|
|||||||
Unveiling Socio-Cultural Barriers to Womens Participation in Panchayati Raj Institutions in Western Odisha, India: Implications for Social Work Practice | |||||||
Paper Id :
17696 Submission Date :
2023-08-01 Acceptance Date :
2023-08-12 Publication Date :
2023-08-14
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. For verification of this paper, please visit on
http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/innovation.php#8
|
|||||||
| |||||||
Abstract |
This paper examines the socio-cultural factors that hinder
women's meaningful participation in Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) in the
region of western Odisha, India. Despite significant strides towards
decentralized and democratic governance at the grassroots level, women's
representation and involvement face various socio-cultural constraints. The study,
conducted in four Gram Panchayats in western Odisha, utilizes primary data
collected through Interview Schedules, Focused Group Discussions, and personal
interviews, supported by relevant secondary data. The research findings
indicate a significant disparity in women's participation in the
decision-making process of the sample Panchayats. Women's plans and demands are
often overlooked, with decision-making primarily dominated by Sarpanch, Word
members, and male Panchayat members. Lady ward members rarely attend village
affairs meetings, frequently delegating representation to their husbands,
resulting in the silencing of women's voices. The paper identifies
socio-cultural restrictions and taboos as key barriers to women's participation
and suggests comprehensive efforts to challenge gender norms, provide education
and awareness, promote inclusive decision-making, and establish support systems
for active female participation in PRIs. Additionally, the application of micro
social work practices is proposed to empower women for more inclusive
participation in PRIs. |
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Keywords | Panchayati Raj Institutions, Women's Participation, Socio-Cultural Constraints, Gender Norms, Decision-Making, Inclusive Governance, Micro Social Work Practices. | ||||||
Introduction | Deep-rooted gender roles and stereotypes prescribe certain
expectations and limitations for women within society. These stereotypes often
view women as caregivers and restrict their participation in public and
political spheres, including Panchayati Raj Institutions.Societies with strong
patriarchal norms tend to prioritize male leadership and decision-making.These
norms can create significant barriers for women aspiring to participate in
PRIs, as they may face resistance, discrimination, and limited support from
their communities. Since gaining independence, rural development has emerged as
a significant objective in India's planning endeavors. The government's
intervention in this realm is deemed essential due to the substantial
population residing in rural areas. Recognizing that increasing agricultural
and industrial output alone would not suffice, attention must also be directed
towards addressing education, healthcare, employment, and poverty in rural
regions. Consequently, the decentralization of governance through the
establishment of a three-tier system of local self-government has been a
crucial step towards fostering broader public participation in India's
democratic framework. The involvement of the populace is a key attribute of
good governance, and its realization within local self-government is a
fundamental prerequisite for driving rural development. The significance of
people's participation in governance and development has garnered recognition
from both national and international organizations. In contemporary society,
the terms governance and good governance have gained increasing prominence in
development discourse. Poor governance is considered a primary cause of
societal ills, while good governance is deemed essential for sustainable
development. At the Panchayati Raj Institution level, good governance plays a
pivotal role in promoting rural development. People's participation, along with
traits such as transparency, responsibility, accountability, and responsiveness
to people's needs, is a cornerstone of good governance. Both men and women must
actively engage in governance processes. According to Joel and Bhore (2003),
people's participation lies at the heart of development. While various elements
such as money, resources, technology, and human capital contribute to
development, human factors are the most crucial. Development should revolve
around people, placing them at the center of human progress (Joel and Bhore,
2003). Active engagement and involvement of the community in all stages of
Panchayat-level development projects, including planning, implementation,
monitoring, and evaluation, are critical for enhancing good governance in local
