P: ISSN No. 2394-0344 RNI No.  UPBIL/2016/67980 VOL.- VIII , ISSUE- VII October  - 2023
E: ISSN No. 2455-0817 Remarking An Analisation
Tradition and Transformation: Tagore's Institutions as Models of Sustainable Education
Paper Id :  18230   Submission Date :  2023-10-04   Acceptance Date :  2023-10-21   Publication Date :  2023-10-25
This is an open-access research paper/article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
For verification of this paper, please visit on http://www.socialresearchfoundation.com/remarking.php#8
Ayush Jaiwal
Senior Research Fellow
Department Of History & Archaeology
Maharshi Dayanand University
Rohtak,Haryana, India
Jaiveer S. Dhankhar
Professor And Head
Department Of History & Archaeology
Maharshi Dayanand University
Rohtak, Haryana, India
Abstract

The concept of Sustainable Development has become increasingly prominent over the last four decades, necessitating a reevaluation of traditional development models. This paper revisits the prescient ideas of Rabindranath Tagore, a 19th-century Indian polymath, whose work offers early insights into sustainable living. It examines how Tagore's educational philosophy integrates economic development with ecological consciousness and social responsibility, a concept he actualized through the establishment of progressive educational institutions like Visva-Bharati University. Through a comparative analysis of Tagore's written works and the pedagogical practices at these institutes, the paper elucidates the enduring relevance of his ideas in contemporary sustainability discourse. The research demonstrates that Tagore's holistic approach to education—encompassing local culture, environment, and self-awareness—prefigured key principles of modern sustainability and offers valuable lessons for integrating these into higher education. The findings suggest that Tagore's institutions serve as living models of sustainability, emphasizing the interconnectedness of humanity and nature, a concept deeply rooted in Indian Knowledge traditions but often sidelined in Western pedagogy. The paper argues that Tagore's vision, if more broadly adopted, has the potential to reshape educational practices towards more sustainable outcomes, advocating for a harmony with nature that counters the ecological destructiveness of unchecked economic development. 

Keywords Rabindranath Tagore, Visva-Bharati, Educational Philosophy, Shantiniketan, Indian Knowledge System, Education for Sustainable Development.
Introduction

The term ‘Sustainable Development’ first came into prominence in the World Conservation Strategy presented in 1980 by the International Union for the Conservation of Nature. But it was popularized and defined by the World Commission on the Environment and Development’s study Our Common Future (1987), known as Brundtland Report. Sustainable Development as the report suggests, seeks to meet the needs and aspirations of the present without compromising the ability of the future generation to meet their own needs1. This definition signifies the need for equity between and within generations to attain sustainability. It involves integrating economic, social, and environmental considerations into decision-making processes to ensure long-term well-being and prosperity2.

Objective of study

This research aspires to thoroughly explore the enduring contributions of Rabindranath Tagore to educational philosophy, emphasizing his sustainable and socially conscious approaches within educational frameworks. A primary objective is to analyze how Tagore's educational ideologies have been actualized in the institutions he established, notably Shantiniketan, and to evaluate their role in fostering sustainable practices. Furthermore, the study seeks to ascertain how modern higher education institutions might adopt Tagore's vision by integrating his ethos of sustainability and community engagement into their curricular and extracurricular activities. In addition, the research will probe into the effectiveness of Tagore's pedagogical techniques in bolstering the environmental, economic, and social aspects of well-being in educational practice and policy. Integrating these analyses, the research endeavors to contribute to the academic discourse on sustainable development within education, positioning Tagore's educational approach as an archetypal example for current and future educational frameworks.

