production productivity and color of Ginger. The study emphasizes the need for standardized testing, extraction, and analysis protocols to compare cultivars grown in different villages. These findings could help to develop a holistic and sustainable approach to improve soil health, increase productivity and profitability of quality Ginger, and promote the use of Ginger as an alternative crop for tobacco. Therefore, this study serves as a valuable reference for determining the most suitable treatments and cultivars for commercial production of Ginger.
Keywords Organic fertilizers, Bio-fertilizers, Inorganic fertilizers, Ginger production, Agriculture.
Introduction
Agriculture is a massive contributor to the Indian economy, accounting for almost 17% of its gross domestic product (GDP). To meet the growing demand for food, the agricultural sector requires dedicated efforts in research and extension. However, despite its significant contribution, the agricultural industry faces several challenges, including poor connectivity, market disintegration, and small landholdings. This leads to a slow adoption of improved technology and unreliable and delayed information for farmers. Therefore, it is crucial to explore various ways to keep farmers updated with modern technologies and relevant information to ensure they can keep pace with the current technological era. Ginger, one of the oldest and most cherished spices, is renowned for its fragrance and pungency. While it originated in South-East Asia, ginger has been cultivated in India and China since ancient times. Today, India is the largest producer of ginger, with Kerala and Meghalaya accounting for almost 40% of the country's production. Ginger is commonly used for both flavoring and medicinal purposes, from food preparations to confectionery, beverages, and ginger candy/preserves. It is also considered a carminative and stimulant in medicine, and ginger oil is used as a flavorant in medicines and perfumery. In Mysore District, including Periyapatna, Hunsur, HD Kote Sargur, and Nanjanagudu taluks, ginger is one of the most important cash crops for farmers, providing vital income and livelihood security. However, for more than five years, farmers have been looking to move away from traditional crops such as tobacco, maize, and cotton to more profitable crops like ginger. This shift has proved to be highly beneficial, as ginger plays a significant economic role as medicinal plants, food flavorings, and nutritional supplements. Moreover, its demand remains high throughout the year, making it a profitable crop for farmers. However, one of the main challenges faced by ginger cultivation in Karnataka is the use of unbalanced and inefficient inorganic and organic fertilizers. Most farmers in Karnataka use inorganic fertilizers, which can lead to soil hardening and decreased environmental quality. One way to improve the environment and increase the yield of ginger is to use a minimum standard quantity of a mixer combination of organic and inorganic fertilizer. Organic fertilizers can improve soil conditions, which will, in turn, help grow and yield ginger plants. This study aims to determine the effectiveness of this minimum standard quantity of a mixer combination of organic fertilizers. Organic fertilizers are naturally occurring mineral sources containing moderate levels of essential plant nutrients that can mitigate issues associated with synthetic fertilizers. They reduce the need for repeated applications of synthetic fertilizers to maintain soil fertility by gradually releasing nutrients into the soil solution and promoting nutrient balance for healthy crop growth. Organic fertilizers also serve as a valuable energy source for soil microbes, improving soil structure and crop growth. Though generally slow-release and containing many trace elements, the improper use of organic fertilizers can result in over-fertilization or nutrient deficiency. Controlled release is, therefore, essential for sustainable agriculture yield. Organic fertilizers consist of plant-derived materials such as fresh or dried plant matter, animal manure, and agricultural by-products. Nutrient content varies depending on the source material, with readily biodegradable materials providing better nutrient sources. Nitrogen and phosphorus content is typically lower than chemical fertilizers, and moisture content can further reduce or dilute their nutrient concentrations, making it less cost-effective to transport high-moisture organic fertilizers over long distances. Analyzing nutrient content is recommended, as nutrient value varies with factors such as animal diet, bedding material, manure age, and storage method. Agricultural by-products have less variable nutrient content but may be affected by the production process. Types of Organic Fertilizers Organic fertilizers are produced from plant and vegetable wastes, animal matter and excreta, and mineral sources. One of their primary advantages is their complex biological structure. They are also easily accessible since they are made from locally sourced ingredients. Some types of organic fertilizers are: 1. Composts: Compost refers to organic waste that has decomposed through composting. Organic materials such as vegetable and plant waste, as well as animal excreta, are examples of such waste. 2. Manure: Manure is composed of animal feces (such as cow dung and goat droppings). Goat manure is high in nitrogen and potassium, while cattle dung is high in nitrogen and organic carbon. 3. Vermicompost: This is the result of the degradation of organic material by numerous species of worms, resulting in a diverse combination of decomposing food waste. 4. Bone Meal: Made from animal bones and other ground slaughterhouse waste, bone meal is rich in phosphorus and amino acids. It is also a slow-release fertilizer because it is organic. Inorganic fertilizer The term "inorganic fertilizer" may suggest that it is not a natural product, but it actually contains natural compounds. However, unlike organic fertilizers that occur naturally, inorganic fertilizers are formulated in a refinery. Inorganic fertilizers contain minerals and chemicals that are essential for plant growth and are readily available at most gardening supply stores. They do not need to decompose over time to supply nutrients, unlike organic fertilizers. Inorganic fertilizers usually have balanced amounts of nitrogen, potassium, and phosphorous that are vital for plant growth, and are derived from chemical processes like urea, ammonium sulfate, and calcium nitrate. Mined deposits like potash, phosphate rock, and lime can also be processed to create inorganic fertilizers. Some gardeners use inorganic fertilizers to treat malnourished plants, as the nutrients provide instant treatment. These fertilizers help nourish all parts of the plant, including the roots, stems, shoots, leaves, and blooms. To ensure effective plant growth, inorganic fertilizers must be applied at least twice within a given growing season, depending on the crop. Gardeners generally use their hands or a gardening applicator to evenly distribute the fertilizer over the soil as per package instructions. Using broadcast spreaders or other tools can also help in evenly distributing the fertilizer and ensuring that plants receive equal amounts of nutrients from the inorganic fertilizer.
Objective of study
1. To examine usage of Organic, Inorganic Fertilizers and their Minimum standard quantity of mixer combination in Ginger production and productivity in study area.
Review of Literature