self-governance. Genuine rural transformation can only be achieved through
sustained and active participation by the people. Ahmed (1987) describes
decentralization as a reform package, with people's participation being one of
its core objectives. Within the context of Panchayati Raj Institutions,
strengthening people's involvement in the Gram Sabha is vital for ensuring
accountability of Panchayats and the overall system to the people (Vaddiraju,
2004). Despite being recognized as constitutional bodies and implementing
numerous development initiatives, Panchayati Raj Institutions have yet to
achieve the desired success in rural development. Encouraging women's
participation in decision-making processes and empowering women political
representatives at the grassroots level are crucial steps to make rural women
more active and engaged in rural development. |
||||||
Objective of study | The present study aims to achieve the following objectives: 1. Evaluate the level of women's awareness regarding
Panchayat activities and rural development programmes/schemes. 2. Analyze the socio-cultural factors that influence women's
participation in Palli Sabha and Gram Sabha. 3. Assess the extent of women's participation in Gram Sabha
and Palli Sabha conducted at the Gram Panchayat level. 4. Develop intervention strategies for social work practices
that promote women's empowerment through their active participation in PRIs. |
||||||
Review of Literature | According to Joel and Bhore (2003), people's
participation lies at the heart of development. While various elements such as
money, resources, technology, and human capital contribute to development,
human factors are the most crucial. Development should revolve around people,
placing them at the center of human progress.Ahmed (1987) describes
decentralization as a reform package, with people's participation being one of
its core objectives. Within the context of Panchayati Raj Institutions,
strengthening people's involvement in the Gram Sabha is vital for ensuring
accountability of Panchayats and the overall system to the people (Vaddiraju,
2004).Cohen and Ulhoff (1977) suggest that participation
encompasses the involvement of people throughout the entire decision-making
process.A study by Afsar (1999) emphasizes the limited involvement of the poor
in local development activities and the minimal engagement of the community in
decision-making. Women, in particular, exhibit less interest in participating
due to their views and opinions not being taken seriously, causing them to
perceive it as a mere waste of time |
||||||
Methodology | Odisha, known for its high levels of poverty and seasonal
migration, particularly in its western region, is considered one of the most
backward and underprivileged states in India. Despite the implementation of
various schemes and programmes, western Odisha continues to face
marginalization and backwardness compared to the eastern part of the state.
This study was conducted in four Gram Panchayats, located in Bargarh and Sambalpur
districts. Two Gram Panchayats were purposively selected from each district.
The primary respondents of the study were married women from the selected
Panchayats, while the secondary respondents were male members of the sample
households. Data were also collected from political representatives, including
Sarpanchand Ward members, from the sample Panchayats in both districts. A total
of ninety women were interviewed, with forty-five respondents from Bargarh
district and forty-five from Sambalpur district. The women were selected from
the voter list of the sample villages using a simple random sampling technique.
Qualitative data were collected through various methods, including Focus Group
Discussions (FGDs), personal interviews, and informal meetings. Four FGDs were
conducted among women respondents, with one FGD conducted in each Panchayat.
Separate FGDs were also conducted among the husbands of the sample women to
capture their perspectives on women's participation in PRIs. Personal
interviews were conducted to gather the views and opinions of the husbands,
particularly focusing on the dynamics of male perspectives towards women's
participation. Special attention was given to collecting the voices of husbands
of female political representatives (female ward members). Secondary data were
collected from government officials, websites, and Panchayat offices.
Initially, some women hesitated to participate in the research; however, with
time, they began expressing their views and opinions freely after understanding
the research objectives. Pseudonyms are used in the research paper to maintain
confidentiality when analysing voice recordings. |
||||||
Result and Discussion |
People’s Participation Participation can be defined as
the active involvement and inclusion of individuals in various economic,
social, cultural, and political processes that have an impact on their lives.