Review of Literature

Education for sustainable development (ESD) plays a crucial role in promoting sustainable development by equipping individuals with the knowledge, skills, and values needed to address global challenges and create a more sustainable future3. Agenda 21 (Earth Summit, 1992) was the first international document that identified education as an essential tool for achieving sustainable development. Education for Sustainable Development involves preparing students by imparting the necessary knowledge, skills, and traits that enable them to contribute to and thrive in a manner that ensures the preservation of environmental, social, and economic stability for current and upcoming generations. ESD involves incorporating key sustainable development issues, such as climate change, biodiversity, poverty reduction, and sustainable consumption, into teaching and learning4. It encompasses a participatory vision of sustainability, enabling conditions for sustainability, competences for sustainability transformation, pedagogies and learning strategies for ESD, and monitoring and evaluation of ESD competences5. ESD aims to empower individuals to make informed decisions and take responsible actions that contribute to a more sustainable society6. Higher education institutions (HEIs) have increasingly recognized the importance of ESD and have been incorporating it into their systems, including education, research, campus operations, community outreach, and assessment and reporting7. HEIs play a crucial role in preparing future leaders, professionals, and citizens who can contribute to sustainable development8. They have the potential to foster transformative learning, which involves challenging existing beliefs and values and promoting critical thinking and reflection9. Transformative leadership practices of educational supervisors can also contribute to the sustainable professional development of students10. However, there are challenges in implementing ESD in higher education. The concept of sustainability is often contested, and there is a lack of clarity between education about sustainable development and education for sustainable development11. The term "sustainability" is sometimes used interchangeably with "green" or "environmentally friendly" in the literature12. There is also a need to overcome the assumption that environmental science is the only place for studies about sustainable development13. Additionally, there is a compressed space for universities and staff to contribute to sustainable development14. Institutions of higher learning stand as hubs for the dissemination of knowledge, cultivation of intellectual prowess, and conduits for teaching and research. Their operations and very being are intrinsically tied to societal responsibility, both directly and indirectly, as they are the nurturing grounds for the workforce of tomorrow. It falls within the social duties of these educational institutions to champion and implement sustainability within their confines and in their extended environments. Engaging with local communities to enhance knowledge application benefits not just the communities themselves, but also enriches the scholarly activities of the higher education institution15. Visva-Bharati founded by Rabindranath Tagore is a torchbearer for sustainable practices and in the promotion of sustainable development through education.  

Methodology

In conducting this historical research, the methodology employed was multifaceted and designed to gather a comprehensive understanding of Rabindranath Tagore’s educational philosophy and its sustainability dimensions. Archival analysis was the cornerstone of this study, where various historical documents, personal correspondences, educational treatises written by Tagore, and records from the institutions he founded were meticulously examined. These documents were sourced from the libraries of Shantiniketan and Visva-Bharati University, as well as from national archives and databases housing collections of Tagore’s works. In-depth literature reviews were conducted to place Tagore’s educational practices within the broader context of sustainability in education. This involved examining both contemporary and retrospective critiques, interpretations, and discussions surrounding Tagore’s pedagogical approach. Secondary sources included academic journals, historical texts, and previous studies on the topic were analysed. To gain a deeper insight into the implementation of Tagore’s educational philosophy, the study also retrospectively analyzed the curriculum, teaching methodologies and campus initiatives at Shantiniketan and related institutions. A qualitative approach guided the analysis of the collected data. Textual analysis techniques were applied to Tagore’s writings to extract themes related to sustainable development and educational philosophy. Throughout this process, efforts were made to maintain historical accuracy and interpretive neutrality, ensuring that Tagore’s views were represented authentically and that the historical context of his work was preserved. The insights garnered from this historical inquiry were synthesized to formulate a narrative that connects Tagore’s legacy with contemporary educational challenges and opportunities. Particular emphasis was placed on uncovering the influences of traditional knowledge traditions within Rabindranath Tagore’s educational and environmental ideas. The significance of elucidating these traditional influences was twofold: firstly, to provide a richer, more nuanced understanding of Tagore’s philosophy, and secondly, to reveal the relevance and potential applicability of traditional knowledge in contemporary sustainable education practices.