Neerja Rana et al. (2010) “Integrated farming with organic and inorganic fertilizers on yield and quality of Ginger (Zingiber officinale Rosc.)” In this study, the results clearly indicated that biofertilizer alone may not significantly increase the yield, but it certainly improves the quality. It was also found that the maximum yield of ginger could not be realized with organic manure alone. Higher yield can only be achieved with the use of organic manures in combination with inorganic fertilizers. Thus, an integrated approach of biofertilizers with inorganic fertilizers can increase the quality and yield of ginger. The recommended dose of chemical fertilizers can be reduced by the use of biofertilizer.

Sigit Soeparjono (2016) “The Effect of Media Composition and Organic Fertilizer Concentration on The Growth and Yield of Red Ginger Rhizome (Zingiber officinale Rosc.)” This study concluded that a single factor of various composition media (M) was not significantly influencing all the parameters of growth and yield of red ginger rhizome. The single factor of concentrations of liquid organic fertilizer (P) and the interaction of two-factor treatments (MP) significantly influenced all parameters of the growth and yield of red ginger rhizome. The combination of treatments (M3P3) gave the best response to all parameters: plant height (58.8 cm), number of leaves (25.2), number of buds (35.6), rhizome fresh weight per plant (2329.64 g), total biomass (258.14 g), zingeron level (1.88%), and oleoresin level (1.57%).