According to the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP, 1993), participation
implies that people have a close and meaningful engagement in shaping and
implementing development programs to enhance their well-being, whether in terms
of income, personal growth, self-reliance, or other values that they
prioritize. Cohen and Ulhoff (1977) suggest that participation encompasses the
involvement of people throughout the entire decision-making process. In the context of development
literature, participation signifies the direct involvement of individuals in
the decision-making processes that are likely to affect their lives. It entails
the active engagement and contribution of people during all phases of a
development project, including planning, implementation, monitoring, and
evaluation. According to ZubairMeenai (2008), the principle of participation is
widely recognized as a fundamental right. The right to participate in public
affairs implies that every person and all people are entitled to actively
engage, contribute, and enjoy civil, economic, social, and political development. Participation can be viewed from
two perspectives: Participation as a
Process In this perspective, participation is seen as
a process within a development program where local people are actively involved
in the implementation of externally designed initiatives. It involves
collaboration between external agencies and the local population, working
together to implement development activities in a participatory manner.
Participation, in this sense, serves as a means or instrument to implement a
program and achieve the desired goals. Participation as an
End In this perspective,
participation is seen as a goal of policy initiatives, with the aim of
empowering people to acquire skills, knowledge, and experience that enable them
to take greater responsibility for their own development. This involves
providing people with access to power and resources, creating opportunities
that are self-sustaining and enable them to actively participate in
decision-making processes. The goal is to enhance people's agency and autonomy
in shaping their own development outcomes. The present study places greater
emphasis on the second perspective of participation, viewing it as an end in
itself, specifically focusing on the empowerment of women through their active
participation in local self-governance. The study analyzes the collected data
and information within the context of women's empowerment, assuming that the
level of women's participation in Gram Sabha and Palli Sabha is directly linked
to their level of empowerment in the study area. However, it is important to note
that the scope of the present study extends beyond viewing participation solely
as a means of empowerment. It also utilizes women's participation as a key
attribute to analyze the state of governance at the Panchayat level in the
study area. By examining women's participation, the study aims to gain insights
into the existing governance practices and dynamics within the Panchayat
system. Palli Sabha The Orissa Gram Panchayat Act,
1964 establishes the formation of Palli Sabha, which represents a Ward within a
Grama. When multiple contiguous villages constitute a Grama, the neighbouring
villages will have their respective Palli Sabha. The Palli Sabha comprises all
individuals registered in the electoral roll for the Assembly Constituency that
pertains to the Palli Sabha's area. The Palli Sabha convenes annually in
February. The Ward Member of the respective Ward, for which the Palli Sabha is
constituted, presides over the Palli Sabha. If there are multiple eligible
individuals, the Grama Panchayat determines the order of preference for their
selection. In the absence of an eligible person at the designated meeting time,
the members present may elect a President from among themselves. The presence
of the members at any Palli Sabha meeting constitutes a quorum, and the
proceedings of the meeting are recorded and authenticated by the
President.During its annual meeting in February, the Palli Sabha has the responsibility
to provide recommendations to the Grama Panchayat regarding matters such as (a)
development works and programs to be undertaken in the upcoming year and (b)
the annual budget estimate submitted by the Grama Panchayat. Gram Sabha The 73rd Amendment to the Indian
Constitution introduced the concept of Gram Sabha or village assembly as a
crucial part of decentralized governance. It established a three-tier structure
of Panchayats, ranging from the village level to the district level. According
to Article 243(b) of the Constitution, the Gram Sabha is defined as a body
comprising individuals registered in the electoral rolls pertaining to a
village within the jurisdiction of the Panchayat at the village level.