Analysis

Tagore’s Education Philosophy

Rabindranath Tagore, a distinguished 20th century Indian poet, philosopher, educator, and social activist, is renowned globally for his significant contributions to education. Often referred to as 'Gurudev', Tagore was deeply cognizant of the prevailing socio-economic challenges and believed in addressing them through education. Instead of a single comprehensive work on education, his insights and perspectives are dispersed across various essays, letters, and speeches he gave both in India and internationally. Additionally, he is celebrated as a pivotal environmental thinker, with his literary works reflecting his profound love and commitment to nature. Tagore's educational philosophy is centered on three main ideas: active communion with nature and mankind, freedom, and creative self-expression16. He believed that modern classroom education was akin to "parrot's training," where students are confined and forced to consume textbook pages, resulting in an artificial and disconnected learning experience17. He feels that education has "been separated from life's streams and confined within the four walls of the classroom, becoming artificial and losing its value." Tagore argued that education should be closely related to one's environment, culture, morals, and personal growth18. Tagore's emphasis on active communion with nature and mankind aligns with his belief in the importance of a curriculum that reflects the love of nature and the preservation of a healthy environment for future generations19. He saw education as a means to promote international cooperation, starting with the educational field. This perspective highlights the relevance of Tagore's vision of education in today's globalized world. Freedom was another key aspect of Tagore's educational philosophy. He believed in the freedom of the individual to explore and express themselves creatively. This aligns with his view that each individual has a unique manifestation of the Creator within them, which can foster unity not only among humans but also with nature20. Tagore's emphasis on freedom in education challenges contemporary pedagogues to consider the effects of teaching methods and regimes on the development of individuals21. Tagore's educational philosophy also resonates with the idea of holistic education, which encompasses the heart and mind of the child. He emphasized the close relationship between students and nature, as well as their relationships with teachers and peers. This holistic approach recognizes the importance of nurturing both intellectual and emotional growth in students. Tagore's ideas continue to be relevant in today's educational landscape, as they challenge conventional approaches and advocate for a more holistic and meaningful learning experience. Tagore's vision of an ideal educational institution was centered on the concept of a "Tapovan," a place situated in natural surroundings where learning could flourish22. He believed that being in close proximity to nature would enhance the learning experience for students. This aligns with the idea that the educational environment plays a crucial role in shaping students' perceptions and experiences23. In terms of discipline, Tagore advocated for giving students autonomy to manage their own affairs, which would foster a sense of responsibility and self-reliance24. This approach is in contrast to the conventional methods of education that rely on strict discipline and control. Tagore believed that students should be trusted to take charge of their own learning and personal development. Tagore's envisioned curriculum was holistic, encompassing scientific, aesthetic, creative, spiritual, and vocational elements25. He rejected the overemphasis on rote learning and examinations, advocating for a more practical and experiential approach to teaching. This aligns with the idea that a well-rounded education should go beyond academic knowledge and include the development of various skills and abilities. Furthermore, Tagore emphasized the role of the teacher in the educational journey of a student. He believed that a teacher should not simply be a transmitter of knowledge, but a guide who nurtures and inspires26. Additionally, he believed that the teacher's attitude played a pivotal role in the educational journey of a student. Tagore's emphasis on the teacher-student relationship and the teacher's attitude towards teaching is also supported by research that highlights the importance of positive teacher-student interactions27. His ideas align with current research on the importance of the educational environment, student autonomy, experiential learning, and positive teacher-student interactions. By incorporating these elements, Tagore aimed to create an educational system that nurtured the overall development of students and prepared them for a well-rounded and meaningful life.

