|
|||||||
Theoretical Approach to the Grasping of Geography |
|||||||
Paper Id :
18082 Submission Date :
2023-05-11 Acceptance Date :
2023-05-19 Publication Date :
2023-05-25
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. For verification of this paper, please visit on
http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/shinkhlala.php#8
|
|||||||
| |||||||
Abstract |
Geography is one of the few subjects
that can boast of being a part of both Humanities and Science. Geography is an
amalgamation of many subjects. You get to study a whole lot of other subjects
in Geography e.g., Geology, Atmospheric Science, Agriculture, Ecology et al.
Apart from the physical landscape, Geography also studies culture. The role of
Man in influencing his environment is integral to Geography. In a way here,
Geography borrows from Anthropology and Sociology. Trade and Commerce is also
studied in Geography whereby one gets to know the dynamics of movement of
geographical produce. The Subject might appear daunting but
once you make up your mind nothing is tough. Atleast it is not boring. Although
being a part of Humanities it inculcates scientific temper in one. That’s the
beauty of Geography. The best thing about geography - it is conceptual and use
of Maps which makes easy to understand concepts and memorizing content.
Geographical knowledge is important- 1. because some people do no think
Russia is in either Europe/Asia resprctively when Russia is in both. 2. for realising that continents are
merely landmasses. They are not the same as culture or countries. Africa is not
a country. Africa is not a singular culture. Africa is a landmass. There are
many countries within, at least one stretches between Africa and Asia (Egypt). 3. for understanding world affairs,
from trade route to geopolitics. 4. to know where people are from. 5. to know that Turkey is in Europe and
Asia, and Istanbul (Constantinople) is at massively important intersection
between continents and between major seas. 6. World history makes sense when one
udnerstands why the East was rich while the West was poor and how increased
cost of transit here led to the search for other routes and the Age of
Exploration (and subsequently the englightenment, jndustrial revolution etc.)
The paper deals with the various
theoretical approaches to the understanding of Geography. |
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Keywords | Geographical, Approaches, Grasping, Physical, Human, Systematic. | ||||||
Introduction | Geographical studies employ various approaches to understand the Earth's physical and human phenomena. Here are some common approaches in geography: Physical Geography: This approach focuses on the natural elements of the Earth, including landforms, climate, vegetation, soil, and ecosystems. Physical geography examines processes such as erosion, weathering, plate tectonics, and the distribution of natural resources. Human Geography: Human geography explores human activities, their spatial patterns, and their impact on the environment. It includes topics such as population distribution, migration, urbanization, cultural landscapes, economic activities, and political systems. Regional Geography: Regional geography studies specific regions, examining their unique characteristics, spatial patterns, and interactions. It analyzes the physical and human features of a particular area, including its environmental conditions, cultural practices, economic activities, and political dynamics. Geographic Information Systems (GIS): GIS involves the use of technology to collect, analyze, and visualize spatial data. It enables geographers to create maps, study patterns and relationships, and analyze complex geographic phenomena. As for the stages of thrust or focal points in geography studies, the discipline has evolved over time, and different geographic paradigms have emerged. While the specific stages can vary based on theoretical frameworks and individual interpretations, here are some broad stages of focus in geography: Environmental Determinism: In the early stages of geographic studies, there was a prominent focus on environmental determinism. This approach suggested that physical environment and climate largely determined human behavior and societal development. Possibilism: Later, the possibilism perspective emerged as a reaction to environmental determinism. It argued that while the environment influenced human activities, humans had the ability to adapt and modify their environment based on their cultural, technological, and economic choices. Humanistic Geography: Humanistic geography emphasized the subjective experiences and perceptions of individuals in relation to their environment. It focused on the study of sense of place, cultural landscapes, and the meanings attached to specific locations. Critical Geography: Critical geography challenged traditional approaches and examined the social, economic, and political power structures that influenced spatial patterns and inequalities. It analyzed issues such as globalization, capitalism, social justice, and the impacts of colonization. It's important to note that these stages represent general trends and are not exhaustive or mutually exclusive. Geography is a dynamic discipline, and contemporary geographic studies often combine elements from multiple approaches, integrating physical and human perspectives to gain a holistic understanding of the Earth and its complexities. |
||||||
Objective of study | To highlight the theoretical approach that helps in the understanding of Geography. |
||||||
Review of Literature |
‘Critical theory is a term coined by
Max Horkheimer in 1937 to describe the work of the Frankfurt School (Buchanan,
2010). From then on, its meaning and scope have begun to broaden gradually and
now it is an umbrella term mainly used in social sciences, humanities and art
studies. It sees the events, phenomena, developments and processes in social
world with/through critical lens not basing them on meta-narratives and
grand-theories which have firm ontological and epistemological foundations
(Crotty, 1998). Meta-narratives could be generally found in positivism, Marxist
theory or the Western-oriented Enlightenment. Critical theory and researches
tend to be found across all social disciplines blurring the discipline
boundaries as drawing on multiple sources. Critical theorists learned to
interpret the particular with an eye on the totality (Bronner, 2011). That’s,
theorist tries to see the particular in its totality and setting. Critical
theory does not mean to criticize everything or in Tyson’s terms critical
theory is not fault finding (Tyson, 2006) as its name may imply. It has
developed mostly in reaction to modernism, meta-narrative, economic determinism
in Marxist theory and foundationalism. It stands against foundationalist
ontology, epistemology and methodology. Critical theory can be seen as
precursor to postmodernism as Zuidervaart (2015) has suggested. Despite the
time span between the two, they share many similar characteristics such as
contextuality, historicity and theory-leadenness of any given phenomenon or
explanation. Critical theory dates back to 1930s and has developed over time
aiming to deal with institutions, culture and society through critical lens.