Additionally, in clause (g), the term "village" refers to a village
specified by the Governor through a public notification for the purpose of
"Part IX: The Panchayats," which may also include a group of villages
specified in such a manner. The Gram Sabha serves as a
platform that allows every eligible voter in the village to participate in
local decision-making. It is a constitutional body composed of all individuals
registered in the electoral rolls of a village Panchayat. Its primary function
is to provide a political forum for villagers to come together, discuss common
issues, understand the community's needs and aspirations, and contribute to the
decision-making process. It also serves as a platform to review and evaluate
the development and administrative actions taken by elected representatives,
promoting transparency and accountability in the functioning of the village
Panchayat. The Gram Sabha is envisioned as a symbol of participatory and direct
democracy, playing a vital role in providing valuable inputs to the Gram
Panchayat for effective local governance. Furthermore, the Gram Sabha is
entrusted with the responsibility of acting as a watchdog, safeguarding the
interests of the village communities by monitoring the functioning of the Gram
Panchayat. It has the authority to address and discuss various developmental
issues affecting the village and is duty-bound to deliberate on them during
meetings to seek consensus among its members. Findings Functioning
of Gram Sabha in the Sample Panchayats In the observed sample
Panchayats, it has been noted that both the Gram Sabha and Palli Sabha meetings
are not consistently organized. Maintaining the required quorum and ensuring
meaningful participation of women show inconsistencies. Siddiqui (1994) pointed
out that the majority of individuals, especially those who are poor and
disadvantaged, have limited or no opportunities to participate beyond the
selection of their representatives. The Gram Sabha meetings, which are expected
to be held at least twice a year in February and June, are often conducted
without prior notice to the people. Consequently, many women are unable to
participate in these meetings and contribute to the decision-making process. A study by Afsar (1999)
emphasizes the limited involvement of the poor in local development activities
and the minimal engagement of the community in decision-making. Women, in
particular, exhibit less interest in participating due to their views and
opinions not being taken seriously, causing them to perceive it as a mere waste
of time. Additionally, during the study, it was observed that the provision for
women's participation in Gram Sabha and Palli Sabha is not effectively
implemented. Even female ward members do not attend meetings regularly and are
often asked to merely sign their names by their husbands or other male family
members. Although women from scheduled castes and scheduled tribes may
participate in Palli Sabha, their involvement. A respondent named Pallavi Bhoi
says: “I am elected as the
Sarpanch of my Panchayat only with the support of my husband and family
members. I am a lady and I have to take care of the family members and at the
same time I have to finish many household chores. So occasionally I attend
meetings and my husband takes care of the affairs” The quoted statement reflects the
perspective of a woman who shares her experience of being elected as the
Sarpanch of her Panchayat with the support of her husband and family members.
She mentions that as a woman, she also has responsibilities to take care of her
family members and fulfil various household chores. Consequently, she is only
able to attend meetings occasionally, while her husband takes care of the
affairs in her absence. This statement highlights the
challenges faced by women in balancing their roles and responsibilities as both
elected representatives and caretakers of their households. The woman's limited
availability for attending meetings is influenced by societal expectations and
gender roles assigned to women. It underscores the need for support mechanisms
and strategies that enable women to effectively manage their dual roles and
actively participate in the affairs of the Panchayat. These findings highlight the
significant lack of awareness among women in the study area regarding the
functioning and importance of Gram Sabha and their roles within the Panchayat
system. remains superficial, relegating them to the
role of mere bystanders. Participation
of Women in PRIs
Indian villages are divided on caste and class basis. Gender plays an important role in the rural pockets of Odisha. Men have say in most of the decisions and women remain at the periphery.The principle of gender equality and protection of women’s rights has been receiving attention from the days of independence. (Sharma, 2011). However,Nanda (2006) reveals that in spite of having a constitution and the 73rd amendment act which reinforces the equity and equality and social justice, women is insignificant and not into decision making in such bodies/ organizations. Similar trends are also found in the study area where women are the most marginalized section. The study reveals that women are not invited to Gram Sabha and PalliSabha. Palanithuri (1997) in a case study “NewPanchayati Raj System at Work: An evaluation of Tamilnadu” reported that they were not informed on invited to the meetings in male headed Gram Panchayat. When focused group discussions are organized with women of the sample Panchayats it is found that a few women hesitate to participate in the meeting as the elder male members of the village remain present in the meeting but a significant number of women have an interest to participate in the meeting but their wish is suppressed by the male members of the family.Nambiar(2001) in her study of “Making the Gram Sabha Work” noted the difference utilities in organizing the gram Sabha. Majority of women reported that they were not informed or invited to the meetings, while other were hesitant in participating in meetings in the presence of a large number of elder members.Biswal (2020) The socio-cultural background of the individuals and the values of the particular society also play a seminal role in enabling and providing appropriate opportunities to the women to take part in the important phenomena of the society. Creating greater awareness among both women and men is also essential at the same time to bring attitudinal change among the male members of the society towards the women. During the study only 8 (8.88%) women mentioned that they participate regularly in the Panchayat meetings. Another 14 (15.55%) women participate seldom participate in the meetings of the Panchayat while a large 68 (75.55%) women never participate in the Panchayat meetings.