Tagore on Sustainable Development

Tagore's perspective on sustainable development is evident in his emphasis on rural revitalization and self-reliance in villages. He believed that villages should not rely on external aid for their sustenance and should instead strive for self-sufficiency28. Tagore championed the idea that rural communities, guided by scientific knowledge and collaborative efforts, should take responsibility for their own development initiatives. He envisioned a society where villages and urban areas would form strong bonds based on mutual trust and respect, working together towards economic progress and poverty alleviation29. Tagore's focus on rural revitalization aligns with the principles of sustainable development, which emphasize the enhancement of life quality and the genuine growth of individual freedoms, rather than just economic expansion. He recognized that the majority of India's population resides in rural areas and prioritized their development and well-being. By promoting self-reliance and autonomy in villages, Tagore aimed to create a society devoid of poverty, starvation, and exploitation30.  Tagore's perspective on sustainable development also resonates with modern development theorists who emphasize the importance of inclusive and participatory approaches to development. He believed that development initiatives should be guided by the collective efforts and innovative abilities of villagers, fostering a sense of unity and shared responsibility. This approach aligns with the principles of sustainable development, which emphasize the importance of social inclusion, community participation, and collaboration. Tagore drew many of his conclusions about development from the Upanishads. He believed that God was present in both nature and humans, and that nature and human life were interconnected and essential components of a unified whole31. Tagore cautioned against disturbing the natural balance in an attempt to satisfy our own desires, emphasizing the importance of preserving the delicate harmony between humans and the environment32. He strongly opposed development initiatives that disregarded human welfare, the natural world, and the balance between humans and the environment, viewing them as self-defeating. Tagore believed that those who recklessly destroyed trees were ultimately digging their own graves33. Tagore's philosophy of education also reflected his views on the interconnectedness of nature and humanity. He saw nature as a manifestation of the Creator, Brahma, and believed that nature revealed the presence of God more clearly than humans34. This perspective highlights Tagore's deep reverence for the natural world and his belief in its inherent value. Furthermore, Tagore's philosophy emphasized the unity of all individuals and their connection to God. He believed that every individual was an expression of God and therefore deserved to be loved and respected35. This perspective underscores Tagore's belief in the inherent worth and dignity of every human being.

Visva-Bharati

Visva-Bharati University, founded by Rabindranath Tagore in 1921, aims to establish a relationship between East and West and promote inter-cultural and inter-social amity and understanding36. The university originated from the Santiniketan Ashram, which was initially a school called Ashram Vidyalaya. Tagore envisioned Visva-Bharati as a place where the world meets, symbolized by the university's motto "Yatra Visvam bhavati ekamidam". The activities of Visva-Bharati encompass cultural and educational endeavors, rural reconstruction work, community service, and the development of village crafts and industries37.  Tagore's vision for Visva-Bharati was to fulfill the highest mission of the present age, which is the unification of mankind. Through this university, he sought to bridge the gap between the East and the West and foster mutual understanding and harmony. The establishment of Cheena-Bhavan (China House) at Visva-Bharati and the introduction of Chinese studies in India were outcomes of Tagore's trip to China. This highlights the university's commitment to promoting global engagement and cultural exchange. Visva-Bharati University has played a significant role in the development of education and libraries in the surrounding areas38. Tagore himself was closely involved in the establishment of rural and institutional libraries in the Santiniketan Sriniketan region, which is the birthplace of Visva-Bharati. This demonstrates the university's commitment to intellectual growth and knowledge dissemination.  Overall, Visva-Bharati University represents Tagore's vision of unifying mankind and fostering harmony among different cultures and societies.

Activities at Visva-Bharati University

1. Palli-Samgathana Vibhaga (earlier known as IRR) is working with nearby villages to make them self reliant and encouraging revival of village arts and crafts.

2. Rural Extension Centre (REC), Dept of Adult, Continuing Education and Extension, is actively working towards improving the conditions of nearby communities and villages. It has also set up rural libraries and mobile literacy services.

3. Visva-Bharati established Palli-Shiksha Bhavana Institute of Agriculture in 1963, promoting agriculture and farming and imparting knowledge to nearby villages.

4. Silpa Sadan, Centre of Rural Craft Technology and Design, works towards promotion of rural crafts and industries.

5. Department of Social Work engages the community on various issues, including disabilities, health and hygiene, helping senior citizens, awareness of fatal diseases and vaccinations. They also work against child marriage and other social evils.

6. Department of Education puts stress on community engagement and social responsibility. Students teach children in village schools as part of their curriculum.

7. The University has adopted more than 48 villages and is working towards their welfare.

8. Visva-Bharati is balancing the modern educational practices of competition in its academic endeavors, while also abiding by Tagore’s ideals.

9. There are many festivals and cultural events started by Tagore, which involved the social, cultural, economic and sustainable development of the people in Santiniketan and its surrounding areas keeping in mind the principles of humanism, sustainability, self-reliance and urban-rural cooperation. 