Shadap et al. (2018) “Integrated Effect of Organic and Inorganic Sources of Nutrients on the Yield and Quality of Ginger (Zingiber officinale Rosc.)” In this study, a field experiment was conducted to assess the yield and quality of ginger treated with different combinations of organic and inorganic nutrition. The plants raised with the integration of organic manures (vermicompost, neem cake, and compost), biofertilizers (Azospirillum, VAM, and PSB), and higher doses of inorganic NPK resulted in higher content of quality parameters such as essential oil and oleoresin as well as recovery percentage. Economic analysis indicated that the best treatment in terms of Benefit: cost ratio was observed in T5 - Vermicompost + NPK 75% + Azospirillum + VAM + PSB (4.09) followed by T4 - Vermicompost + NPK 100% + Azospirillum + VAM + PSB (3.83) and thus, clearly indicating the chance of saving 25 percent inorganic fertilizers. Thus, an integrated approach of organic and inorganic nutrition can increase the yield and quality of ginger. It clearly indicates the chance of saving 25 percent inorganic fertilizers.

Supriyono et al. (2021) “Effectiveness of giving organic fertilizer with different doses on the growth and yield of red ginger (Zingiber officinale var Rubrum)” This study aimed to obtain an effective dose of organic fertilizer in increasing the growth and yield of red ginger. From March to October 2020, the research was conducted at the UNS experimental area in Wonorejo Village, Jatiyoso, with an altitude of 778 masl. The study was conducted using a randomized complete block design (RCBD) with 1 factor and 5 treatments it is P0 (control), P1 (dose 1 kg. m-2), P2 (dose 1.5 kg. m-2), P3 (dose 2 kg. m-2), and P4 (dose 2.5 kg. m-2). The results showed that the application of organic fertilizer had an effect. The effective dose of organic fertilizer in increasing the growth and yield of red ginger was a dose of 2 kg. M-2

Methodology
The present study involves an empirical investigation based on sample interviews conducted with ginger cultivators in Mysore district. It is based on both primary and secondary data, with a systematic random sampling method adopted for the survey. The primary data was collected from various villages in Periyaptna taluks of Mysore district, where a large number of ginger cultivators grow ginger crop in Karnataka. The majority of the people in this area are economically well-off and have a good standard of living. A survey was conducted in twenty villages, including Billahalli, Komalapura, Hitnahalli, Aythanahalli, Bettadapura, Koorgallu, Sundavalu, Poodanahalli, Sathyagala, Thelaginakuppe, Harave Mallarajapatna, Harnahalli, Konasuru, and other villages in Chamarajanagar district of Karnataka state.
Sampling

The survey was conducted by selecting 90 ginger cultivators in the study area, who were randomly chosen and engaged in cultivating ginger for more than five years with at least one acre of land.

Tools Used Simple tables and the percentage method were used to analyze the results,
Statistics Used in the Study

ANOVA test was used to test the hypothesis, and the findings have been depicted in a simple chart.

Analysis

A survey was conducted in twenty villages, including Billahalli, Komalapura, Hitnahalli, Aythanahalli, Bettadapura, Koorgallu, Sundavalu, Poodanahalli, Sathyagala, Thelaginakuppe, Harave Mallarajapatna, Harnahalli, Konasuru, and other villages in Chamarajanagar district of Karnataka state. Ninety ginger cultivators were interviewed through a questionnaire, and the research findings are as follows:

Table: 1 Distribution of Gender, Age and qualification of respondents. (N=100)

Characteristics

Respondents

Percentage

Rank

Distribution of Gender

Male

74

82.22

01

Female

16

17.78

02

Distribution of Age

25 to 30

8

8.89

04

30 to35

16

17.78

03

35 to40

46

51.11

01

40 and above

20

22.22

02

Cast of respondents

SC

16

17.78

03

ST

26

28.89

02

OBC

48

53.33

01

Education Qualification

Illiterate

14

15.56

04

Primary and Higher Primary

36

40

01

PUC and above

18

20

03

Degree and above

22

24.44

02

Table 1 indicates that all of these factors have an influence on the adoption of Ginger and Tobacco cultivation. The aforementioned table demonstrates that out of a total of 100 respondents, 82.22% were male and 17.78% were female. The majority of respondents, which is 51.11%, were aged between 35 to 40 years. Only 17.78% of respondents were aged between 30 to 35 years, and a mere 8.89% fell between the ages of 25 to 30. The majority of respondents, specifically 53.33%, belonged to OBC, followed by 28.89% who belonged to ST, and 17.78% who belonged to SC, all of whom were engaged in Ginger and Tobacco cultivation in the study area.