Source:
Fieldwork The
socio-cultural practices also become a constraint for women to participate in
the meetings. The image of women going and sitting in the middle of the village
among the male members in case of PalliSabha and in the Panchayat office among
the male members of different villages in case of Gram Sabha is not quite an
acceptable behavior. It is considered to be a sense of disrespect to the male
members of the family and disgrace to the family and hence a form of deviant
behavior. Thus, hardly a woman dares to participate in the meetings. However,
the strong desire to participate in the meeting is expressed by one of the
female respondents Mrs. TejaswiniSahuwho says: “Whenever
I come to know about a PalliSabha being organized in the village, I feel like
going and sitting there. I have many things to speak about my village but I
dare not to participate.” The quoted statement reflects the
perspective of a woman in the village who expresses her desire to participate
in the Palli Sabha but faces resistance from her husband. She mentions that
whenever she becomes aware of a Palli Sabha being organized, she feels inclined
to attend and share her thoughts about the village. However, she feels hesitant
and reluctant to participate due to the societal norms and expectations placed
on women.She discloses that she has discussed her desire to participate with
her husband, but he disapproves and questions her about the absence of women
from their village participating in such meetings. He raises concerns about how
her participation would be perceived by others in the community and the potential
consequences for their family's reputation. As a result, she remains silent and
refrains from actively engaging in the Palli Sabha. This excerpt highlights the
challenges and social pressures faced by women in rural communities when it
comes to their participation in decision-making processes. Cultural norms and
gender roles often restrict women's agency and discourage their active
involvement in public forums. Women
mention during the study that though they hardly participate in Palli Sabha and
Gram Sabha, their participation is high in public meetings during electoral
campaign. Many women travel to the meeting place from each of the sample
villages to participate during such electoral campaign. Rohini Bhoi says “I
do not know what is Palli Sabha and Gram Sabha but I participate in the
meetings during election because a large number of women go together to the
meeting and so also, I go with them.” The quoted statement reflects the
perspective of a woman who admits to not knowing what Palli Sabha and Gram
Sabha are, but she participates in the meetings during elections. She mentions
that she joins the meetings because many other women also attend, and she goes
along with them. This statement highlights a situation where the woman's
participation in the meetings is primarily influenced by the collective
presence of other women rather than a personal understanding of the purpose or
significance of Palli Sabha and Gram Sabha. It suggests that her involvement is
more driven by the social dynamics and group dynamics during election-related
events rather than a clear understanding of the decision-making processes or
objectives of these meetings. This scenario underscores the need for greater
awareness and education about the roles and functions of Palli Sabha and Gram
Sabha, ensuring that women have a deeper understanding of their significance
beyond the context of elections. Socio-Cultural
Factors Influencing Women’s Participation in PRIs There are several factors that influence
the level of women's participation in the sample Panchayats. One significant
factor is the lack of awareness among women about the importance of
participating in Gram Sabha meetings, which contributes to their apathy towards
involvement. Khan (2009) identifies bureaucratic domination in local councils,
lack of knowledge, and limited expertise in technical matters as root causes of
non-participation. Local elites often collude with the local administration to
prioritize their own interests, neglecting the needs of the masses. As a
result, participation in Panchayats tends to be limited to the affluent, while
the rural poor have minimal representation. Common factors influencing participation
include migration, awareness levels among the population, family income
standards, education levels, cultural practices, and the dissemination of
information. Seasonal migration for livelihood opportunities is a prevalent
phenomenon in Bargarh district. People heavily migrate to other states during
lean periods, and there is also migration within the district from
non-irrigated to irrigated areas. Consequently, women are deprived of
participating in meetings during such periods. Many women report non-participation
due to a lack of awareness about the meetings. The study also reveals that
women are unaware of the importance of Gram Sabha and Palli Sabha.