10. The events work to spread awareness on many issues relevant to the local areas including water conservation, soil fertility, agricultural conservation, tree plantation, use of bio-fertilizers, animal husbandry and village handicrafts.

11. Some of these festivals and events are Basant Utsav, Poush Mela, Magh Mela, Nandan Mela, Sona Jhuri Mela or Kjoai Mela or Sonibar haat, Brikharopana Utsav, Halakarshan etc.

12. Some other sustainable practices at Visva-Bharati include Gandhi Puniyah, Shilpotsav, Sabujayan, Samavartana, Varsha-Shesh etc.

Conclusion

Tagore’s views on economic development and its effects on the Nature, shows that he was amongst the earliest thinkers on sustainable living, much before the modern development thinkers. His ideas in education were way ahead of his times and he put them into practice and created world class institutions like Visva-Bharati, which continue to walk on the great path started by Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore. Tagore’s vision transcends the conventional confines of education, seeking to nurture the whole person in a dynamic interaction with the environment, community, and culture. His insistence on freedom of intellect and the cultivation of creativity and critical thinking aligns with modern educational imperatives that are essential for fostering sustainable development. Through this lens, education is not just a tool for personal enlightenment but also a means for social transformation—a transformative process that echoes the core principles of sustainable development goals (SDGs). In the face of today's global challenges, such as climate change, resource depletion, and social inequality, Tagore's education philosophy provides a blueprint for creating more resilient and adaptable learners. His advocacy for educational experiences that are deeply rooted in one’s immediate environment yet open to the diverse influences of a globalizing world reflects the balance needed to navigate the complexities of the 21st century. As we continue to strive towards achieving sustainable development, Tagore's integrative educational approach serves as a beacon of inspiration. It compels us to rethink and re-imagine our educational systems not merely as pathways to employment but as crucibles for nurturing responsible global citizens capable of leading the charge towards a more just, sustainable, and equitable world. Thus, Rabindranath Tagore's educational philosophy, with its timeless relevance, continues to be an indispensable ally. 

Acknowledgement Researcher is grateful to the University Grants Commission for the award of the Senior Research Fellowship.
References

1. Vos, R. O. (2007). Defining sustainability: a conceptual orientation. Journal of Chemical Technology & Biotechnology: International Research in Process, Environmental & Clean Technology82(4), 334-339.

2. Ibid.

3. Grosseck, G., Țîru, L. G., & Bran, R. A. (2019). Education for sustainable development: Evolution and perspectives: A bibliometric review of research, 1992–2018. Sustainability11(21), 6136.

4. Sund, P., & Gericke, N. (2020). Teaching contributions from secondary school subject areas to education for sustainable development–a comparative study of science, social science and language teachers. Environmental Education Research26(6), 772-794.

5. Kioupi, V., & Voulvoulis, N. (2019). Education for sustainable development: A systemic framework for connecting the SDGs to educational outcomes. Sustainability11(21), 6104.

6. Pouratashi, M. (2021). The Influence of Formal and Informal Education on Students’ Sustainable Development Skills, a Study in Iran. Zagreb International Review of Economics & Business24(2), 25-35.

7. Lozano, R., Ceulemans, K., Alonso-Almeida, M., Huisingh, D., Lozano, F. J., Waas, T., ... & Hugé, J. (2015). A review of commitment and implementation of sustainable development in higher education: results from a worldwide survey. Journal of cleaner production108, 1-18.

8. Molokova, E. (2021). Higher education as a sustainable development tool. In E3S Web of Conferences (Vol. 291, p. 05040). EDP Sciences.

9. Grosseck, G., Țîru, L. G., & Bran, R. A. (2019). Education for sustainable development: Evolution and perspectives: A bibliometric review of research, 1992–2018. Sustainability11(21), 6136.

10. Al-Matroushi, S., & Al-Kiyumi, M. (2022). Impact of Transformative Leadership Practices of Educational Supervisors on the Sustainable Professional Development of Mathematics Teachers.

11. Thomas, I. (2004). Sustainability in tertiary curricula: what is stopping it happening?. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education5(1), 33-47.