In terms of education, 40% of respondents had qualifications up to Primary and Higher Primary, 15.56% were illiterate, 20% had PUC, and 24.44% had degrees. It is apparent that individuals who are illiterate or have only completed Primary and Higher Primary education are capable of engaging in Ginger cultivation, which requires a certain level of skill rather than a formal education.

Table 2 factor influenced adoption of Ginger cultivation. (N=100)

Characteristics

Respondents

Percentage

Rank

Occupation

Agriculture

45

50

01

Agriculture and Business

25

27.78

02

Agriculture and agricultural labourer

08

8.89

04

Agriculture and service sector

12

13.33

03

Land Holding

Below 1 Acre

10

11.11

04

1 to 2.5 acres

22

24.44

03

2.5 to 5 acres

30

33.33

01

Above 5 acres

28

31.11

02

Aera under Ginger cultivation

Below 1 Acre

40

43.96

01

1 to 2.5 acres

25

27.17

02

2.5 to 5 acres

15

16.13

03

Above 5 acres

10

10.64

04

Years of experience in Ginger

Up to 5year

12

13.33

04

5 to 10 years

40

44.44

01

10 to 15 years

23

25.56

02

Above 15year

15

16.67

03

Family Income

Less than 2lak

08

8.89

04

 2 to 5 lak

20

22.22

03

5 to 10 lak

35

38.89

01

10 and above

27

30

02

Share of Income from Ginger production

Less than 2 lak

46

51.11

01

2 to 3 lak

28

31.11

02

3 lak and above

16

17.78

03

 

 

 

 
























(Source: field survey)

Table 2 indicates that all of these factors have an impact on the adoption of Ginger cultivation. Half of the respondents (50%) depend solely on agriculture, 27.78% are involved in both agriculture and business, 8.89% engage in agriculture and agricultural labor, and 13.33% are engaged in agriculture and the service sector. In terms of land ownership, 24.44% of respondents own 1 to 2.5 acres of land, 33.33% own 2.5 to 5 acres, 31.11% own 5 acres and above, while 11.11% own less than 1 acre of land. Furthermore, 43.96% of respondents cultivate ginger in less than 1 acre of land, 27.17% cultivate in 2 to 3 acres, 16.13% cultivate in 4 to 5 acres, and only 10.64% cultivate in more than 5 acres. In terms of experience, 44.44% of respondents have 5 to 10 years of experience in ginger cultivation, 25.56% have 10 to 15 years of experience, 16.67% have more than 15 years of experience, and only 13.33% have up to 5 years of experience. With regards to family income, 8.89% of respondents have a family income of less than 2 lakhs, 22.22% have 2 to 5 lakhs, 38.89% have 5 to 10 lakhs, and 30% have 10 lakhs and above per year. In terms of income from ginger cultivation, 56% of respondents earned less than 2 lakhs, 28% earned 2 to 3 lakhs, and 16% earned 3 lakhs and above as part of their total family income. Finally, 51.11% of respondents earned less than 2 lakhs from ginger cultivation, 31.11% earned 2 to 3 lakhs, and 17.78% earned 3 lakhs and above as part of their total family income.