Additionally, Panchayat officials fail to effectively communicate information
about meeting dates and locations. Since the sampled women come from lower
economic backgrounds, mostly working as farmers and wage laborers, they
prioritize their work over attending morning meetings, as they return from work
in the afternoon. Socio-cultural factors in the study area
further restrict women's participation in Palli Sabha and Gram Sabha. The
presence of women alongside elder family members during these meetings is
deemed unacceptable by villagers in the sample area. The cultural practices and
norms discourage women from participating in Palli Sabha and Gram Sabha. The
idea of a woman sitting among men in the center of the village is perceived as
unacceptable. Thus, cultural practices heavily influence women's participation
levels in Panchayati Raj Institutions at the grassroots level. The study also reveals that some women
are dissatisfied with the work of Panchayat officials. They report that
discussions and decisions made in Palli Sabha and Gram Sabha are not
implemented. Research by Kosecik and Sagbas (2004) indicates a relationship
between citizens' attitudes toward local government and their level of
participation in local government affairs. Stevenson (2007) found that
individuals with a positive attitude toward local government are more likely to
engage in local governance. Ledingham (2001) suggests that citizens are
inclined to participate in local government when they perceive that it provides
benefits, acts in the best interest of the community, and allocates resources
to address citizens' concerns. Citizens expect a mutually beneficial
interaction with local government and seek a balance between the social costs
of engaging with the government. For relationships between people and local
government to be effective, they need to be perceived as mutually beneficial and
based on mutual interest. Gender Roles and
Stereotypes Deep-rooted gender roles and stereotypes
prescribe certain expectations and limitations for women in the sample
community. These stereotypes often view women as caregivers and restrict their
participation in public and political spheres, including Panchayati Raj
Institutions (PRIs). Patriarchal Norms Societies with strong patriarchal norms
tend to prioritize male leadership and decision-making. These normscreate
significant barriers for women aspiring to participate in PRIs, as they face
resistance, discrimination, and limited support from their communities. Women's
restricted mobility due to cultural norms and safety concerns can hinder their
active participation in PRIs. Traditional expectations may confine women to
their homes, limiting their access to training, meetings, and interaction with
other PRI members. Lack of Education
and Awareness Limited access to quality education and
low levels of awareness about political processes and rights impede women's
participation in PRIs. Educational disparities undermine their confidence,
skills, and understanding of governance, making it difficult for them to
effectively contribute. “I used to
visualise myself as the Sarpanch of our Panchayat since childhood. But my dream
remains a distant dream as I could not go for upper classes due to lack of
support from my family and how can I contest in the panchayat with low
education.” The
statement from the respondent highlights her childhood dream of becoming the
Sarpanch of her Panchayat, a position of leadership in their local community.