12. Vukić, T., Jovanović, M., & Todorović, D. (2021). Goals and objectives of education for sustainable development as modern curriculum innovation in Serbia, Montenegro and Croatia. Facta Universitatis, Series: Philosophy, Sociology, Psychology and History, 055-072.

13. Sibbel, A. (2009). Pathways towards sustainability through higher education. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education10(1), 68-82.

14. Maia, C., & Tristan, M. (2021). Higher education and the Sustainable Development Goals. Higher Education81(1), 1-8.

15. Anand, S. (2021). Tagore, social responsibility and higher education in India. In Socially Responsible Higher Education (pp. 203-215). Brill.

16. Switala, A. (2021). The Self-Orientalization of Polish Music Education. Nordic Journal of Comparative and International Education (NJCIE)5(2), 37-50.

17. Sun, Y. (2017). Revisiting Tagore’s Philosophy of Education: A Perspective on Social Sustainability and Human Development. American International Journal of Humanities and Social Science3(5), 12-17.

18. Switala, A. (2021). The Self-Orientalization of Polish Music Education. Nordic Journal of Comparative and International Education (NJCIE)5(2), 37-50.

19. Samuel, F. A. (2010). Tagore's vision of international education: Relevance and implications for today. In The Educational Forum (Vol. 74, No. 4, pp. 347-356). Taylor & Francis Group.

20. Bhattacharjee, S. (2014). Relevance of Tagore’s philosophy of education in postmodern era-a conceptual analysis. OSR Journal of Humanities and Social Science (IOSR-JHSS). 19, 34-40.

21. Lesar, I. (2015). The role of the arts in Tagore’s Concept of Schooling. CEPS Journal5(3), 111-128.

22. Jamshed, M. (2023). Revisiting the relevance of Tagore’s concept of education and his vision of cosmopolitan existence with special reference to “The Home and The World”. Journal of Educational and Social Research, 13(1), 283.

23. Kohli, V., & Dhaliwal, U. (2013). Medical students’ perception of the educational environment in a medical college in India: a cross-sectional study using the Dundee Ready Education Environment questionnaire. J educ eval health prof10(5), 10.

24. Mayya, S. S., & Roff, S. U. E. (2004). Students′ perceptions of educational environment: a comparison of academic achievers and under-achievers at kasturba medical college, India. Education for health17(3), 280-291.

25. Akshaya, E. (2022). Contribution of Indian philosophers in early childhood care and education during the pre-independence period. education, 2.

26. Samuel, F. A. (2010). Tagore's vision of international education: Relevance and implications for today. In The Educational Forum (Vol. 74, No. 4, pp. 347-356). Taylor & Francis Group.

27. Livingston, K. (2014). Teacher educators: Hidden professionals?. European Journal of Education49(2), 218-232.

28. Rachanabali, R. (2004). Collected Works of Rabindranath Tagore. Calcutta: Viswa Bharati, Ashwin.

29. Ibid.

30. Sarkar, S. & Ghosh, C. (2015). Environment and Development: A Visit to the World of Tagore. International Journal of Inclusive Development. 1(2). 23-27

31. Bhattacharjee, S. (2014). Relevance of Tagore’s philosophy of education in postmodern era-a conceptual analysis. OSR Journal of Humanities and Social Science (IOSR-JHSS). 19, 34-40.

32. Rachanabali, R. (2004). Collected Works of Rabindranath Tagore. Calcutta: Viswa Bharati, Ashwin.

33. Bhattacharjee, S. (2014). Relevance of Tagore’s philosophy of education in postmodern era-a conceptual analysis. OSR Journal of Humanities and Social Science (IOSR-JHSS). 19, 34-40.

24. Ibid.

35. Sen, S. (2023). The Melody of Universalism: Political Thought in Rabindra Sangeet. Society and Culture in South Asia9(1), 104-127.

36. Krishnapriya, T. K., & Rani, P. (2022). The Parrot’s Training in the pandemic: fallacies in India’s educational response to COVID-19. Asia Pacific Education Review23(2), 285-296.

37. Ibid.

38. Das, A. K. (2015). Legacy of the Bengal Renaissance in public library development in India. IFLA journal41(4), 370-380.