Currently, critical theory-based research designs and research paradigms
inspire a large number of books, articles especially in qualitative researches
due to their beneficial outcomes for the vulnerable, the poor and the othered
segments of society with which critical researches are mainly concerned.In the
study, firstly it was described critical theory and critical research
characteristics. Secondly, human geography and critical research relationships
covered. Thirdly, human geography courses in geography teaching departments in
Turkey explained in connection with critical theory. The relationships between
these courses, critical theory and critical research were tried to explore. The
study emphasized the importance of critical theory in courses in human
geography considering far-reaching effects of critical theory on humanities,
social sciences and art studies. Human geography has and should have close
connections with other disciplines and sub-disciplines drawing on multiple
theories, concepts and approaches.’[1] ‘Though Nordic geography could be
considered as a community of practice, it has certainly not developed in a
vacuum and there have been important theoretical and philosophical exchanges,
not only among geographers within the Nordic region but also with geographers
situated elsewhere. Particularly in the early history of institutionalised
Nordic geography the discipline was strongly influenced by German geography.
But later inspirations have also come from particularly French, British and
Anglophone North American geographers. Meanwhile, Nordic geographers of the
past and the present have occasionally made impressions well outside the Nordic
region.’[2] ‘Theory, in my view, is what defines an
academic discipline. When we study a particular geographical phenomenon, we can
go about describing it in great detail and accuracy, much like the heydays of
regional geography prior to the so-called ‘quantitative revolution’ in the
1960s (Barnes and Farish, 2006). Theory was not the core concern then in
regional geography; accurate and comprehensive description was. Equally, we can
re-present the pattern(s) and process(es) of this geographical phenomenon in
stylized models and theories that ‘abstract’ their essence from the empirical
details or ‘mess’, much like what the young Harvey (1969: 486) was advocating
as ‘controlled, consistent, and rational, explanation of events’. To Harvey
(1969: 46–47), this a priori reduction of explanation to variation in the laws
of mechanics is a ‘mechanical’ or ‘mechanistic’ explanation.’[3] ‘Marxist ideas had little influence in
human geography until the 1960s when a younger generation of geographers became
increasingly frustrated at the inability of contemporary geographical theory to
contribute to the pressing social problems of the day. Key issues, such as
racial tensions in US cities, the Vietnam War (symbolizing the imperialism of
US foreign policy), gender inequalities, and the rediscovery of poverty in
inner-city ghettos, were largely absent from geographical research, leading
David Harvey to call for a revolution in geographic thought: The quantitative
revolution has run its course, and diminishing marginal returns are apparently
setting in … There is an ecological problem, an urban problem, an international
trade problem, and yet we seem incapable of saying anything of depth or
profundity about any of them.’[4]
‘Geography is a discipline with a
diversity of subfields, including cartography and GIScience as well as human,
physical and nature-and-society geography. Despite the enduring debate on
whether geography should be an idiographic (aiming to produce
phenomenal/declarative knowledge) vs. nomothetic (aiming to develop general
principles and theories) discipline, geography has witnessed dramatic
specialization within its subfields over the past two decades. This
specialization might enable scholars to develop in-depth understandings and
techniques that better address the issues faced in respective subfields under
particular contexts or conditions. These specializations may lead to topical
overlap with scholars from other disciplines with whom they still differ by
their geographical imagination and approach. Thus, there is a need for
geographers to articulate general principles and analytical frameworks that are
held in common across the diverse subfields in geography to both better
articulate what is common to geography and how it is different from other
disciplines and approaches.’[5] |
||||||
Methodology | The study is designed on the basis of the secondary data available on the various sites of internet that provide research journals with quality research papers therein. The conclusion is drawn on the basis of the study of the approaches of Geography. |
||||||
Analysis | There are two main approaches to
geographical studies: Systematic approach studies a particular
phenomenon in detail, regardless of its location. For example, a geographer
using a systematic approach might study the distribution of earthquakes around