However, several challenges stand in the way of realizing this dream. Social Stigma and Opposition Women who challenge societal norms by
participating in PRIs face social stigma, criticism, and opposition. This
discourages potential candidates from entering politics and result in
self-exclusion due to fear of social isolation or reputation damage. During the
focus group discussion, the women shared that attending village meetings where
male members of the villages are also there bring bad reputation for the
family. If at all any women is interested to go and participate then she is
discouraged by the family members. A respondent named janakabhoi says: “You see, it is
not the trend of our community to attend meetings with the male members of the
family. When my husband and his elder brother are there in the meeting, how can
I sit among them and attend the Palli Sabha and Gram Sabha. It does not look
nice to me.” The
statement from the respondent, Janaka Bhoi, highlights the societal challenges
and gender norms that discourage women from participating in Panchayati Raj
Institutions (PRIs) and political activities. She mentions that women who
challenge societal norms by attending meetings with male family members face
social stigma, criticism, and opposition. This reflects the deep-rooted
patriarchal mindset and gender biases prevalent in the community. Such stigma
can discourage women from actively participating in political activities,
fearing social isolation or damage to their reputation. The respondent
expresses concern that attending village meetings alongside male family members
may lead to a bad reputation for the family. This fear of social isolation and
reputation damage can deter women from engaging in political activities, as
they prioritize maintaining the family's honor.This highlights the gendered
cultural norms and expectations that restrict women's participation in public
forums and decision-making processes. Such norms perpetuate gender inequalities
and limit women's access to political spaces. The
challenges identified by Janaka Bhoi reflect the need for broader societal
change to overcome gender biases and promote gender equality in political
participation. Addressing these issues requires community-level interventions,
awareness campaigns, and advocacy efforts to challenge gender norms, educate
community members about the importance of women's participation, and foster a
supportive environment for women in politics. Lack of Support
Structures Inadequate support structures, such as
childcare facilities and networks pose challenges for women seeking to balance
their familial responsibilities with PRI participation. The absence of
supportive policies and resources further restricts their ability to actively
engage in PRIs. The lady wards members share their experience of facing
difficulties in balancing the household chores and their involvement in PRIs
activities. Mousumi Padhan says “I am elected as
the ward member of my village but I seldom attend meetings both in the village
and in the Panchayat Office. Most of the time my husband attends meetings on
behalf of me as I have to cook and take care of my two daughters.”
The statement from the respondent highlights the challenges faced by women who are elected as ward members in their village, but are unable to actively participate in meetings due to household responsibilities and childcare duties. The respondent mentions that she is unable to attend meetings regularly because she has to prioritize cooking and taking care of her two daughters. This reflects the gendered division of labor in many societies, where women are expected to shoulder the majority of household responsibilities and childcare duties. These responsibilities often limit their ability to engage fully in public and political activities. The respondent's commitment to her household duties and childcare responsibilities leaves her with limited time to attend meetings. This highlights the competing demands and priorities that women face, which can make it challenging for them to dedicate time to their elected roles. Balancing family responsibilities with political commitments becomes a significant barrier for women in active participation. The respondent mentions that her husband attends meetings on her behalf. While this may seem like a practical solution to ensure representation, it perpetuates the assumption that men are more suitable or available for political participation, while women's role is limited to domestic affairs. It is crucial to challenge these gender norms and encourage equal participation and shared responsibilities within households. Imperative For Social Work Practice Social work with women is a specialized field that focuses
on addressing the unique challenges, needs, and empowerment of women across
various contexts. It encompasses a range of interventions aimed at promoting
gender equality, empowering women, and addressing issues related to
discrimination, violence, social injustice, and inequality. Social workers can play a crucial
role in addressing the constraints on women's participation in Panchayati Raj
Institutions (PRIs) and promoting gender equality. Social workers working with women should be guided by
principles of social justice, human rights, and empowerment. Social workers should
strive to provide a safe, non-judgmental space for women to share their
experiences, identify their strengths, and work towards achieving their goals.
By addressing the unique socio-cultural challenges faced by women in the study area,
social workers can contributeto building a more equitable, inclusive, and
gender-just society. When addressing the socio-cultural
constraints of women issues, social workers can employ various methods of
practice based on the specific context and needs of the individuals and
communities they serve. Some social work practice that can be effective in
addressing these issues have been discussed below. Case Work Casework with women of the community in
general and with the elected women can provide a safe and confidential space
for women to explore their experiences, emotions, and challenges. Social
workers can utilize various therapeutic approaches to help women build
resilience, develop coping strategies, and work towards personal empowerment. Group Work Group interventions bring together
women who share similar experiences or face common challenges in the study area.