Materials and Treatments of Ginger cultivation 

The research was conducted in the experimental field in 30 villages of Periyapatna taluk of Mysore District This research was a field experiment by fertilizing and observing ginger plants. The research design used a Randomized Completely Block Design (RCBD). In this study, there were 3 treatments and repeated so that there were 90 observed units. The treatments used in this study were:

List of treatments in Ginger cultivation

Treatments

Description

Material used

Average yield

 

      T1

Fully organic

Green manure + cow dung 10 tonnes/a +chicken manure 3 tonnes/a + neem cake 2 tonnes/a + biofertilizer + waste decompose solution + Jeevabrutha once in every 15days

 

180 bags

(60 Kgs per bag)

 

      T2

Fully inorganic

NPK 100:50:50 kg/a + water soluble fertilizer 60kg/a + Granules 40kg/a + Micro Nutrients 50kg/a + Plant protection Chemicals

 

230 bags

(60 Kgs per bag)

 

 

     T3

Minimum standard quantity of mixer combination of organic and in organic fertilizer

Green manure + cow dung 6 tonnes/a +chicken manure 2 tonnes/a + waste decompose solution + NPK 80:40:40 kg/a + water soluble fertilizer40kg/a + neem cake +biofertilizer+ Granules 40kg/a + Micro Nutrients 20kg/a + Plant protection Chemicals

 

350 bags

(60 Kgs per bag)

Result and Discussion

In this study, there were 90 respondents' plots, each with 1 acre of land. Growth observations, including plant height, number of leaves, number of tillers, and total weight of rhizomes, were carried out once a month, while harvesting observations were carried out simultaneously, including rhizome size (length, width, thickness), fresh weight of rhizome per clump and plot, rhizome storage weight per clump and plot, and fresh straw and dry straw plant weight. Data analysis using analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed to determine the effect of treatment on variables. The results presented in Table 1 showed that different treatments had a significant effect on the yield and quality of ginger, particularly on production and productivity. The combined application of organic manures, biofertilizers, and inorganic fertilizers had a beneficial effect on yield and yield attributing characters, with chicken manure producing the best performance and higher yield among the organic manures. The study findings are consistent with the observations of farmers in ginger. The data in the table also showed that the application of a minimum standard quantity of mixer combination of organic and inorganic fertilizer significantly increased the performance of ginger in terms of yield and quality compared to other treatments with similar organic manures and inorganic nutrition combination. The study suggests that the use of minimum standard quantity of mixer combination of organic and inorganic fertilizer has a positive impact on enhancing the production and productivity of ginger, attributed to the improved physico-chemical and biological properties of the soil resulting in better utilization and absorption of NPK and micronutrients required for enhancing the quality of the Ginger rhizome.

Average Ginger Production at deferent Treatments (cropping practice) in study area


T1

T2

T3

170

215

350

170

215

330

170

215

360

170

215

290

150

215

340

150

200

360

150

200

350

150

200

320

200

200

390

160

200

370

200

230

400

200

230

380

200

230

350

180

230

350

175

260

350

175

260

370

215

270

370

250

270

370

200

270

370

220

270

360

190

260

360

180

260

360

190

250

360

215

280

360

200

200

360

130

200

290

115

175

340

165

190

340

190

220

300

170

270

300

∑T1=5400

∑T2=6900

∑T3=10500



H0: There is no significant differentiating between samples.
H1: There is significant differentiating between samples.
F (2,87) at 0.05 level of significance =3.1013
As calculated F=279.0336>3.1013.
So, H0 is rejected, hence there is significant differentiating between samples