the world. Regional approach studies a specific
region of the world, and examines all of the different phenomena that occur in
that region. For example, a geographer using a regional approach might study
the geography of the Middle East. The stages of thrust of geography
studies are: 1. Descriptive geography was the
dominant approach in geography until the early 20th century. It focused on
describing the physical and human features of the Earth's surface. 2. Analytical geography emerged in the
early 20th century, and it focused on understanding the relationships between
different geographic phenomena. 3. Quantitative geography emerged in
the 1950s, and it used statistical methods to analyze geographic data. 4. Critical geography emerged in the
1970s, and it focused on the social and political dimensions of geography. 5. Humanistic geography emerged in the
1980s, and it focused on the human experience of place.· These are just some of the major
approaches and stages of thrust in geography studies. The field of geography is
constantly evolving, and new approaches and perspectives are being developed
all the time. In addition to the two main approaches mentioned above, there are
also a number of other approaches that are used in geography studies. Spatial analysis is the study of the
spatial patterns and relationships of geographic phenomena. GIS (Geographic
Information Systems) is a computer-based technology that is used to store,
analyze, and visualize geographic data. Remote sensing is the use of technology
to collect data about the Earth's surface from a distance. Geographic modeling
is the use of mathematical models to simulate geographic processes. These are just
a few of the many approaches that are used in geography studies. The field of
geography is a vast and complex one, and there is no single approach that can
be used to study all of the different aspects of the Earth's surface. Geography is one of the sciences where
everything connects. Geographers take a phenomenon and apply various methods to
find out how it affects the societal or natural systems. Take a forest for
example, what is a forest to you, a collection of species of plants and
animals, a place to go hunt in, a place where you relax, a place you maybe fear
as you are not familiar with it, or maybe you see forest as ecosystem service,
that provides all of the above and more, lumber, food, medicinal plants, safety
for animals, CO2 capture, hiking paths etc. Geographers look at mundane things and
place them in context. Geographers can for example look at the locations where
the malls are and find out through GIS research how much CO2 emissions are
produced by using those, and where should new one be built to minimise the
effect. Geographers study volcanoes, and in addition to the obvious physical
questions, they can ask how it has affected the local culture and life around
it.
Geographers study humor, the
differences in humor between places, and ages. How humor can shape our
worldview. |
||||||
Conclusion |
Studying geography gives us wider view of the world around us. Its systems, both natural and cultural are exposed, explained, and tied to other systems. Geography opened my eyes to the complexity of our world in a different way to any other subject. |
||||||
References | 1. https://www.quora.com/Is-geography-a-major-subject-of-the-humanities
2. https://www.quora.com/What-kind-of-a-person-studies-geography-What-does-a-geographer-do
3. https://www.quora.com/Most-students-think-that-geography-memorizes-the-names-and-locations-of-countries-cities-capitals-rivers-etc-But-geography-is-so-much-more-than-that-How-are-you-going-to-discuss-this-subject-engagingly
4. https://www.quora.com/Why-is-geography-a-unique-subject
5. https://www.quora.com/What-are-the-approaches-of-geographical-studies-What-are-the-stages-of-thrust-of-geography-studies
6. https://www.quora.com/How-does-geography-affect-population-distribution-Why-is-the-study-of-geography-important
7. https://www.quora.com/What-two-major-approaches-can-be-used-to-study-geography
8. https://www.quora.com/What-are-the-approaches-to-the-study-of-behavioral-geography |
||||||
Endnote | 1. Münür Bilgili-Critical Theory-Based Approaches in Geography Teaching Departments in Turkey, Journal of Education and Training Studies, Vol. 6, No. 2; February 2018 2. Peter Jakobsen, Erik Jönsson & Henrik Gutzon Larsen- Geographies and Theories of Geography: An Introduction, Socio-Spatial Theory in Nordic Geography pp 1–13, 31 May 2022 3. Henry Wai-chung Yeung- What kind of theory for what kind of human geography?, Dialogues in Human Geography, Volume 9, Issue 3, 2020 4. A. Cumbers- International Encyclopedia of Human Geography, 2009 5. Daniel Sui & Matthew Turner- General theories and principles in geography and GIScience: Moving beyond the idiographic and nomothetic dichotomy, Annals of GIS, Volume 28, 2022 - Issue 1: General Principles Analytical Frameworks in Geography/GIScience, Pages 1-4 |