Social group workers can facilitate group discussions, support networks, and
skill-building sessions to foster mutual support, empowerment, and collective
problem-solving. Community Organisation Social workers can be engaged with
communities to understand their needs, build partnerships, and mobilize
resources. They can facilitate community development initiatives, encourage
active participation, and empower women to take leadership roles in addressing
community concerns. Capacity Building and Skills
Training Social workerscan provide capacity-building
programs and skills training to enhance women's knowledge regarding PRIs,
abilities, and self-confidence. This can include workshops on leadership,
communication, financial literacy, legal rights, and vocational training to
promote economic empowerment. Crisis Intervention Social workers can respond to
immediate crises and emergencies in the study area such as cases of domestic
violence, sexual assault, or trafficking. They can provide safety planning,
connect survivors with appropriate services, and support their journey towards
healing and recovery. Research and Evaluation Social workers can conduct research
and evaluation to better understand the socio-cultural barriers faced by women
and assess the effectiveness of interventions. Research findings help shape
evidence-based practices, inform policy development, and drive continuous
improvement in social work interventions. Social workers can advocate for
policy reforms, gender-responsive initiatives, and targeted interventions to
promote women's participation and influence in PRIs. Networking and Collaboration Social workers can facilitate
networking opportunities for women within PRIs, connecting them with other
women leaders, experts, and organizations. By creating supportive networks,
social workers can enable knowledge-sharing, solidarity, and collective action
among women in PRIs. Policy Development and
Implementation Social workers can actively engage
in policy development processes, ensuring that gender equality and women's
empowerment are integral components of PRI policies and programs. They can also
monitor the implementation of gender-responsive policies to address gaps and
barriers effectively. By fulfilling these roles, social
workers contribute to the broader goal of creating an inclusive and equitable
society where women have equal opportunities and meaningful participation in
PRIs. Their expertise, advocacy, and support are essential in challenging sociocultural
constraints, promoting gender equality, and empowering women to actively
contribute to local governance.
It is important to note that a
combination of these methods can be utilized in a holistic and integrated
approach. Social Workers should select method depending on the specific needs,
strengths, and goals of the individuals and communities being served. Social
workers must tailor their practices to the cultural context, maintain cultural
sensitivity, and work collaboratively with women to ensure their voices and
choices are respected throughout the process. |
||||||
Conclusion |
The sociocultural constraints on women's participation in
Panchayati Raj Institutions (PRIs) pose significant challenges to their
meaningful involvement in local governance. Deep-rooted patriarchal norms,
gender stereotypes, limited mobility, lack of education and awareness, unequal
resource distribution, social stigma, resistance, and the absence of a
supportive ecosystem collectively hinder women's active engagement in
PRIs.Efforts to address these constraints have been made through awareness
campaigns, gender sensitization programs, reservations for women in PRIs, and
capacity-building initiatives. These interventions aim to empower women,
challenge gender norms, and create a more inclusive and enabling environment
for their participation. However, overcoming these sociocultural barriers
requires sustained commitment and collaboration from multiple stakeholders.
Policymakers, civil society organizations, communities, and individuals must
work together to dismantle patriarchal structures, promote women's education,
provide necessary infrastructure, and foster an inclusive ecosystem that
supports and encourages women's involvement in PRIs.By addressing these
constraints, women can contribute their unique perspectives, skills, and
experiences to local governance, leading to more inclusive decision-making
processes and holistic development at the grassroots level. Achieving gender
parity and empowering women in PRIs will not only promote gender equality but
also strengthen democracy and foster sustainable development in India. |
||||||
References | 1. Afsar, R. (1999). The State of Urban Governance and
People’s Participation in Bangladesh. The Journal of Local Government, 28(2),
Dhaka: NILG. |