Swoc Anlysis

Strengths

Weakness

1. Climatic and soil Suitability

2. Possibility of multiple cropping within a year like maize, bean, and vegetables

3. Alternate commercial crop for tobacco

1. Non availability of enough and hybrid seeds

2. Lack of scientific and technical Knowledge

3. Uncertainty in price up and down

4. Less awareness regarding risk management practice.

5. There is no good marketing and minimum support price facility.

Opportunities

Challenges

1. Create High demand for ginger through export to other countries.

2. Relatively can create good income for farmers after combination of risk management practice.

3. Can be use modern farming practice.

1. High incidence of disease and pest leading to low production.

2. Less availability of agri-credit at lower rate of interest.

3.Youth migration leading to labor shortage

4. Fertilizer, Plant protection chemicals, labor cost irrigation materials are rapidly increased.

Conclusion
There is a limited number of studies available in the literature on the production of ginger using organic, inorganic, and combined fertilizer conditions. This study, which involved a range of comparative fertilizer treatments, is considered a valuable reference for determining the most suitable treatments and cultivars for commercial production. The findings of the study suggest that the combination of organic and inorganic fertilizers significantly improves the production, productivity, and color of ginger, and it is necessary to apply chemical fertilizers together to obtain high-quality ginger. In conclusion, there is a need for standardized testing, extraction, and analysis protocols to compare cultivars grown in different villages. This research will undoubtedly be helpful in better understanding the use of the minimum standard quantity of mixer combination of organic and inorganic fertilizer for ginger as a holistic and sustainable approach to improving soil health and increasing the productivity and profitability of quality ginger.
Suggestions for the future Study 1. Ginger cultivators should be educated about scientific methods to produce higher yields at lower costs.
2. The government should conduct seminars and farmers' meetings to create awareness about risk management practices in ginger cultivation.
3. A good environment should be created to provide production and market information through smartphone and mobile applications.
4. The government should protect ginger cultivators against excessive falls in price during bumper production years by providing a minimum support price as a guarantee and issuing agri-credit at lower interest rates.
5. There is a need to create regulated marketing facilities, storage structures, and processing units in the study area.
Acknowledgement Author thanks Authorities of Karnataka State open Universaity for giving me an opportunity to prepare this paper.
References
1. Neerja Rana et al. (2010) “Integrated farming of organic and inorganic fertilizers on yield and quality of Ginger (zingiber officinales rosc.)”. Agricultural Research Communication Centre, Vol. 30, No. 4, pp. 250-253. 2. Sigit Soeparjono (2016) “The effect of media composition and organic fertilizer concentration on the growth and yield of red ginger rhizome (Zingiber officinale Rosc.)” in Agriculture and Agricultural Science Procedia 9 (2016), pp. 450-455, doi: 10.1016/j.aaspro.2016.02.162. 3. A. Shadap et al. (2018) “Integrated effect of organic and inorganic sources of nutrients on the yield and quality of ginger (Zingiber officinale Rosc.)” in International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences ISSN: 2319-7706 Volume 7, pp. 754-760. 4. G. Chandrashekhar et al. (2019) “ effect of growth and yield of the ginger with the combination of organic, inorganic, and biofertilizers” in Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry; 8(3): pp. 1174-1176. 5. Supriyono et al. (2021) “Effectiveness of giving organic fertilizer with different doses on the growth and yield of red ginger (Zingiber officinale var Rubrum)” in The 8th International Conference on Sustainable Agriculture and Environment 905 (2021), 012063, doi: 10.1088/1755-1315/905/1/012063. 6. Olayinka, A., Olayinka, B.U., Olayinka, O.A. (2018). Effect of Organic, Inorganic and Combined Fertilizers on the Growth and Yield of Ginger (Zingiber officinale Rosc.). International Journal of Agriculture and Biology, 20(6), 1383-1389. 7. Sharmila, S., Ramanathan, T. (2017). Comparative study on the effect of organic and inorganic fertilizers on growth and yield of ginger (Zingiber officinale). International Journal of ChemTech Research, 10(5), 233-238. 8. Reddy, G.K., Reddy, P.M., Kumar, K.V., Raju, M.K. (2016). Effect of different organic and inorganic fertilizers on growth, yield and quality of ginger (Zingiber officinale Rosc.). International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences, 5(2), 1-10. 9. Kumar, R., Singh, V.K., Kumar, M. (2015). Effect of organic, inorganic and bio-fertilizers on growth and yield of ginger (Zingiber officinale Rosc.). International Journal of Agricultural Science and Research, 5(3), 321-326. 10. Gangaiah, B., Ravindra Babu, P., Srilatha, V., Sreenivasulu, R. (2014). Effect of organic and inorganic fertilizers on growth, yield and quality of ginger (Zingiber officinale Rosc.). Journal of Plant Nutrition, 37(6), 927-939.